Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-146

1989-146Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL December 7, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 146
The Honorable Dale M. Sprague
State Representative, Seventy-Third District
P.O. Box 119
McPherson, Kansas 67460
Re: Taxation--Homestead Property Tax Refunds--
Extending the Deadline for Payment of Property
Taxes; Equal Protection
Synopsis: Classifying taxpayers on the basis of eligibility
under "residential circuit breaker guidelines" for
purposes of determining when property tax payments
must be made does not violate the Equal Protection
Clause of the United States Constitution or article
11, section 1 of the Kansas Constitution. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 79-4501 et seq.; L. 1989, ch.
303, § 5; Kan. Const., Art. 11, § 1, U.S.
Const., Amend. XIV.
Dear Representative Sprague:
Along with Representative Aldie Ensminger you request our
opinion on the following proposal for property tax relief:
"Relating to the issues of property tax payments to be
considered by the 1989 Special Session, it would be proposed
that individual and business/corporate taxpayers who meet the
guidelines and restrictions of the 'Residential Circuit
Breaker Guidelines' would be allowed to pay their 1989 taxes
in quarterly payments, the first payment due on January 16,
1990, the second on March 20th, and the last half on June
20th. In the case of business/corporate taxpayers, adjusted
net income would be the standard for meeting the $35,000.00
test of the residential circuit breaker guidelines.
"All other taxpayers would pay taxes under current statutes, a
minimum one-half (1/2) payment due on December 20, 1989, and
the last half on June 20, 1990."
Recognizing that this proposal creates a bifurcation of
classes of taxpayers, you question its legality under current
statutory and constitutional standards. Due to time
constraints, we limit this opinion to a discussion of the
validity of the proposal under the Equal Protection Clause of
the United States Constitution and article 11, section 1 of
the Kansas Constitution.
The Equal Protection Clause, Amend. XIV, U.S. Const.,
prohibits states from denying to any person within their
jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. The equal
protection clause does not forbid discrimination with respect
to things that are different. The test is whether the
difference in treatment is an invidious discrimination. 16A
Am.Jur.2d Constitutional Law § 738 (1979).
"But there is a point beyond which the
State cannot go without violating the
Equal Protection Clause. The State must
proceed upon a rational basis and may not
resort to a classification that is
palpably arbitrary. The rule often has
been stated to be that the classification
' must rest upon some ground of difference
having a fair and substantial relation to
the object of the legislation.' [citation
omitted]. 'If the selection or
classification is neither capricious nor
arbitrary, and rests upon some reasonable
consideration of difference or policy,
there is no denial of the equal protection
of the law.' [Citation omitted]. That a
statute may discriminate in favor of a
certain class does not render it arbitrary
if the discrimination is founded upon a
reasonable distinction, or difference in
state policy." Allied Stores of Ohio v.
Bowers, 358 U.S. 522, 79 S.Ct. 437, 3
L.Ed.2d 480, 485 (1959).
The classification here involved is based on the
qualifications established in the homestead property tax
refund act, K.S.A. 79-4501, and the "circuit breaker" act, L.
1989, ch. 303, § 5. The object of the legislation would be to
provide relief to those persons and entities most severely
affected by property tax increases by allowing them more time
to pay those taxes. In ruling on a state revenue act which
required property taxpayers in larger counties to pay their
taxes on an accelerated basis but allowing taxpayers in
smaller counties to pay on an unaccelerated basis, the
Appellate Court of Illinois upheld the classification holding
that the "plaintiff [had] not met his burden of proving that
section 224 of the Revenue Act is clearly unreasonable or
palpably erroneous." The court noted that statutes are to be
presumed valid and that it was unable to find that there was
no rational basis for the enactment. Fox v. Rosewell, 371
N.E.2d 287 (Ill. App. 1977). The Georgia Supreme Court has
held that state provision of direct benefits for a certain
group to the exclusion of other citizens does not, unless done
by arbitrary standards, constitute a violation of the
constitutional guarantee of equal protection under the laws.
Williamson v. Housing Authority of Augusta, 199 S.E. 43
(Ga. 1938). See also Jefferson v. Hackney, 406 U.S.
535, 92 S.Ct. 1724, 32 L.Ed.2d 285 (1972); Hiatt Grain &
Feed, Inc. v. Bergland, 446 F.Supp. 457, aff'd, 602
F.2d 929, cert. den. 444 U.S. 1073, 100 S.Ct. 1019, 62
L.Ed.2d 755 (D.C. Kan. 1978); Annot, 67 L.Ed.2d 883
(1982).
"Many problems must be attacked piecemeal,
and it is not a denial of equal protection
that defendant does not aid all those who
need aid with every program he
promulgates. Few programs would ever be
adopted if they were required to aid all
who need assistance equally." Hiatt
Grain, 446 F.Supp. at 508.
Based on these authorities, it is our opinion that the
classification you propose would be upheld under an equal
protection challenge.
In delaying the payment deadline for some and not others, the
situation may arise where one person must pay interest if his
property taxes are not paid by December 20, 1989, while
another person will owe no interest as long as he pays prior
to January 16, 1990. This may be argued to violate the
uniform and equal provision of the Kansas Constitution.
Kan. Const., Art. 11, § 1. However, the Kansas Supreme
Court has held that "[w]here constitutional challenges have
been made to tax exemption schemes as violative of Article 11,
Section 1, of the Kansas Constitution, this court has
consistently held that the uniform and equal rate of
assessment and taxation provision is, in principle and effect
substantially identical to the principle of equality embodied
in the Equal Protection Clause of the United States
Constitution," State ex rel. Tomasic v. Kansas City, Kansas
Port Authority, 230 Kan. 404, 426 (1981), and "in general,
what violates one will contravene the other and vice versa."
Topeka Cemetery Association v. Schnellbacher, 218 Kan.
39, 43 (1975). Since we have found no equal protection
violation, we also find no violation of the uniform and equal
taxation provision of the Kansas Constitution.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.