CourtListener 9482256•Southern Luxury Motorcars, LLC, D/B/A Crave Luxury Auto, and Andrew Powers v. Karl Stomberg A/K/A Karl C. Stomberg A/K/A Karl Christopher Stomberg, Kristin Stomberg, Matthew Stomberg, Sydney Walsh, William P. Reid, 54 DYER, L.P., Zelma Reid, Patrick Kelly, Patrick Kelly Holdings LLC, EPK Holdings, LP, EPK Management, INC., Finis E. Cowan III, Esquire, and Finis Cowan Inc. PC
Southern Luxury Motorcars, LLC, D/B/A Crave Luxury Auto, and Andrew Powers v. Karl Stomberg A/K/A Karl C. Stomberg A/K/A Karl Christopher Stomberg, Kristin Stomberg, Matthew Stomberg, Sydney Walsh, William P. Reid, 54 DYER, L.P., Zelma Reid, Patrick Kelly, Patrick Kelly Holdings LLC, EPK Holdings, LP, EPK Management, INC., Finis E. Cowan III, Esquire, and Finis Cowan Inc. PC
CourtListener 9482256Txctapp9Mar 7, 2024
Full text
In The
Court of Appeals
Ninth District of Texas at Beaumont
__________________
NO. 09-21-00180-CV
__________________
SOUTHERN LUXURY MOTORCARS, LLC, D/B/A CRAVE LUXURY
AUTO, AND ANDREW POWERS, Appellants
V.
KARL STOMBERG A/K/A KARL C. STOMBERG A/K/A KARL
CHRISTOPHER STOMBERG, KRISTIN STOMBERG, MATTHEW
STOMBERG, SYDNEY WALSH, WILLIAM P. REID, 54 DYER, L.P.,
ZELMA REID, PATRICK KELLY, PATRICK KELLY HOLDINGS LLC,
EPK HOLDINGS, LP, EPK MANAGEMENT, INC., FINIS E. COWAN III,
ESQUIRE, AND FINIS COWAN INC. PC, Appellees
__________________________________________________________________
On Appeal from the 284th District Court
Montgomery County, Texas
Trial Cause No. 20-09-10625-CV
__________________________________________________________________
MEMORANDUM OPINION
On June 23, 2021, Andrew Powers, individually and derivatively on behalf of
Southern Luxury Motorcars, LLC d/b/a Crave Luxury Auto, filed a notice of
accelerated appeal from orders granting the special appearances of Matthew
Stomberg and Sydney Walsh in Trial Cause Number 20-09-10625-CV. We received
1
a notice of bankruptcy for Southern Luxury Motorcars, LLC, and abated the appeal.
See Tex. R. App. P. 8.
On December 20, 2023, Appellees William P. Reid, Zelma Reid, and 54 Dyer,
L.P. filed a motion to reinstate the accelerated appeal and dismiss the appeal as moot.
Appellees contend that Appellants claims against Matthew Stomberg and Sydney
Walsh are property of the bankruptcy estate, the bankruptcy estate did not assert any
claims against Sydney Walsh in the bankruptcy court, and settled and dismissed its
claims against Matthew Stomberg. Appellees contend there is no longer a justiciable
controversy at issue in this accelerated appeal. No party responded to the suggestion
of mootness.
We sent a letter to all parties requesting the parties to state their position on
whether this action is stayed by an automatic stay in the Bankruptcy, and we notified
the parties of our intention to reinstate the appeal, grant the motion to dismiss, and
dismiss this case as moot. We also sent a copy of our letter to the Bankruptcy
Trustee, by sending a copy to the attorney for the Bankruptcy Trustee who is listed
on the November 3, 2023, Joint Stipulation of Dismissal of Trustee’s Claims against
Stomberg Defendants, signed by the attorneys and the Judge of the Bankruptcy
Court.
We received a response from Appellees, William P. Reid, Zelma Reid and 54
Dyer, L.P. (hereinafter “Reid and 54 Dyer”) to our letter requesting that the parties
2
state their position on whether this action is stayed by an automatic stay in the
Bankruptcy. In their response, Reid and 54 Dyer argue the bankruptcy stay no longer
stays this appeal and Appellees contend the appeal should be reinstated and
dismissed as moot.
We hereby reinstate the appeal, we grant the motion to dismiss the appeal, and
we dismiss the appeal as moot. See Tex. R. App. P. 43.2(f).
APPEAL DISMISSED.
PER CURIAM
Submitted on March 6, 2024
Opinion Delivered March 7, 2024
Before Golemon, C.J., Horton and Johnson, JJ.
3
Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.