Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-091

1989-091Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL July 21, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 91
Lawrence T. Buening, Jr.
General Counsel
Kansas Board of Healing Arts
Landon State Office Building, Suite 553
Topeka, Kansas 66612-1256
Re: Public Health--Healing Arts; Kansas Healing Arts
Act--Persons Deemed Engaged in Practice of
Chiropractic
Synopsis: A surgical operation includes severing tissue and
penetrating the human body for treatment,
replacement, or removal of afflicted parts.
Surgical operations must be performed by those
individuals who are licensed to practice medicine
and surgery. An individual licensed to practice
chiropractic may treat a stress fracture if the
treatment does not involve a surgical operation,
and so long as the treatment is within chiropractic
methodology. Such methodology may include the use
of a plaster cast. Cited herein: K.S.A. 65-2802,
65-2803; K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 65-2836, as amended by
1989 Senate Bill No. 182; K.S.A. 1988 Supp.
65-2869; K.S.A. 65-2871; R.S. 1923, 65-1005.
*
Dear Mr. Buening:
As general counsel to the Kansas board of healing arts, you
request our opinion regarding the authorized scope of practice
for a chiropractic licensee. Specifically, you ask:
"a. Is an individual who has been issued a license to
practice chiropractic by the State Board of Healing Arts in
violation of the Healing Arts Act (K.S.A. 65-2801, et
eta.) by treating a possible stress fracture?
"b. Does an individual who has been issued a license to
practice chiropractic by the State Board of Healing Arts
unlawfully engage in the practice of medicine and surgery by
applying a cast for any purpose whatsoever?"
Treatment of a fracture is included in the practice of the
healing arts, which is defined in K.S.A. 65-2802(a) as:
"any system, treatment, operation,
diagnosis, prescription, or practice for
the ascertainment, cure, relief,
palliation adjustment, or correction of
any human disease, ailment, deformity, or
injury, and includes specifically but not
by way of limitation the practice of
medicine and surgery; the practice of
osteopathic medicine and surgery; and the
practice of chiropractic."
Any person engaging in the practice of any branch of the
healing arts must first obtain a license to do so. K.S.A.
65-2803. A person who is licensed by the board is subject to
disciplinary action for unlawfully invading the field of
practice of another branch of the healing arts in which that
individual is not licensed to practice. K.S.A. 1988 Supp.
65-2836(g), as amended by 1989 Senate Bill No. 182.
The scope of practice of chiropractic is established by K.S.A.
65-2871. Individuals are deemed to engage in the practice of
chiropractic if they are:
"(a) Persons who examine, analyze and
diagnose the human living body, and its
diseases by the use of any physical,
thermal or manual method and use the X-ray
diagnosis and analysis taught in any
accredited chiropractic school or college
and (b) persons who adjust any misplaced
tissue of any kind or nature, manipulate
or treat the human body by manual,
mechanical, electrical or natural methods
or by the use of physical means,
physiotherapy (including light, heat,
water or exercise), or by the use of
foods, food concentrates, or food extract,
or who apply first aid and hygiene, but
chiropractors are expressly prohibited
from prescribing or administering to any
person medicine or drugs in materia
medica, or from performing any surgery,
as hereinabove stated, or from practicing
obstetrics." K.S.A. 65-2871.
The statute is broader than other definitions associated with
the practice of chiropractic. For example, chiropractic is
defined elsewhere as
"a method of detecting and correcting by
manual or mechanical means structural
imbalance, distortion or subluxations in
the human body to remove nerve
interferences where such is the result of
or related to distortion, misalignment or
subluxations of or in the vertabral
column. [citation omitted.] A system of
therapeutic treatment, through adjustment
of articulations of human body,
particularly those of the spine.
[citation omitted.] The specific science
that removes pressure on the nerves by the
adjustment of the spinal vertebrae."
Black's Law Dictionary 218 (5th ed.
1979).
Reference to treating the human body through manipulation of
the spine summarizes the scope of practice of chiropractic in
other states.
"'Chiropractic' is a limited science which
deals with the relationships between the
articulations of the vertebral column as
well as other articulations and the
nervous system and the role of these
relationships in the restoration and
maintenance of health.
"The practice of chiropractic embraces
diagnosis, including spinal analysis to
determine the existence of spinal
subluxations or misalignments that
produce nerve interference, indicating the
necessity for chiropractic care, the
adjustment of spinal subluxations and
misalignments and related bones and
tissues for the establishment of neural
integrity, and the furnishing of the
necessary patient care for the restoration
of health. The practice of chiropractic
does not include the performance of
incisive surgical procedures, the
performance of an invasive procedure
requiring instrumentation, the reduction
of fractures, or major dislocations, or
the dispensing or prescribing of drugs or
medicines. 70 C.J.S., Physicians and
Surgeons, §5 (1987).
This narrower scope of practice appears to be what was
understood as chiropractic in the earlier days in Kansas. In
State v. Johnson, 84 Kan. 411 (1911), the Kansas Supreme
Court held that the laws regulating the practice of medicine,
surgery and osteopathy embrace one who practices
chiropractic. At that time, the practice involved
manipulation of the spinal column to treat disease. 84 Kan.
at 415-16.
As indicated, the current statute does not limit the practice
of chiropractic to manipulation of the spinal column. A
chiropractic licensee may treat the human body by the listed
methods, but may not perform any surgery. The statutes
address "how" something is treated, not "what" is treated.
Therefore, it appears that the scope of chiropractic does not
exclude treatment of a fracture, so long as such treatment
does not amount to surgery.
The prohibition against performing any surgery limits the
method of treating a fracture. The term "surgery" in the
context of the scope of chiropractic was construed in
Acupuncture Society of Kansas v. Kansas State Bd. of
Healing Arts, 226 Kan. 639 (1979). In that case, the
Kansas Supreme Court held that acupuncture is not surgery, and
is not prohibited in the practice of chiropractic. The trial
court had stated that "'[s]urgery' is a broad term employed
to cover the work surgeons do. 'Surgery' covers procedures in
which no incision or entering of the skin is involved; for
example, a closed reduction of a fracture. The traditional
chiropractic theory involves external manipulation, applying
heat to the exterior, etc." 226 Kan. at 642. The trial
court was therefore applying a broad concept of surgery and a
narrow concept of chiropractic. The Kansas Supreme Court
reversed, applying a narrower definition of "surgery," stating
"'[s]urgery is what surgeons do' -- sever the tissues of the
body for the purpose of penetration for treatment, replacement
or removal of afflicted parts." 226 Kan. at 646.
In so construing the healing arts act the Supreme Court did
not address previous definitions of surgery. In The State,
ex rel. v. Eustace, 117 Kan. 746 (1925), the Court had
applied the dictionary definition of surgery in construing
R.S. 1923, 65-1005, the previous law which is similar to
K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 65-2869. Surgery was defined by Webster's
dictionary as "'the art or practice of healing by manual
operation; that branch of medical science which treats of
mechanical or operative measures for healing diseases,
deformities, or injuries.'" 117 Kan. at 748. In State, ex
rel. v. Gleason, 148 Kan. 1 (1938), the Court
distinguished the practice of medicine and surgery from the
practice of osteopathy. Osteopaths had been prohibited from
performing operations in surgery. This phrase was later
deleted from the statute. The court held that this did not
confer unrestricted authority to perform surgery. Surgery, in
a "broadest sense includes adjustment of bones, muscles,
ligaments and nerves by manual operation. . . ." 148 Kan.
at 11. These decisions appear to be limited by Acupuncture
Society.
In summary, we believe that a chiropractic licensee may treat
a stress fracture, unless the treatment involves a surgical
operation. A surgical operation involves severing tissue and
penetrating the human body for treatment, replacement or
removal of afflicted parts. A surgical operation to diagnose,
cure, or treat a fracture must be conducted by a person
licensed to practice medicine and surgery. See K.S.A. 1988
Supp. 65-2869(b). Obviously, the chiropractic licensee is
limited to treating the stress fracture through the use of
chiropractic methods. In our opinion, such methods may
include the use of a plaster cast.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Mark W. Stafford
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MWS:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.