Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-116

1989-116Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL September 14, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 116
Tom C. Hitchcock, Executive Secretary
Kansas State Board of Pharmacy
Landon State Office Bldg., Room 513
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Public Health -- Regulation of Pharmacists --
Definitions; Prescription Order
Public Health -- Examination, Licensure and
Regulation of Nursing -- Advanced Registered Nurse
Practitioners; Transmitting Prescription Orders
Public Health -- Healing Arts; Physicians'
Assistants -- Transmitting Prescription Orders
Synopsis: Physicians' assistants and advanced registered
nurse practitioners may not originate a
prescription order, as they are not practitioners
within the meaning of the pharmacy act. However,
these health care providers may transmit
prescription orders pursuant to written protocols.
The transmitted order is a prescription order as
defined by the pharmacy act. An order may be
transmitted through a note written by the health
care provider, and the signature of that person is
neither required nor prohibited by the pharmacy
act. The pharmacist may refuse to fill the
prescription if, in the pharmacist's professional
judgment and discretion, it is believed that the
prescription should not be filled. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 65-1129; 65-1130 (Ensley 1985); K.S.A.
65-1130, as amended by L. 1989, ch. 192, § 1;
K.S.A. 65-1626 (Ensley 1985); K.S.A. 1988 Supp.
65-1626, as amended by L. 1989, ch. 192, § 2;
K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 65-1637(a), 65-2896e; K.S.A.
65-4101; L. 1989, ch. 192, S 1; L. 1986, ch.
236, S. 1; K.A.R. 60-11-104; 60-11-104a; 68-20-18;
21 C.F.R. § 1306.05.
*
Dear Mr. Hitchcock:
As Executive Secretary for the Kansas State Board of Pharmacy,
you have requested our opinion regarding a pharmacist's
obligation to fill a prescription when an order has been
transmitted in written form and signed by an advanced
registered nurse practitioner (ARNP) or a physicians'
assistant (PA). Your question arises from the uncertainty of
these health care providers' authority which attended an
amendment to the pharmacy act in 1986. Subsequent legislation
clarifies this authority.
Only a "practitioner" may prescribe drugs. See Kansas
Attorney General Opinion No. 86-125. Prior to the effective
date of L. 1986, ch. 236, § 1, a practitioner was defined as
follows:
"'Practitioner' means a person licensed to
practice medicine and surgery, dentist,
podiatrist, veterinarian, scientific
investigator or other person licensed,
registered or otherwise authorized by law
to administer, prescribe and use
prescription-only drugs in the course of
professional practice or research."
K.S.A. 65-1626(t) (Ensley 1985).
The statute was amended to read:
"'Practitioner' means a person licensed to
practice medicine and surgery, dentist,
podiatrist, veterinarian, scientific
investigator or other person licensed,
registered or otherwise authorized by
law expressly licensed or registered
to administer, prescribe and use
prescription-only drugs in the course of
professional practice or research."
K.S.A. 65-1626(t) (L. 1986, ch. 236,
1).
Based on the amended language of the above-noted statute, and
based upon the practice acts for the ARNP's and PA's, we
stated that ARNP's
"may not issue prescription orders
pursuant to a physician's standing orders
or protocol because they have not been
granted such authority by the statutes and
regulations under which they are
licensed. Physicians' assistants,
however, are expressly authorized by
statute to practice medicine under the
direction and supervision of a physician.
Since the practice of medicine includes
the act of prescribing medicine, we
conclude that physicians' assistants may
issue prescription orders under the
direction and supervision of a
physician." Attorney General Opinion No.
86-125, at page 8.
Following our 1986 opinion, the physicians' assistants act was
amended to clarify the nature of a PA's authority to
prescribe. It now states in part:
"A physician's assistant may not
prescribe drugs but may transmit a
prescription order for drugs pursuant to a
written protocol as authorized by the
responsible physician. " K.S.A. 1988
Supp. 65-2896e (emphasis added).
The underscored terms were not defined by the legislature.
Regarding ARNP's, the Kansas state board of nursing
clarified the nurse practitioners' expanded role by
promulgating K.A.R. 60-11-104a. The existing nursing
regulations had included in the scope of expanded practice the
authority to "manage the medical plan of care prescribed for
the client, based on protocols or guidelines" which the
attending physician and nurse practitioner had adopted.
K.A.R. 60-11-104(f). Since the language of this regulation
did not expressly license an ARNP to administer, prescribe
or use prescription-only drugs, ARNP's were not
practitioners within the meaning of the pharmacy act. The new
regulation gives the express authority, but only to the extent
the prescription order originates from a written protocol.
The authority cited for the regulation is K.S.A. 65-1129
(general rule-making authority) and K.S.A. 65-1130 (Ensley
1985) (specific rule-making authority regarding ARNP's).
The legislature expressed concern that the nursing regulation
exceeded the agency's authority. See Minutes, Joint
Committee on Administrative Rules and Regulations, December 9,
1988, page 13. The Legislature subsequently amended K.S.A.
65-1130, adding language nearly identical to that used for the
physicians' assistants (provider may transmit order pursuant
to protocol, but may not prescribe). See L. 1989, ch.
192, § 1. Once again, the terms "transmit" and "prescribe"
are not defined by statute. See K.S.A. 65-1130, as amended
by L. 1989, ch. 192, § 1.
With this background, we address the issue of whether a
pharmacist may fill a prescription order which is
transmitted in writing and signed by a PA or an ARNP. To
simplify the issue, we assume that the prescription order does
not involve a controlled substance, as defined by K.S.A.
65-4101(e).
Generally, pharmacists are under a duty to fill a prescription
in strict compliance with a prescription order. See K.S.A.
1988 Supp. 65-1637(a). A prescription order is defined as:
"(1) An order to be filled by a
pharmacist for prescription medication
issued and signed by a practitioner in
the authorized course of professional
practice; or (2) an order transmitted to
a pharmacist through word of mouth, note,
telephone or other means of communication
directed by such practitioner." K.S.A.
1988 Supp. 65-1626(y), as amended by L.
1989, ch. 192, § 2 (emphasis added).
From the language employed by the legislature in amending the
PA statute in 1987 and the ARNP statute this last session,
it is clear that those categories of health care providers are
not to be considered "practitioners" within the meaning of the
pharmacy act. Therefore, subsection (y)(1) of the
above-quoted definition does not apply. However, subsection
(y)(2) uses language which corresponds to the language of the
specific practice acts. As with the PA and ARNP practice
acts, the term "transmit" is not defined in the pharmacy act.
We believe that subsections (y)(1) and (y)(2) of the
definition and the practice acts distinguish between the
origination of a prescription order by a practitioner and the
conveyance of such order. The definition also makes clear
that the order may be conveyed through a variety of media.
In summary, a physician's order for prescription medication
which is transmitted to a pharmacist is a prescription order.
The practice acts regulating PA's and ARNP's authorize
those health care providers to receive their direction
regarding a practitioner's order from the written protocol.
In relaying an order from a protocol to a pharmacist, whether
by verbal or written message, a prescription order is created,
and a pharmacist is authorized to fill the prescription. By
transmitting the physician's order in this manner, the ARNP
or PA is not prescribing, as prohibited by statute.
The form of the written note does not appear to be regulated
by the pharmacy act or by regulations of the pharmacy board.
In comparison, state and federal law both dictate the elements
of a prescription order for controlled substances. See
K.A.R. 68-20-18 and 21 C.F.R. § 1306.05. For controlled
substance prescriptions, a practitioner must sign the order
when an oral order is not permitted. In effect, this is a
mandated verification that the order was given by a person
entitled to issue the prescription order. Our review of the
federal and state pharmacy laws reveals no similar requirement
for non-controlled prescription medications. Therefore, from
the pharmacists perspective, the presence or absence of a
PA's or ARNP's signature is of no legal consequence. The
licensing board of either of the classes of health care
providers may make requirements regarding the form of
transmitting the prescription order. Such requirements should
be perceived as regulating the PA or ARNP, and not the
pharmacist.
Having determined that a pharmacist is authorized to fill a
prescription order transmitted, in writing, by an ARNP or
PA, we next look at the degree to which the pharmacist is
required to fill such prescription. We need not reach the
question of whether a pharmacist, without cause, may decline
to fill a prescription. A pharmacist may decline to fill a
prescription if, in the pharmacist's professional discretion,
such prescription should not be filled. See, e.g., K.S.A.
1988 Supp. 65-1637. It appears that the refusal must arise
out of professional judgment and discretion. One writer notes
that a pharmacist may refuse to fill or refill a prescription
because the pharmacist may "(1) not have the prescribed drug
in stock; (2) suspect that the prescription is forged or is
fictitious writing; (3) distrust his or her ability to fill
the prescription; (4) believe that the prescription will be
harmful to the patient due to error on [the] part of the
prescriber; and (5) (in the case of a refill) know that the
refilling of the prescription violates the law." Pharmacy
Law Digest (Facts and Comparisons) Looseleaf Service, at
CL-57 (July, 1988). The writer goes on to say that, in
refusing to fill the prescription, the pharmacist should avoid
commenting on the professional ability of the prescriber, as
civil liability may arise out of defamatory remarks. Id.
In conclusion, the statutes upon which Attorney General
Opinion No. 86-125 was based have been amended. In light of
those amendments, it is our opinion that physicians'
assistants and advanced registered nurse practitioners may not
originate a prescription order, as they are not practitioners
within the meaning of the pharmacy act. However, these health
care providers may transmit a prescription order pursuant to
written protocols. A prescription order may be transmitted
through a note written by the health care provider, and a
signature of that person is neither required nor prohibited by
the pharmacy act. The pharmacist may refuse to fill the
prescription if, in the pharmacist's professional judgment and
discretion, it is believe that the prescription should not be
filled.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mark W. Stafford
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MWS:bas

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.