JUDICIAL ETHICS OPINION 2024-1

2024 OK JUD ETH 1Judicial Ethics Advisory PanelJul 10, 2024

Full text

JUDICIAL ETHICS OPINION 2024-1
2024 OK JUD ETH 1

Decided: 07/10/2024


Cite as: 2024 OK JUD ETH 1, __ __

JUDICIAL ETHICS OPINION 2024-1
2024 OK JUD ETH 1
Decided: July 10, 2024


JUDICIAL ETHICS ADVISORY PANEL

JUDICIAL ETHICS OPINION 2024-1

July 10, 2024

¶1 Question: May a district court judge attend a fundraising event sponsored by Equality South?

¶2 Answer: No

¶3 Discussion: While no information was provided about Equality South , one of its publicly stated "Missions" is as follows:

"Equality South Action Fund will recruit, support and elect LGBTQ+ and
community allies running for local, county, tribal and statewide offices
in Oklahoma, Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Arkansas and Alabama."

¶4 Attendance at a fundraising event sponsored by Equality South would be a clear violation of Canon 4.1(A)(5). Under this rule, "a judge....shall not.....attend or purchase tickets for dinners or other events sponsored by a political organization or another candidate for public office."

¶5 While this mission of Equality South certainly has merit, it is purely political and precisely the type of "event" sponsored by a "political organization" that is prohibited by Canon 4.1(A)(5). Further, this type of event could be interpreted as supporting "another candidate for public office", which is also prohibited conduct for district court judges.

¶6 JEAP 2012-1, ¶ 6 provides some perspective, stating:

"Because of the unique position a judge holds in our constitutional system
of government, this is but another example of a judge being prohibited
from participating in a project of undoubted merit, just as a judge is
prohibited from fund raising for good and worthwhile projects, or being
prohibited from exercising civic responsibility to engage in political
activities."

 

Honorable William C. Hetherington, Chair -- Concur

Honorable Glenn D. Adams -- Concur in the Result

Honorable Allen McCall -- Concur

Honorable Patricia G. Parrish -- Concur

Honorable Sheila Condren -- Concur

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.