Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-166

1988-166Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL_ December 1, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 166
Judith Bravence-Stringer
Consumer Credit Commissioner
Landon State Office Building
900 Jackson, Room 352
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Contracts and Promises--Investment Certificates of
Investment Companies--Registration of Investment
Certificates of Investment Companies; Restriction
on Investments Not Inherent to Principal Business
of Licensed Lender
Synopsis: K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16-601i authorizes the investment
of funds obtained from the sale of investment
certificates in a majority-owned affiliate or
subsidiary of the issuer as long as the
affiliate/subsidiary is engaged in the same type of
business as the issuer and does not itself issue
investment certificates. Based on the historical
background of the investment certificate act and
the rules of statutory construction, it is our
opinion that this provision would not preclude the
acquisition of the majority stock of a savings and
loan association with funds obtained from the sale
of investment certificates. However, the Consumer
Credit Commissioner has the discretion to prohibit
such an investment if her determination is
reasonably based on other provisions of the act.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 9-1101, as amended
by L. 1988, ch. 62, §1; 16-601i; 16-630; 16a-1-301,
as amended by L. 1988, ch. 85, §2; 17-5501.
Dear Commissioner Stringer:
You request our opinion regarding the limitation on investment
of funds obtained from the sale of investment certificates
issued pursuant to the Kansas investment certificate act,
K.S.A. 16-601 et seq. Specifically, your questions are
as follows:
"1. May an investment certificate company use funds obtained
from the sale of investment certificates to purchase the
common stock of a state chartered savings and loan company?
"2. May an investment company form a subsidiary company in
which it would invest funds obtained from the sale of
investment certificates so that it could purchase the common
stock of the savings and loan company?"
The Kansas investment certificate act (act) requires
investment companies to register investment certificates with
the consumer credit commissioner prior to sale. The act sets
forth standards of operation to be maintained by the
investment company and limitations and restrictions on the
issuance of investment certificates. One such restriction
provides as follows:
"No investment company shall allow the
investment of funds obtained from the sale
of certificates to be made that is not
inherent to the principal business of a
licensed lender under the Kansas uniform
consumer credit code, except that this
restriction shall not apply to: (a) Any
majority-owned affiliate or subsidiary
company of the issuer which does not issue
certificates but which is engaged in the
same type of business in Kansas; (b) loan
contracts when the proceeds of the loan
are used for business or agricultural
purposes, installment sales contracts or
leases of personal property when used for
agricultural or business purposes; or (c)
the purchase of commercial paper or to
loans secured by real estate mortgages as
described and limited in K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
16-601h." K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16-601i
(emphasis added).
We believe the underscored language is the key to answering
your questions. There is no case law and very little
legislative history in terms of written minutes to aid in the
interpretation of this language. Thus, we turn to the rules
of statutory construction. When a statute is plain and
unambiguous, the primary rule of statutory construction is to
give effect to the statute's clear meaning; however, if the
statute is ambiguous (when there are two or more
interpretations which can be fairly made) legislative intent
must be ascertained and the statute interpreted accordingly.
Kansas Power and Light Co. v. State Corp. Commission, 237
Kan. 394, 397 (1985). In construing statutes, legislative
intent should be determined from a general consideration of
the whole act, and effect must be given, if possible, to the
entire statute and every part thereof. To this end we must
attempt to reconcile different provisions so as to make them
consistent, harmonious and sensible. State v. Board of
Education of U.S.D. 428, 231 Kan. 579, 584 (1982); State v.
Adee, 241 Kan. 825, 829 (1987). A construction which
renders part of a legislative act surplusage is to be avoided
if reasonably possible. American Fidelity Ins. Co. v.
Employers Mutual Cas. Co., 3 Kan. App. 2d 245, 249
(1979). Finally, legislative intent can be found in the
historical background of an enactment and the circumstances
attending its passage. State v. Kansas City, 230 Kan. 404,
432 (1981). Any changes and additions made in existing
legislation raise a presumption that a change in meaning and
effect was intended. State v. U.S.D. 428, supra at 582.
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16-601i is less than clear in its meaning.
Since there is more than one interpretation which can be
fairly made, we must strive to determine the legislative
intent. An initial reading of the language in question might
lead one to conclude that a majority-owned affiliate or
subsidiary of an investment company, which is engaged in the
same type of business as the parent/issuer and which has no
authority to itself issue investment certificates, is not
subject to the restrictions imposed by the statute. Such a
reading, however, would render the entire statute meaningless
as an investment company could easily form a subsidiary
through which it could funnel money obtained from the sale of
investment certificates thereby sidestepping any restrictions
on investment of those funds. We do not believe the statute
should be interpreted so as to allow such circumvention.
A second possible interpretation is that the statute allows an
investment company to invest funds obtained from the sale of
investment certificates in the assets of a majority-owned
affiliate or subsidiary engaged in the same type of business
and which does not itself issue investment certificates. The
problem with this interpretation is that it renders
subsections (b) and (c) of the statute superfluous in that the
principal assets of a company engaged in the same type of
business as an investment company (i.e., a consumer lender,
a savings and loan, a bank etc.) are the same assets as those
listed in subsections (b) and (c). See K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
17-5501, 9-1101. As mentioned above, a statute should be
construed, if possible, so as to give effect to all of its
provisions and a construction which renders part of the act
surplusage is to be avoided.
In disposing of the above-mentioned interpretations, we are
left with the conclusion that K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16-601i(a)
should be construed to allow an investment certificate company
to use funds obtained from the sale of investment certificates
to acquire a majority of the stock of a company engaged in the
same type of business as the investment company and which does
not itself issue investment certificates. This interpretation
would give meaning to the entire statute and is also
consistent with the historical background and circumstances
surrounding the passage of the investment certificate act as
we understand it. The act was introduced to the legislature
in response to the downfall of the Coffeyville Loan &
Investment Company, an issuer of investment certificates
pursuant to the Kansas securities act. This company got into
trouble when the controlling owner began investing in
businesses other than those engaged in lending. These
non - lending-business investments contributed to the eventual
bankruptcy of the investment company which in turn lead to the
enactment of the investment certificate act in general, and
what is now K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16-601i in particular. Thus,
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16-601i was intended to limit investments of
funds obtained from the sale of investment certificates to
those associated with the principal business of the issuer.
The acquisition of a company engaged in the same type of
business as the issuer would be consistent with this intent.
Disallowing the purchase of stock of a company engaged in the
same type of business as an investment company would not
necessarily be consistent with the overall intent of the act,
which we believe to be the protection of investors. The
purchase of stock in such a company is arguably no more risky
than the purchase of some loans or other assets listed in
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16-601i. Use of an investment certificate
investor's money to purchase the stock would not cause that
investor to be liable for the company purchased. The investor
stands to lose only his original investment in the investment
certificates, just as though the funds were being used to
invest in other assets such as loans or commercial paper.
We must emphasize that we are in no way making a judgment on
the wisdom of the investment in question. We are merely
concluding that K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16-601i does not preclude
it. We believe you, as Consumer Credit Commissioner, have the
discretion to determine the wisdom of the investment based on
the other provisions of the act and facts we do not have the
advantage of using.
Having concluded that an investment company may use funds
obtained from the sale of investment certificates to acquire
the majority stock of a company engaged in the same type of
business, we must now determine whether a savings and loan
association is engaged in the "same type of business" as that
of the issuer/investment company. Pursuant to the investment
certificate act an investment company must be licensed under
the provisions of the Kansas uniform consumer credit code
(UCCC), K.S.A. 16a-1-101 et seq. K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
16-630. The UCCC defines "licensed lender," or "supervised
lender," as one authorized to make or take assignments of
supervised loans. K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16a-1-301(38), as amended
by L. 1988, ch. 85, §2. A "supervised loan" is "a consumer
loan [as defined by K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16a-1-301(13), as
amended], including a loan made pursuant to open end credit,
in which the rate of the finance charge . . . exceeds 12% per
year." K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16a-1-301(39), as amended.
In addition to making consumer loans, an investment company
may also, with specified limitations, engage in the lending of
money to persons, firms and corporations for other than
consumer purposes. K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16-630, 16-601i.
Similarly, a savings and loan association is primarily engaged
in the business of making consumer, business, agriculture and
first mortgage loans. K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 17-5501. It is
therefore our opinion that a savings and loan association is
engaged in the same type of business as an investment company.
You have also inquired whether an investment company may form
a subsidiary for the purpose of investing funds obtained from
the sale of investment certificates issued by the investment
company in the majority stock of a savings and loan. Since in
our opinion the investment company could make this investment
directly, we see no reason why it couldn't be made indirectly
through a majority owned affiliate or subsidiary.
In conclusion, K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 16-601i authorizes the
investment of funds obtained from the sale of investment
certificates in a majority-owned affiliate or subsidiary of
the issuer as long as the affiliate/subsidiary is engaged in
the same type of business as the issuer and does not itself
issue investment certificates. Based on the historical
background of the investment certificate act and the rules of
statutory construction, it is our opinion that this provision
would not preclude the acquisition of the majority stock of a
savings and loan association with funds obtained form the sale
of investment certificates. However, the Consumer Credit
Commissioner has the discretion to prohibit such an investment
if such a determination is reasonably based on other
provisions of the act.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Julene L. Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.