Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-145

1989-145Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL December , 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 145
The Honorable Al Ramirez
State Representative, Fortieth District
913 Sheidley
Bonner Springs, Kansas 66012
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas--Finance and
Taxation--System of Taxation; Classification
Synopsis: In considering possible alternatives for providing
property tax relief, the Legislature may not
postpone or alter procedures required by article
11, section 1 of the Kansas Constitution. The
Legislature may limit local units of government in
the total amount of property tax moneys they
collect, or adjust payment schedules, with the
possible repercussion of private lawsuits based on
the local units' inability to meet contractual or
other obligations. Cited herein:K.S.A. 1988 Supp.
79-1476 et sea.; Kan. Const., Art. 11,
§ 1.
Dear Representative Ramirez:
You request our opinion on the Legislature's ability to enact
certain property tax relief measures. Your specific questions
are as follows:
"1.) Does the Legislature have the authority by simple
legislative action to delay implementation of any or all of
the requirements of Section 1, Article 11 of the Kansas
Constitution?
"2.) If the Legislature does have such power, how long of a
delay would be permissible?
"3.) Does the Legislature have the power by simple
legislative action to either allow or require payment of
property taxes at 1988 assessments at 1988 mill levies?
"4.) Does the Legislature have the power by simple
legislative action to either allow or require payment of
property taxes at 1988 assessments at 1989 mill levies?
"5.) Does the Legislature have the power by simple
legislative action to require rolling back of local
jurisdictions' property tax rates to such an extent that the
local jurisdictions collect no more in property taxes in 1989
than each did in 1988?
"6.) If the Legislature does not have the power by simple
legislative act to roll back the property tax revenue of local
jurisdictions to 1988 figures, may the Legislature roll back
the property tax revenue of local jurisdictions at least
partially?
"7.) Does the Legislature have the power by simple
legislative action to allow or require payment of property
taxes, at whatever rate, in quarterly instead of biannual
payments?
"8.) I have attached a copy of an order issued November
27th by a district judge in Wyandotte County. The judge
rules that taxpayers could pay 1/2 of their 1988 property
taxes when filing a protest and still be in compliance with
various statutes. Does the Legislature have the power by
simple legislative action to make the judge's ruling
statewide?"
The first of your questions has previously been addressed by
this office. In Attorney General Opinion No. 87-8, attached,
we concluded that the January 1, 1989 date set forth in
article 11, section 1 of the Kansas Constitution may not be
altered by simple legislative action. To postpone the
effective date of classification, an amendment to the
Constitution would be required. Your second question hinged
on an affirmative answer to the first and so need not be
addressed.
You next ask whether the legislature may by statute allow or
require payment of property taxes based on 1988 assessments
and 1988 mill levies. Property taxes are calculated using
property valuations, assessment rates and mill levy rates.
Assessed valuations are determined by applying the appropriate
assessment rate to the appraised valuation. The assessment
rates are set out in the constitution which, as noted above,
may only be altered by constitutional amendment. Therefore,
the assessed valuations for 1988 may not be used in 1989 as
they in many cases were not calculated at the current
constitutionally prescribed rates.
Appraised valuations on the other hand are reached pursuant to
statutory and administrative guidelines. Reappraisal was
mandated at this particular time by statute rather than the
constitution. K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 79-1476 et seq.
Therefore, no constitutional provision would specifically
prohibit a delay in the use of reappraised values; however,
the constitution does provide for a "uniform and equal basis
of valuation and rate of taxation of all property subject to
taxation," except as otherwise specifically provided in the
constitution. It is a question of fact whether the 1988
valuations would provide a more uniform and equal basis than
the 1989 valuations. Absent further statistical information,
we cannot predict with any certainty whether a court would
uphold a legislative determination that 1988 valuations are
more uniform and equal than 1989 valuations. It should also
be kept in mind that article 11, section 1 of the constitution
provides for certain tax exemptions. Thus, there is property
which was on the tax rolls in 1988 which cannot be placed on
the rolls in 1989. This could result in a drastic reduction
in revenues and inability to fund certain required services.
In short, because of the classification amendment, it is not
possible to revert entirely to the tax scheme as it existed in
1988.
Your fourth question can be answered in much the same way.
Using a different mill levy rate would not alter the fact that
use of the 1988 assessments may not be possible.
Your fifth question is whether the legislature may by statute
require local units of government to collect no more in
property taxes in 1989 than each did in 1988. This would
require local units of government to amend their budgets,
recalculate their mill levies, reissue tax statements, and
return some of the moneys which have already been collected.
While this may be argued by county officials to be burdensome,
costly and time consuming, and would result in a loss of
income to local units of government, it appears to be within
the Legislature's authority. The Kansas Supreme Court has
held that counties are not protected by the constitutional
principles of due process. Albright v. Douglas County,
198 Kan. 184, 190 (1921). This general rule applies to
other political subdivisions of the state as well. City of
Safety Harbor v. Birchfiled, 529 F.2d 1251, 1254 (5th
Cir. 1976) ("municipal corporations have repeatedly been
denied the right to challenge state legislation allegedly
violative of the Federal Constitution. Williams v. Mayor and
City Council of Baltimore, [289 U.S. 56, 53 S.Ct. 431, 77
L.Ed. 1015 (1933)1"). See also Pawhuska v. Pawhuska
Oil & Gas Co., 250 U.S. 394, 398, 39 S.Ct. 526, 528, 63 L.Ed.
1054, 1057 (1919) ("as respects grants of political or
governmental authority to cities, towns, counties, and the
like the legislative power of states is not restrained by the
contract clause of the Constitution"); Newark v. New Jersey,
262 U.S. 192, 193, 196, 43 S.Ct. 539, 540, 67 L.Ed. 943 (1923)
("city cannot invoke the protection of the Fourteenth
Amendment against the State"); City of Moore, Oklahoma v.
Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Ry. Co., 699 F.2d 507, 511
(10th Cir. 1983). These authorities indicate that local
units of government would have no standing to challenge
legislation requiring them to rework their budgets.
Individual taxpayers or entities contracting with the local
units may, however, have some standing if contractual or other
obligations cannot be met. The merits of these possible law
suits would have to be determined on a case-by-case basis.
Since we have answered your fifth question affirmatively, we
need not address your sixth question.
You next ask whether the Legislature may by statute allow or
require payment of property taxes in quarterly instead of
biannual payments. The analysis of this question is much the
same as that of the previous question. Local units of
government may suffer from loss of interest because moneys
traditionally invested before being used might no longer be
available. As noted above, however, political subdivisions of
the state generally have no authority to challenge such
legislation. Further, this alternative may be less intrusive
as to individual taxpayers or entities which may be affected
by a local unit of government's decrease in revenues because
the underlying taxes would eventually be paid.
Finally, you question whether the Legislature may by statute
adopt the order issued by Judge Meeks in Wyandotte
County. That order provides in pertinent part:
"1. That such property owners be allowed
to pay their taxes under protest and
appeal that part of their taxes which
exceeds what these same property owners
paid for the year 1988 on their real
estate without being required to pay into
the Treasurer that portion of their taxes
which have been increased over and above
their 1988 taxes.
"2. That said defendants are required and
ordered to allow the appeal process to go
forward without the necessity of having to
pay the increased taxes to the end that
all property owners shall be accorded due
process and shall have a fair, full and
complete hearing on any and all increases
that may have been added to their taxes
over and above the tax they paid in
1988." Sullwold v. Hamblin, Case
No. 89C5187, Wyandotte County District
Court (Nov. 27, 1989).
The order does not forgive payment of increases occurring in
1989 property taxes, but merely allows taxpayers to pursue
appeals prior to having to pay such increases. This too would
appear to be a valid exercise of legislative authority. Local
units of government would eventually receive all lawfully
assessed property taxes, though maybe not for a long time
depending upon the volume of appeals. Again, private parties
may have a cause of action if the local units of government
fail to meet contractual or other obligations, though whether
any such actions would be successful is difficult to determine
at this time.
In conclusion, in considering possible alternatives for
providing property tax relief, the Legislature may not
postpone or alter procedures required by article 11, section 1
of the Kansas Constitution. The Legislature may limit local
units of government in the total amount of property tax moneys
they collect, or adjust payment schedules, with the possible
repercussion of private lawsuits based on the local units'
inability to meet contractual or other obligations.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.