329 IAC 1 — ARTICLE 1. GENERAL PROVISIONS

TITLE 329 OFFICE OF LAND QUALITY NOTE: Under P.L.133-2012, SECTION 72, the statutory authority to adopt these rules has been transferred to the Environmental Rules Board to be administered and implemented by the Solid Waste Management Division of the Department of Environmental Management, effective January 1, 2013.

NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.

ARTICLE 1. GENERAL PROVISIONS

Rule 1

329 IAC 1-1-1 329 IAC 1-1-1 Applicability of rule

Rule 1. Provisions Applicable Throughout Title 329

329 IAC 1-1-1 Applicability of rule

Authority: IC 13-14-8; IC 13-19-3

Affected: IC 13-19-3

Sec. 1. This rule ( 329 IAC 1-1) is applicable to all of Title 329 IAC.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-1-1 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed May 31, 1988, 2:42 p.m.: 11 IR 3199; readopted filed Sep 7, 2001, 1:35 p.m.: 25 IR 233; readopted filed May 27, 2020, 9:00 a.m.: 20200624-IR-329200188BFA; readopted filed Oct 16, 2024, 11:58 a.m.: 20241113-IR- 329230812RFA)

329 IAC 1-1-2 329 IAC 1-1-2 Severability

329 IAC 1-1-2 Severability

Authority: IC 13-14-8;IC 13-19-3

Affected: IC 13-19-3

Sec. 2. If any provision of these rules ( 329 IAC) or the application thereof to any person or circumstances is held invalid, the invalidity shall not affect any other provision or application of these rules ( 329 IAC) which can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-1-2 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed May 31, 1988, 2:42 p.m.: 11 IR 3200; readopted filed Sep 7, 2001, 1:35 p.m.: 25 IR 233; readopted filed May 27, 2020, 9:00 a.m.: 20200624-IR-329200188BFA; readopted filed Oct 16, 2024, 11:58 a.m.: 20241113-IR-329230812RFA)

329 IAC 1-1-3 329 IAC 1-1-3 Savings clause

329 IAC 1-1-3 Savings clause

Authority: IC 13-14-8; IC 13-19-3

Affected: IC 13-19-3

Sec. 3. The repeal and reenactment in this Title ( 329 IAC) of any rule previously the responsibility of the Solid Waste Management Board, the Environmental Management Board, or the Stream Pollution Control Board shall not have the effect to release or extinguish any penalty or forfeiture incurred under the same, and such previous rule shall be treated as still remaining on in force for the purpose of sustaining any proper action, or prosecution for the enforcement of such penalty, forfeiture or liability.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-1-3 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed May 31, 1988, 2:42 p.m.: 11 IR 3200; readopted filed Sep 7, 2001, 1:35 p.m.: 25 IR 233; readopted filed May 27, 2020, 9:00 a.m.: 20200624-IR-329200188BFA; readopted filed Oct 16, 2024, 11:58 a.m.: 20241113-IR- 329230812RFA)

329 IAC 1-1-4 329 IAC 1-1-4 Reference to federal acts

329 IAC 1-1-4 Reference to federal acts

Authority: IC 13-14-8; IC 13-19-3

Affected: IC 13-19-3

Sec. 4. (a) Unless otherwise indicated, references in this title to the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) mean the Solid Waste Disposal Act, as amended by the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act of 1976, as amended, by the Hazardous and Solid Waste Amendments of 1984, as amended, 42 U.S.C. §6901, et seq.

(b) Unless otherwise indicated, references in this title to the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA) mean the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act of 1980, as amended by the Superfund Amendments and Reauthorization Act of 1986, as amended, 42 U.S.C. §9601, et seq.

(c) Unless otherwise indicated, references in this title to the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) mean the Toxic Substances Control Act as amended by the Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act of 1986 and the Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act, as amended, 15 U.S.C. §2601 et seq.

(d) Unless otherwise indicated, references in this title to the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) mean the July 1, 2017, version.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-1-4 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed May 31, 1988, 2:42 p.m.: 11 IR 3200; readopted filed Sep 7, 2001, 1:35 p.m.: 25 IR 233; errata filed Feb 19, 2018, 10:06 a.m.: 20180228-IR-329180109ACA; filed Apr 24, 2020, 4:48 p.m.: 20200506-IR-329190411FRA, eff Apr 24, 2020, see Executive Order 20-15, posted at 20200422-IR-GOV200234EOA; readopted filed May 27, 2020, 9:00 a.m.: 20200624-IR-329200188BFA; readopted filed Oct 16, 2024, 11:58 a.m.: 20241113-IR- 329230812RFA)

Rule 2

329 IAC 1-2-1 329 IAC 1-2-1 Applicability

Rule 2. Restrictive Covenants

329 IAC 1-2-1 Applicability

Authority: IC 13-14-2-9; IC 13-25-4-1; IC 13-25-4-2

Affected: IC 13-11-2-193.5; IC 13-14-2-9; IC 13-23; IC 13-24; IC 13-25-4; IC 13-25-5

Sec. 1. This rule applies to the owner of a property:

(1) that is subject to a restrictive covenant, as defined in IC 13-11-2-193.5, created in connection with a remediation project conducted under:

(A) IC 13-23;

(B) IC 13-24;

(C) IC 13-25-4; or

(D) IC 13-25-5; and

(2) for which the owner seeks approval from the department to:

(A) modify a restriction or obligation; or

(B) terminate a restrictive covenant.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-2-1 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed Apr 28, 2016, 3:41 p.m.: 20160525-IR- 329140254FRA; readopted filed Jun 8, 2022, 11:40 a.m.: 20220706-IR-329220122BFA; readopted filed Oct 16, 2024, 11:58 a.m.: 20241113-IR-329230812RFA)

329 IAC 1-2-2 329 IAC 1-2-2 Definitions

329 IAC 1-2-2 Definitions

Authority: IC 13-14-2-9; IC 13-25-4-1; IC 13-25-4-2

Affected: IC 13-11-2; IC 13-14-2-9

Sec. 2. (a) In addition to the definitions in IC 13-11-2, the definitions in this section apply throughout this rule.

(b) "Applicant" means a person who applies for a modification or termination of a restrictive covenant.

(c) "Modification" means any amendment to a restrictive covenant subject to this rule that results in a remaining restriction or obligation to the owner of the property.

(d) "Owner" means the owner of real property subject to a restrictive covenant.

(e) "Termination" means the expiration of the restrictive covenant and cessation of all terms of the restrictive covenant.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-2-2 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed Apr 28, 2016, 3:41 p.m.: 20160525-IR- 329140254FRA; readopted filed Jun 8, 2022, 11:40 a.m.: 20220706-IR-329220122BFA; readopted filed Oct 16, 2024, 11:58 a.m.: 20241113-IR-329230812RFA)

329 IAC 1-2-3 329 IAC 1-2-3 General provisions

329 IAC 1-2-3 General provisions

Authority: IC 13-14-2-9; IC 13-25-4-1; IC 13-25-4-2

Affected: IC 13-14-2-9

Sec. 3. An owner may request a modification or termination in accordance with IC 13-14-2-9 if:

(1) there is a change in conditions or advancement in science or technology that would permit a modification; and

(2) the modification of the conditions and restrictions imposed by the restrictive covenant would not increase the potential hazards to human health or the environment.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-2-3 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed Apr 28, 2016, 3:41 p.m.: 20160525-IR- 329140254FRA; readopted filed Jun 8, 2022, 11:40 a.m.: 20220706-IR-329220122BFA; readopted filed Oct 16, 2024, 11:58 a.m.: 20241113-IR-329230812RFA)

329 IAC 1-2-4 329 IAC 1-2-4 Modification or termination application

329 IAC 1-2-4 Modification or termination application

Authority: IC 13-14-2-9; IC 13-25-4-1; IC 13-25-4-2

Affected: IC 13-14-2-9

Sec. 4. (a) An application for modification or termination of a restrictive covenant must be submitted to the commissioner on forms provided by the department. To be considered complete, the following information must be included:

(1) A copy of the proposed modification or termination.

(2) An explanation of the change in condition or advancement of science and technology that permits the modification or termination.

(3) Third party contact information based on:

(A) required approvals from the original restrictive covenant; or

(B) approval required by a court action.

(4) A copy of written approval for the requested modification or termination from:

(A) the property owner, if different than the applicant; and

(B) any third party as required by:

(i) the original restrictive covenant; or

(ii) a court action.

(b) In accordance with IC 13-14-2-9(c), the commissioner may request additional information to make a determination on the modification or termination request.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-2-4 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed Apr 28, 2016, 3:41 p.m.: 20160525-IR-329140254FRA; readopted filed Jun 8, 2022, 11:40 a.m.: 20220706-IR-329220122BFA; readopted filed Oct 16, 2024, 11:58 a.m.: 20241113-IR-329230812RFA)

329 IAC 1-2-5 329 IAC 1-2-5 Action on an application

329 IAC 1-2-5 Action on an application

Authority: IC 13-14-2-9; IC 13-25-4-1; IC 13-25-4-2

Affected: IC 13-14-2-9

Sec. 5. (a) The commissioner shall approve a request for modification or termination of a restrictive covenant if the commissioner determines that the modification or termination meets the requirements of:

(1) IC 13-14-2-9; and

(2) this rule.

(b) The commissioner may authorize the filing of a supplemental recording to reflect an approved modification or termination of a restrictive covenant pursuant to IC 13-14-2-9(c). A supplemental recording must comply with section 6 of this rule.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-2-5 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed Apr 28, 2016, 3:41 p.m.: 20160525-IR- 329140254FRA; readopted filed Jun 8, 2022, 11:40 a.m.: 20220706-IR-329220122BFA; readopted filed Oct 16, 2024, 11:58 a.m.: 20241113-IR-329230812RFA)

329 IAC 1-2-6 329 IAC 1-2-6 Submittal of supplemental recording

329 IAC 1-2-6 Submittal of supplemental recording

Authority: IC 13-14-2-9; IC 13-25-4-1; IC 13-25-4-2

Affected: IC 13-14-2-9

Sec. 6. (a) All restrictive covenant modifications and terminations must be recorded in the same manner and with the same county recorder as the original restrictive covenant.

(b) The owner shall provide a copy of the supplemental recording to the department within thirty (30) days of the recordation.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-2-6 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed Apr 28, 2016, 3:41 p.m.: 20160525-IR- 329140254FRA; readopted filed Jun 8, 2022, 11:40 a.m.: 20220706-IR-329220122BFA; readopted filed Oct 16, 2024, 11:58 a.m.: 20241113-IR-329230812RFA)

329 IAC 1-2-7 329 IAC 1-2-7 Cost recovery

329 IAC 1-2-7 Cost recovery

Authority: IC 13-14-2-9; IC 13-25-4-1; IC 13-25-4-2

Affected: IC 13-14-2-6; IC 13-14-2-9

Sec. 7. (a) In accordance with IC 13-14-2-9(d), the applicant shall reimburse the department for the administrative and personnel expenses incurred by the department in evaluating a proposed modification or termination of a restrictive covenant under this rule.

(b) Administrative expenses must include any expense to the department related to the review of the modification or termination request that would not have otherwise been incurred by the department.

(c) The department shall charge personnel expenses at seventy-five (75) dollars per hour of time a department employee expends in evaluating the proposed modification or termination request.

(d) The department shall send an invoice to the owner for personnel and administrative costs to the department.

(e) Failure to reimburse the department for expenses incurred by the department in evaluating a proposed modification or termination of a restrictive covenant under this rule may result in:

(1) denial of the modification or termination; or

(2) legal action under IC 13-14-2-6.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-2-7 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed Apr 28, 2016, 3:41 p.m.: 20160525-IR- 329140254FRA; readopted filed Jun 8, 2022, 11:40 a.m.: 20220706-IR-329220122BFA; readopted filed Oct 16, 2024, 11:58 a.m.: 20241113-IR-329230812RFA)

Rule 3

329 IAC 1-3-1 329 IAC 1-3-1 General provisions

Rule 3. Civil Penalties

329 IAC 1-3-1 General provisions

Authority: IC 4-22-2; IC 13-14-9; IC 13-30-4-1

Affected: IC 13-23-14-2; IC 13-23-14-3; IC 13-30-4

Sec. 1. (a) The department shall assess civil penalties consistent with this rule when imposing civil penalties as provided under IC 13-30-4.

(b) A civil penalty is the figure resulting from the following calculation:

(1) The base civil penalty is determined dependent on the severity and duration of the violation as described in section 3 of this rule.

(2) The base civil penalty is adjusted for special factors and circumstances as described in section 4 of this rule.

(3) The economic benefit of noncompliance is considered and added as described in section 5 of this rule.

(c) In situations where several violations have occurred, the following applies:

(1) Separate violations may be grouped for the purpose of applying this rule.

(2) Each violation or group of violations is considered as a separate violation for the purpose of calculating a civil penalty if it results from independent acts or compliance problems and is distinguishable from any other violation cited in the same notice of violation.

(3) The total civil penalty assessed in an enforcement case is the sum of all penalties for multiple violations or groups of violations, as calculated under this rule.

(d) Relevant parts of this rule are applied in conjunction with 329 IAC 9-11 to calculate penalties for violations set forth in IC 13-23-14-2 and IC 13-23-14-3.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-3-1 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed Nov 18, 2024, 5:00 p.m.: 20241218-IR-329240048FRA)

329 IAC 1-3-2 329 IAC 1-3-2 Definitions

329 IAC 1-3-2 Definitions

Authority: IC 4-22-2; IC 13-14-9; IC 13-30-4-1

Affected: IC 13-30-3-3; IC 13-30-4

Sec. 2. The following definitions apply to this rule:

(1) "Avoided costs" means expenditures that are nullified by the violator's failure to comply and never incurred. The economic benefit of avoided costs equals the cost of complying with the requirement from the time of violation to compliance, less any tax savings.

(2) "Delayed costs" means expenditures that have been deferred by a violator by failing to comply with the requirements. Delayed costs are the equivalent of capital costs. The economic benefit for delayed costs includes the amount of interest on the unspent money that reasonably was able to be earned by the violator during noncompliance.

(3) "Notice of violation" or "NOV" means the notice issued by the department to an alleged violator under IC 13-30-3-3 to initiate a formal enforcement action.

(4) "Prior violation" means an act or omission for which the violator has previously been given written notification, however informal, that the department or U.S. EPA believes a violation exists, or for which an enforcement response from the department or U.S. EPA has occurred, including a:

(A) NOV;

(B) warning or violation letter;

(C) complaint;

(D) consent agreement; or

(E) final order.

(5) "Qualified supplemental environmental project" means an environmentally beneficial project that improves, protects, or reduces risks to public health or the environment, and that a regulated entity agrees to undertake in further settlement of an enforcement action, but that the regulated entity is not otherwise legally required to perform.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-3-2 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed Nov 18, 2024, 5:00 p.m.: 20241218-IR- 329240048FRA)

329 IAC 1-3-3 329 IAC 1-3-3 Base civil penalty

329 IAC 1-3-3 Base civil penalty

Authority: IC 4-22-2; IC 13-14-9; IC 13-30-4-1

Affected: IC 13-30-4

Sec. 3. (a) A base civil penalty is calculated by selecting a penalty from the matrix in subsection (f), under subsections (b) through (e), and multiplying the base penalty by the number of days of violation as described in subsection (g).

(b) In calculating the base civil penalty, the range of penalties to be selected from the penalty matrix in subsection (f) is the range corresponding to the violation's:

(1) potential for harm to human health or the environment, or to a regulatory program as described in subsections (c) and (d); and

(2) the extent of deviation from a statutory, regulatory, or permit requirement as described in subsection (e).

(c) The department shall determine a violation's potential for harm by evaluating:

(1) the likelihood and degree of exposure of persons or the environment to pollution; or

(2) the degree of adverse effect of noncompliance on statutory or regulatory purposes or procedures for implementing the program, based on the following factors:

(A) Amount of pollutant.

(B) Toxicity of pollutant.

(C) Sensitivity of the environment.

(D) Sensitivity of the human population.

(E) Length of time of exposure.

(F) Size of the violator.

(d) The degree of potential harm represented by each category is defined as follows:

(1) For a major violation:

(A) the violation poses a substantial likelihood or degree of exposure to pollution; or

(B) the actions have or may have a substantial adverse effect on the statutory or regulatory purposes or procedures for implementing the program.

(2) For a moderate violation:

(A) the violation poses a significant likelihood or degree of exposure to pollution; or

(B) the actions have or may have a significant adverse effect on the statutory or regulatory purposes or procedures for implementing the program.

(3) For a minor violation:

(A) the violation poses a relatively low likelihood or degree of exposure to pollution; or

(B) the actions have or may have an adverse effect on the statutory or regulatory purposes or procedures for implementing the program.

(e) The extent of deviation from a statutory, rule, or permit requirement relates to the degree to which the requirement is violated as follows:

(1) For a major deviation, the violator deviates from the requirements of the regulation, permit, or statute to the extent that there is substantial noncompliance.

(2) For a moderate deviation, the violator significantly deviates from the requirements of the regulation, permit, or statute, or only some of the requirements are implemented.

(3) For a minor deviation, the violator deviates somewhat from the regulatory, permit, or statutory requirements, or most of the requirements are met.

(f) The department shall determine the base civil penalty based on individual circumstances using the following matrix:

(g) The department shall multiply the penalty derived from the matrix calculation by the number of days of violation to obtain the base civil penalty.

(h) Multi-day penalties may be calculated in the case of continuing violations.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-3-3 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed Nov 18, 2024, 5:00 p.m.: 20241218-IR-329240048FRA)

329 IAC 1-3-4 329 IAC 1-3-4 Penalty adjustment factors

329 IAC 1-3-4 Penalty adjustment factors

Authority: IC 4-22-2; IC 13-14-9; IC 13-30-4-1

Affected: IC 13-30-4

Sec. 4. (a) The department may make an upward or downward adjustment to a base civil penalty based on unique factors and circumstances that exist in relation to the violation, including the following aggravating or mitigating circumstances:

(1) Actions before the violation as described in subsection (c).

(2) Actions after the violation as described in subsection (d).

(3) History of noncompliance as described in subsections (e), (f), and (g).

(4) Ability to pay as described in subsection (h).

(5) Enforcement costs to the department as described in subsection (i).

(6) Unanticipated circumstances as described in subsection (j).

(b) Aggravating and mitigating factors, for which the department has sufficient information, may be applied to an initial penalty calculation. Other factors, including other mitigating factors the violator wishes to have considered, may be evaluated at the settlement stage.

(c) The department may adjust a base civil penalty up or down by up to fifty percent (50%) based on an assessment of the degree to which a violator is able to anticipate or prevent a violation, using the following factors:

(1) How much control the violator had over the events constituting the violation.

(2) The violator's ability to anticipate the events constituting the violation.

(3) Whether the violator took reasonable precautions against the events constituting the violation.

(4) Whether the violator knew or should have known of the hazards associated with the conduct.

(5) The degree to which the violator knew or should have known of the statutory, rule, or permit requirement that was violated. Lack of knowledge of a legal requirement will not be used as a basis to reduce civil penalty.

(d) Action or inaction by the violator after a violation, to limit real or potential harm or exposure, may either decrease or increase the civil penalty amount by up to fifty percent (50%) of the base civil penalty, and is determined based on the following actions by the violator:

(1) Promptly reporting noncompliance if not otherwise required by law.

(2) Promptly correcting environmental problems in conjunction with other good faith efforts.

(3) The amount of control the violator had over how quickly the violation was remedied.

(4) The degree and timeliness of cooperation exhibited by the violator in resolving an enforcement action.

(e) The department may increase a base civil penalty by up to one hundred percent (100%) for a history of noncompliance, taking into consideration subsections (f) and (g) and based on the following factors:

(1) Similarity of the violation to a prior violation.

(2) If the prior violation occurred within the last five (5) years.

(3) The number of prior violations.

(4) Efforts by the violator to correct a prior violation.

(5) Other relevant factors to be considered.

(f) A violation is considered similar to a prior violation if the previous enforcement response from the department or U.S. EPA alerted, or reasonably should have alerted, the violator to a particular type of compliance problem. A prior violation of the same or comparable requirement constitutes a similar violation.

(g) The department may adjust a penalty toward the lower end of the range if a prior violation was handled in an informal manner, such as a warning letter, and toward the higher end of the range if a prior violation was handled in a formal manner, such as a notice of violation or an agreed order.

(h) The department may defer or reduce a civil penalty depending on a violator's ability to pay the penalty in the following manner:

(1) The violator shall provide a demonstration to the department that:

(A) the department determines to be acceptable and sufficient; and

(B) shows the existence and extent of the violator's inability to pay the assessed penalty.

(2) The department may consider the compliance history of the violator before consideration of the ability to pay.

(3) The department may consider the following options related to the ability to pay:

(A) A delayed payment schedule.

(B) An installment payment plan, with or without interest.

(C) A reduced penalty, as a last recourse.

(i) The department may adjust a base civil penalty upward to include all costs incurred by the department in a particular enforcement action, including the following:

(1) Special sampling and analysis costs.

(2) Research time for collecting other specialized information.

(3) Other costs associated with above average department staff time for collecting evidence or pursuing settlement of the violation.

(j) The department may recalculate a civil penalty under this rule when unanticipated circumstances arise, such as additional evidence that leads to a significant reevaluation of the facts surrounding a violation.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-3- 4 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed Nov 18, 2024, 5:00 p.m.: 20241218-IR-329240048FRA)

329 IAC 1-3-5 329 IAC 1-3-5 Economic benefit of noncompliance

329 IAC 1-3-5 Economic benefit of noncompliance

Authority: IC 4-22-2; IC 13-14-9; IC 13-30-4-1

Affected: IC 13-30-4

Sec. 5. (a) Under this section, the department shall calculate and add the economic benefit to the base civil penalty as adjusted under section 4 of this rule when a violation results in significant economic benefit to the violator.

(b) The department shall consider the economic benefit of noncompliance, but may disregard it if:

(1) there is a lack of information necessary to determine the economic benefit; or

(2) the economic benefit of noncompliance is calculated to be less than one thousand dollars ($1,000).

(c) The department shall examine the following types of economic benefit of noncompliance in determining the economic benefit component:

(1) Benefit from delayed costs as described in subsection (d).

(2) Benefit from avoided costs as described in subsection (e).

(3) Other benefits, such as profits from a startup period before obtaining a permit.

(d) Delayed costs may result from the following types of violations:

(1) Delay or failure in installing equipment needed to meet pollution control standards.

(2) Delay or failure in effecting process changes needed to eliminate pollutants from products or waste streams.

(3) Testing violations, where testing is required to demonstrate achieved compliance.

(4) Improper disposal, where proper disposal is required to achieve compliance.

(5) Delay or failure in obtaining necessary permits, where those permits are likely to be granted.

(e) Avoided costs may result from the following:

(1) Costs savings for operation and maintenance of equipment the violator failed to install.

(2) Delay or failure in properly operating and maintaining existing control equipment.

(3) Delay or failure in employing enough adequately trained staff.

(4) Delay or failure in establishing or following precautionary methods required by rules or permits.

(5) Improper storage, where redisposal or cleanup is not possible.

(6) Process, operational, or maintenance savings from removing pollution equipment.

(7) Failure to collect, record, or report required samples.

(f) The department shall calculate the economic benefit of delayed, avoided, and other costs for each year and may use a model, such as U.S. EPA's Economic Benefit model, to estimate economic benefit costs.

(g) If a violator believes the economic benefit derived from noncompliance differs from the estimated amount, the violator may present information documenting its actual savings at the settlement stage. The department shall consider information that is verifiable.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-3-5 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed Nov 18, 2024, 5:00 p.m.: 20241218-IR- 329240048FRA)

329 IAC 1-3-6 329 IAC 1-3-6 Other penalty considerations

329 IAC 1-3-6 Other penalty considerations

Authority: IC 4-22-2; IC 13-14-9; IC 13-30-4-1

Affected: IC 13-30-4

Sec. 6. (a) A negotiated order may contain a provision that allows a portion of the civil penalty to be offset by a qualified supplemental environmental project.

(b) An order may include a stipulated or an additional penalty as follows:

(1) An order may specify certain actions the violator must take to remediate an environmental problem or comply with a requirement.

(2) The order must list the necessary actions and include:

(A) a milestone date for each action; and

(B) a stipulated or an additional penalty that is contingent on completion of the critical actions in a timely and satisfactory manner.

(3) A stipulated or an additional penalty is separate from the assessed civil penalty.

(4) A stipulated or an additional penalty is assessed in amounts that provide an incentive sufficient to meet the milestone.

(Office of Land Quality; 329 IAC 1-3-6 [NOTE: Under P.L. 135-2026, SECTION 53, the name of Solid Waste Management Division is changed to Office of Land Quality, effective July 1, 2026.]; filed Nov 18, 2024, 5:00 p.m.: 20241218-IR- 329240048FRA)