Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-120

1989-120Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL September 25, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 120
Mr. David L. Hiebert
Counsel for Oaklawn Improvement District
Century Plaza Bldg., Suite 920
111 W. Douglas
Wichita, Kansas 67202-3922
Re: Counties and County Officers -- Public
Improvements; Improvement and Services Districts --
Improvement Districts; Powers
Synopsis: An improvement district incorporated pursuant to
K.S.A. 19-2753 et seq. . may plan and construct
or purchase public improvements. Pursuant to
K.S.A. 19-2765(4), (8) and (15), an improvement
district may expend funds for maintenance of sewage
disposal systems, improvement district roads or
improvements that were planned and constructed or
purchased by the improvement district. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 19-2753; 19-2755; 19-2765;
19-2765a; 68-159; 68-160; 80-1605.
Dear Mr. Hiebert:
As counsel for the Oaklawn Improvement District you request
our opinion concerning whether the improvement district may
pay for fire hydrant maintenance or street lighting. You
state that Oaklawn Improvement District is currently
operating solely as a sewer improvement district and was
incorporated pursuant to K.S.A. 19-2753 et !fa . You
specifically ask that we address these questions:
"1. Is it permissible for an improvement
district which supplies sewer services to
its residents under the facts hereinabove
set out, to also provide and pay for
street lighting and fire hydrant
maintenance?
2. Is it the responsibility of the local
township to provide street lighting and
fire hydrant maintenance when said
residents are not living within an
incorporated city, and even though said
residents reside in an incorporated
improvement district?"
K.S.A. 19-2753 et seq. authorizes the establishment of
improvement districts. When deciding whether to create such a
district, certain factors are considered such as "the present
cost and adequacy of governmental services [and] . . . the
need for public improvements in the proposed
district. . . ." K.S.A. 19-2755(b)(7) and (8). The need for
sewer services apparently led to the organization of Oaklawn
Improvement District.
The powers of an improvement district have been previously
examined by this office. See Attorney General Opinions No.
88-141 and 83-56 (an improvement district does not have zoning
authority); 83-162 (an improvement district cannot enforce a
restrictive covenant); 83-40 (an improvement district cannot
prohibit nonresidents from using district roads); 81-279
(improvement district inhabitants cannot be required to
connect to the sewer system provided by the district); 80-211
(general funds, not special assessments, should be levied in
order to pay for the repair and maintenance of improvement
district roads, but see K.S.A. 19-2765(a)(8)); and 79-303
(improvement districts have no authority to enter into cable
franchise agreements). See also Lakeside Improvement
District v. Jefferson County, 237 Kan. 106 (1985). These
opinions follow the well established rule that municipal
corporations possess only those powers specifically granted by
statute or necessarily implied in order to perform the duties
of the municipality.
K.S.A. 19-2765 sets forth the general powers and duties of
improvement districts created pursuant to K.S.A. 19-2753 et
!fa, and states in pertinent part that:
"(a) every improvement district
incorporated under the terms of this act
shall have the power to:
(4) Plan and construct or to purchase
public works and improvements necessary
for public health, recreation, convenience
or welfare within the limits of the
improvement district. Also to construct
or purchase works outside the limits of
the district which may be necessary to
secure outlets, disposal, etc., and
permit satisfactory performance of the
works within the district.
(8) Levy assessments and special taxes,
if deemed expedient by the directors, upon
all of the real estate in the district
that may be benefited by special works and
improvements including the improvement and
maintenance of roads in the district,
which will be conducive to the public
health, convenience or welfare.
(15) Do all other acts that may be
necessary to carry out and execute the
general powers hereinbefore or hereinafter
granted, although not hereinbefore
specifically enumerated." (Emphasis
added).
All improvement districts incorporated pursuant to K.S.A.
19-2753 et seq. possess the powers enumerated under K.S.A.
19-2765 unless otherwise limited by law. While K.S.A. 19-2765
does not specifically discuss fire hydrants or street lights,
it permits an improvement district to construct or purchase
public improvements which will "be conducive to the public
health, convenience or welfare." A "public improvement" is
generally understood to mean any permanent improvement upon
real property which is owned by a municipality. Western Lion
Ltd. v. City of Manhattan, 462 N.E.2d 891 (Ill. 1984).
Utility systems, including water mains, are generally
considered public improvements. Cardellini v. Casey,
181 C.A.3d 389 (Cal. 1987). Improvements are defined
generally as
"buildings, but may also include any
permanent structure or other development,
such as a street, sidewalks, sewers,
utilities, etc. An expenditure to extend
the useful life of an asset or to improve
its performance over that of the original
asset. Such expenditures are capitalized
as part of the asset's cost." Blacks Law
Dictionary 682 (5th ed. 1979).
Erection and maintenance of waterworks and electric lights
constitutes a "public improvement." Bank of Commerce v.
Huddleston, 291 SW 422 (1927).
K.S.A. 19-2765(a)(8) permits funds to be expended on
maintenance of roads. If street lights on improvement
district roads will be conducive to public health, convenience
or welfare, maintain improvement district roads, and help
prevent crime or promote public safety, K.S.A. 68-159 and
K.S.A. 19-2765 permit an improvement district to provide
safety lights on improvement district roads.
You also question the appropriateness of using improvement
district funds for maintenance of fire hydrants within an
improvement district. Maintenance of fire hydrants affects
fire protection services, but may also relate to water supply
within an area. If organized and operating pursuant to K.S.A.
19-2753 et seq. an improvement district may exercise the
powers contained therein. K.S.A. 19-2765(a)(8) specifically
discusses and authorizes maintenance of improvement district
roads. K.S.A. 19-2765a specifically approves using certain
funds for maintenance of the district's sewage disposal
system. These appear to be the only sections discussing
maintenance of an improvement. However, K.S.A. 19-2765(a)(4)
permits improvement districts to plan and construct or
purchase public improvements. K.S.A. 19-2765(a)(15) permits
the district to "do all acts that may be necessary to carry
out and execute the powers hereinbefore specifically.
enumerated." In order to provide a public improvement that
has been constructed or purchased by an improvement district,
maintenance becomes necessary. [See Oswald v. City of Blue
Springs, 635 S.W.2d 332 (Mo. 1982) (where a municipality
has the authority to construct a water treatment plant it may
provide for the costs of maintaining such a public
improvement)]. There is no indication that the legislature
intended to permit an improvement district the authority to
construct or purchase public improvements but then required
the improvement district to ignore maintenance of such
improvements. It is therefore our opinion that an improvement
district may provide for maintenance of public improvements
(in addition to roads or sewer systems) if those improvements
were validly planned and constructed or purchased by the
improvement district.
Your second question concerns whether a township has the duty
or authority to provide street lights and fire hydrants within
improvement district territory. K.S.A. 68-159, 68-160 and
80-1605 permit townships to take certain actions with regard
to lights and fire hydrants and to levy for those purposes.
However, as discussed in Attorney General Opinion No. 89-78,
statutory authority to levy a tax is not mandatory where funds
are not owing or needed. See also 71 Am.Jur.2d State
and Local Taxation, § 91 (1973); 84 C.J.S. Taxation, S 361
(1954). Kansas case law evidences acceptance of the general
rule that the authority to provide a public service or
improvement does not necessarily obligate the municipality to
provide such services or improvements. See Davies v.
City of Lawrence, 218 Kan. 551 (1976); Board of Education
of Unified School and District No. 345, Shawnee County v.
Topeka, 214 Kan. 811 (1974); Bock v. Stack, 132 Kan.
533 (1931). Rather, absent an imposition of a specific
mandatory duty, the decision whether to provide a particular
service or improvement is discretionary. See Huser v.
Duck Creek Watershed District No. 59, 234 Kan. 1 (1983);
Gronniger v. Board of County Commissioners, Doniphan
County, 6 Kan.App.2d, 642 (1981); Paul v. Topeka
Township Sewage District, 199 Kan. 394 (1967); Hill v.
City of Lawrence, 2 Kan.App.2d 457 (1978). A township
may provide authorized improvements or services within an
improvement district if, in its discretion, such improvements
or services are deemed necessary.
Creation of a new public entity may impact upon another
pre-existing public corporation. The legislature has the
power to vacate existing townsites either expressly or by
clear implication. City v. Eudora v. French, 204 Kan.
258 (1969). For example, K.S.A. 80-1541 provides that upon
annexation by a city, property within a fire district is
removed from the district. We are unaware of any statute,
common law, or general rule divesting a township of all
jurisdiction or authority within improvement district
boundaries, nor have we located authority declaring an area
within an improvement district to be excluded from an existing
township. Authority granted to townships under K.S.A. 68-159
and 80-1605 permit townships to provide for lights or fire
hydrants within townships. The fact that the township
includes an improvement district within its boundaries does
not prohibit the township from proper exercise of its
discretionary powers. It is therefore our opinion that a
township may discretionarily choose to provide safety lights
or fire hydrants pursuant to K.S.A. 68-159, 68-160 and 80-1605.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Theresa Marcel Nuckolls
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TMN:bas

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.