Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-095

1989-095Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
July 27, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89-95
Mr. Tom Crossan
Attorney at Law
Rural Water District No. 1
Montgomery County
P.O. Box 987
Independence, Kansas 67301
Re: Waters and Watercourses -- Water Districts; Rural
Water Districts -- Powers of Rural Water Districts;
Contract with City for Purchase of Water
Synopsis: Pursuant to K.S.A. 66-104, a municipally owned and
operated water company, which supplies a rural
water district with surplus water pursuant to a
contract, is not a public utility subject to the
control of the state. Kansas law does not require
city owned water companies to extend existing water
services to new consumers residing in rural water
districts. Therefore, pursuant to a contract with
a rural water district, a city may limit the
availability of services to new consumers residing
outside the city. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1988 Supp.
12-519; K.S.A 12-707; K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 12-715b;
K.S.A. 12-801; 12-808; K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 12-2001;
65-162a; 66-104; 66-131a; 66-133, 82a-612; 82a-619;
82a-625.
Dear Mr. Crossan:
As legal counsel for Rural Water District (RWD) No. 1,
Montgomery County, created pursuant to K.S.A. 82a-612 et
seq., you request our opinion concerning the city of
Independence and its water supply policy as it relates to
areas outside the city limits. You state that "the city is
apparently attempting to impose zoning laws upon the rural
water districts which are supplied with water from the city.
The city has proclaimed that no new water users will be
supplied water, even if they are in the district, for any
property of less than 15 acres." You maintain that this is
being done in an attempt to require builders to build within
the city limits. You specifically ask that we address the
following questions posed by the secretary of the RWD:
"1. Can a city that has been providing
water for thirty years to a rural water
district contractually limit the number of
acres associated with new benefit units
within the water district?
2. Does such a contract imply zoning
control outside the city limits?
3. When a city limits acreage, is there a
possible infringement upon the civil
rights of the property owners who own less
than fifteen acres and who desire water?
4. Can one assume that the city water
department becomes a public utility when a
contract to supply water to a rural water
district outside the city limits has been
signed?
5. If such a contract does imply that the
city water department is a public utility,
are there certain responsibilities and/or
rights and privileges that the city has in
relationship to the water district and/or
to the individuals in the water district?
6. What power does the state have in such
a situation?"
A public utility is generally defined as "a business or
service which is engaged in regularly supplying the public
with some commodity or service of public consequence, such as
electricity, gas, water, transportation, or telephone or
telegraph service." 64 Am.Jur.2d Public Utilities § 1
(1972). See also 56 Am.Jur.2d Municipal Corporations
§ 561 (1971); 73B C.J.S. Public Utilities §§ 2-4 (1983).
However, where a business might otherwise be defined and
qualify as a public utility, its nature and regulation
affecting its operation may be altered by statute. K.S.A.
66-104 defines public utilities subject to supervision by the
state of Kansas:
"The term 'public utility' shall also
include that portion of every municipally
owned or operated electric or gas utility
located outside of and more than three (3)
miles from the corporate limits of such
municipality, but nothing in this act
shall apply to a municipally owned or
operated utility, or portion thereof,
located within the corporate limits of
such municipality or located outside of
such corporate limits but within three (3)
miles thereof except as provided in K.S.A.
66-131a.
Except as herein provided, the power and
authority to control and regulate all
public utilities and common carriers
situated and operated wholly or
principally within any city or principally
operated for the benefit of such city or
its people, shall be vested exclusively in
such city, subject only to the right to
apply for relief to the corporation
commission as hereinafter provided in
K.S.A. 66-133 and to the provisions of
K.S.A. 66-131a." (Emphasis added).
K.S.A. 66-131a concerns heat loss standards and energy
efficient ratios and K.S.A. 66-133 discusses extension and
additions to public utilities and rates for those utilities.
Pursuant to K.S.A. 66-104, and in accordance with discussions
with legal counsel for the Kansas Corporation Commission
(KCC) (the state agency given regulatory authority over
public utilities), unless a rate dispute is involved or the
city has entered into individual contracts with private
entities outside the city, a municipally owned and operated
public utility is not subject to the control and supervision
of the state. See also Shawnee Hills Mobile Homes, Inc.
v. Rural Water District No. 6, 217 Kan. 421 (1975); Kansas
Gas and Electric Company v. City of McPherson, 146 Kan.
614 (1937); Kansas Public Service Company v. State
Corporation Commission, 199 Kan. 736 (1967); Holton
Creamery Company v. Brown, 137 Kan. 418 (1933). Since the
RWD is not a private entity, state agency control over the
specific situation presented is limited to any possible
applicability of K.S.A. 66-131a or 66-133. The issues
presented do not appear to implicate state authority. It
therefore becomes a matter subject to control by local
authorities and review by the court.
Pursuant to K.S.A. 12-801 et seq., a municipality may
provide water to the inhabitants of that municipality. A city
may establish, operate and own a water company. A city may
alternatively give an exclusive franchise to a privately owned
company, thus allowing that company the sole privilege of
providing water to a city's inhabitants. K.S.A. 12-2001 et
seq. If exclusivity is not established, an area may be
served by privately owned water companies. See K.S.A.
65-161a et seq. .
K.S.A. 82a-612 et seq. authorizes a rural water district
to supply inhabitants of that district with water and permit a
RWD to construct and operate its own water supply facility
and to contract in order to carry out the purposes of the
RWD. See also K.S.A. 82a-619(a)(5), 82a-619(a)(3), and
82a-625.
Pursuant to K.S.A. 12-808, cities may sell surplus water to
other public entities or individuals. We assume that this is
the authority employed by Independence in selling surplus
water to the RWD. In City of Strong v. Rural Water
District No. 1, 6 Kan.App.2d 859 (1981) the appellate
court concluded that courts have no supervisory power over the
legislative function of a municipality involved in selling
surplus water to a rural water district and establishing water
rates charged to that RWD. The court recognized that a
city's authority to sell water to a RWD is found at K.S.A.
12-808 and concluded that:
"Courts can only interfere to curb action
which is ultra vires because of some
constitutional impediment, or lack of
valid legislative authority, or unlawful
acts under a valid statute, or because
action under a valid statute is so
arbitrary, capricious, unreasonable and
subversive of private rights as to
indicate a clear abuse rather than a bona
fide exercise of power." Schulenberg
v. City of Reading, 196 Kan. 43, 52
(1966). (Emphasis added).
The issue thus becomes whether the city's refusal to sell
water to new users under the facts and circumstances provided
violates a duty imposed upon the city by state or federal law
or is arbitrary, capricious, unreasonable or subversive of
private rights.
As a general rule, the furnishing of public services rests
within the discretion of the governing municipal authorities
and, unless controlled by positive law, courts will not
undertake to control or interfere with the exercise of such a
discretionary decision in the absence of bad faith or abuse.
56 Am.Jur.2d Municipal Corporations, § 560 (1971). State
or federal law does not mandate that Kansas cities provide
water to individuals residing outside city limits. Therefore,
no positive duty exists requiring cities to furnish surplus
water to residents outside the city or to a RWD supplying
those residents. Thus, we must determine whether refusal to
extend services to new users occupying less than 15 acres
evidences bad faith or abuse.
The proposed action by the city does not seek to terminate
water service to those currently using city water. Such
termination of current users would be subject to
constitutional notice and hearing requirements as discussed in
Donnelly v. City of Eureka, 399 F.Supp. 64 (1975), and
Dedeke v. Rural Water District No. 5, 229 Kan. 242
(1981). Rather, the city seeks to establish new contract
terms by which it will agree to supply new users of city water
residing in the RWD. A city cannot generally be compelled
to supply water in an area outside its limits where it has not
previously placed itself by contract or conduct in the
position of a public utility subject to regulation:
"Likewise, a city cannot be compelled to
supply water to anyone outside its limits,
even if it is already engaged in doing so
in a given extraterritorial area, where it
has made merely limited and special
contracts to do so with particular parties
and has not placed itself by contract or
conduct in the position of a public
utility subject to regulation, and
subject, therefore, to a duty to supply
all in like position to that of others
being served. It would seem that in
situations where a city cannot be
compelled to serve new consumers as a
general proposition, a fortiori it cannot
be compelled to extend its system in order
to serve a new consumer." Annot., 48
A.L.R.2d 1222, 1230 (1956).
"As to nonresidents to whom a municipality
furnishes water, it has been held not to
assume the duties of a public service
corporation, nor can it be compelled to
furnish water to nonresidents. It has
been said that to compel a municipality to
furnish water service to persons outside
its corporate limits and beyond its taxing
powers at a loss would violate the due
process clauses of both the state and
federal constitutions. It has also been
said that to hold that a city may be
compelled to extend its mains beyond its
corporate limits and then, as a natural
result, to serve and maintain them, merely
because it is operating a municipal water
system, could lead to endless difficulties
for the city, financial and otherwise, and
make it the prey of every unwise or
unscrupulous promoter of subdivisions or
other enterprises.
"A municipally owned waterworks system
supplying water without its corporate
limits may, generally, charge more for
that service than is charged users of the
water service who reside within the
corporate limits. The fact that residents
of the municipality have borne the cost of
establishing or financing the system will
justify charging a higher rate to
nonresidents."
"Since, as a general proposition, a
municipality cannot be compelled to serve
consumers outside its limits, it naturally
follows that a municipality cannot be
compelled to extend facilities it has
voluntarily established outside the
municipal limits, at least in the absence
of contract, or of a course of conduct
whereby the city has held itself out as a
public utility in a particular area. . . .
Thus, limited contracts made by a
municipality obligating it to supply water
to particular consumers outside the
municipal limits, usually executed
pursuant to a power to sell excess water
outside the corporate limits, will not
place it under obligation to extend its
system to serve impartially all who seek
service. It has been held that after the
termination of a general contract to
supply, a city can then refuse to extend
the existing system to serve new
consumers, although an opposite result has
been reached where a statute provided that
a water system once established in an area
beyond the city limits becomes subject to
regulation as a public utility." 78
Am.Jur.2nd Waterworks and Water
Companies, § 6 and § 22 (1975). See
also McQuillan Municipal
Corporations, § 35.34 (1986).
The proposed contract terms specifically limit the
availability of water services the city will agree to provide
to the RWD and links such services to the size of,area to be
served. This classifies property owners by the amount of
property they own. Classification of water users is not of
itself discriminatory. See Usher v. City of Pittsburg,
196 Kan. 86, 89 (1966): "We find no merit in appellant's
charge of discrimination. Although this court has not
heretofore passed directly on the question, it is a very
general rule that a city operating a municipal water plant and
serving customers outside the city limits may make a separate
classification of customers without the city for rate making
purposes. The fact that the rates charged within the city are
different than those charged outside the city does not of
itself characterize the rates as discriminatory." Id. at
89. We do not have sufficient information to determine the
motives or purposes of the city for such a contract term. If
there is a nondiscriminatory purpose for such a requirement,
the city may take actions which classify users who reside
outside the city.
The final issue posed by counsel for the RWD concerns the
zoning authority of a city in areas outside its boundaries.
K.S.A. 12-707 et seq. discuss the zoning authority of a
city. K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 12-715b gives cities limited
authority to adopt zoning regulations affecting land located
outside the city, but within three miles of the city. These
authorities set forth the procedures whereby a zoning
regulation or ordinance may be adopted by a city and thereby
affect property uses.
The activity in question does not involve the adoption of a
zoning regulation or ordinance. Rather, it involves a
contract term or water supply policy which may affect property
uses outside the city. Counsel believes this contract term is
an attempt to require builders to build individual residences
within the city. We note that many decisions by city
authorities could have a similar impact; the lack of or
location of city roads, industrial sites located near the
boundaries of the city, and zoning or uses permitted along the
boundaries of the city. We find no mandatory duty imposed
upon Kansas cities to encourage or promote the building of
individual residences outside city limits. If property owners
or residents outside the city wish to obtain the same rights
and privileges afforded to persons residing within the city,
K.S.A. 12-519 et seq. set forth annexation procedures.
Thus, the denial of water services by the city to new RWD
consumers residing on less than 15 acres does not rise to the
level of an improper exercise of zoning authority outside the
city.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Theresa Marcel Nuckolls
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TMN:bas

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.