Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-088

1989-088Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
July 10, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 88
Gene Porter
Barton County Attorney
P.O. Box 881
Great Bend, Kansas 67530
Re: Taxation -- Collection and Cancellation of Taxes --
Time for Payment of Personal Property Taxes;
Computation of Interest When County Treasurer
Accepts Partial Payment of Delinquent Personal
Property Taxes
Synopsis: K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 79-2004a provides for the accrual
of interest on delinquent personal property taxes.
When a county treasurer accepts a partial payment
of delinquent personal property taxes, future
computations of interest should be based on the
amount of delinquent taxes remaining unpaid after
crediting the partial payment, rather than on the
full amount of delinquent taxes originally owing.
A different rule may apply if the delinquent taxes
become a "judgment" tinder the operation of K.S.A.
1988 Supp. 79-2101. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1988
Supp. 79-2004a; 79-2101.
Dear Mr. Porter:
As Barton County Attorney, you request our opinion regarding
the computation of interest when a county treasurer accepts
partial payments of delinquent personal property taxes.
Specifically, you ask whether a county treasurer should
compute future interest based upon the amount of delinquent
taxes remaining unpaid after a partial payment, or should
continue to charge interest on the full amount of delinquent
taxes originally owing until the entire balance is paid.
The procedure to be followed in computing interest on
delinquent personal property taxes is set forth in K.S.A. 1988
Supp. 79-2004a:
"In the event anyone charged with personal
property taxes shall fail to pay the first
half thereof on or before December 20, the
full amount thereof shall become
immediately due and payable.
In case the first half of the taxes
remains unpaid after December 20, the
entire and full amount of personal
property taxes charged shall draw
interest at the rate per annum prescribed
by K.S.A. 79-2968(b) and amendments
thereto, from December 20 to date of
payment. All personal property taxes of
the preceding year and interest thereon
which shall remain due and unpaid on June
21 shall draw interest at the rate per
annum prescribed by K.S.A. 79-2968(b), and
amendments thereto, from June 20 until
paid." (Emphasis added.)
The statute does not specifically provide for partial payment
of delinquent personal property taxes. However, county
treasurers may discretionarily accept partial payments in
certain circumstances. See Attorney General Opinion No.
86-96. The statute does not contain instruction for computing
interest when partial payment is made. Therefore, the rules
of statutory construction must be applied.
The primary rule of statutory construction is that the purpose
and intent of the legislature governs when that intent can be
ascertained from the statute. National Cooperative Refinery
Ass'n v. Board of McPherson County Commr's, 228 Kan.
595, 597 (1980). The language of K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 79-2004a
does not provide clear intent on this issue because it does
not indicate whether the words "payment" and "paid" refer
exclusively to payment of the "entire and full amount" of
delinquent taxes charged, or whether they apply equally to
partial payments. A subordinate rule of statutory
construction holds that words in common usage are to be given
their natural and ordinary meaning in arriving at the proper
construction of a statute. In re Tax Appeal of Black, 9
Kan.App.2d 666, 668 (1984). Black's Law Dictionary 71
(5th ed. 1979) defines "interest" as "the compensation
allowed by law or fixed by the parties for the use or
forbearance or detention of money." It would be more
consistent with this ordinary meaning to charge interest on
the amount of unpaid delinquent taxes remaining after a
partial payment rather than to continue charging interest on
amounts that have already been paid.
Further, "where there is reasonable doubt as to the meaning of
a taxing act, it will be construed most favorably to the
taxpayer. . . . Such a statute should not be so read as to
add that which is not readily found therein or to read out
what as a matter of ordinary English language is in it."
National Cooperative Refinery Ass'n, 228 Kan. at 597.
Given this rule of construction, the language of the statute
is too ambiguous to support the more punitive approach of
charging interest on the portion of delinquent taxes that has
already been paid.
Additional guidance can be obtained from the Kansas Supreme
Court's treatment of partial payments on interest-bearing
commercial debts. "According to the United States rule, in
the absence of an agreement or a statute to the contrary,
partial payments to an interest-bearing debt which is due are
first applied to the interest due. If the payment exceeds the
interest, the surplus goes toward discharging the principal,
and the subsequent interest is computed on the remaining
principal due." Shutts v. Phillips Petroleum Co., 240
Kan. 764, 798 (1987) (emphasis added). Nothing in the
statute indicates that the term "interest" as applied to
delinquent personal property taxes should be handled
differently than in an ordinary commercial transaction.
Therefore, it is our opinion that if a county treasurer
properly and legally accepts partial payment toward delinquent
personal property taxes, interest should be computed only on
the balance of delinquent taxes that remain unpaid after
crediting the partial payment, rather than on the full amount
of delinquent taxes originally owed.
Once delinquent personal property taxes become a "judgment"
under K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 79-2101 this result may be altered.
According to that statute, unpaid personal property taxes
. . shall become a judgment in the same manner and to the
same extent as any other judgment under the code of civil
procedure" upon the filing of an abstract of the delinquent
taxes and the last tax warrant. Thus, as some point, a tax
debt becomes a judgment.
The Kansas Supreme Court has not stated a clear position on
how interest is to be computed when partial payment of a tax
debt is made after a judgment. However, in McGuire v.
Sifers, 235 Kan. 368, 382 (1984), the court reviewed
Schaefer and Associates v. Schirmer, 3 Kan.App.2d 114,
(1979), and Bartlett v. Heersche, 209 Kan. 369,
(1972), two cases that dealt with the issue of tolling
interest on judgments. The court concluded:
"Neither Bartlett nor Schaefer
addresses the question of whether partial
payment of a judgment tolls postjudgment
interest on the portion paid into court,
but the language used in the opinions
suggests a judgment debtor must pay the
full amount of the judgment into court to
toll postjudgment interest." Id. at 383.
The McGuire case suggests that the court would require the
full amount of the judgment to be paid before interest would
be tolled on any portion of the delinquent property taxes.
Thus, it appears that the proper computation of interest
following partial payment of delinquent property taxes may
depend upon whether the delinquent taxes have become a
judgment under operation of K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 79-2101. Prior
to a judgment, it appears that the computation of interest
should be made in accordance with the customary "United
States" rule as in ordinary commercial transactions. Once
there is a judgment on delinquent taxes, it may be necessary
to compute interest on the full amount until the entire debt
is paid. Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Theresa Marcel Nuckolls
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TMN:bas

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.