Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-124

1988-124Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL August 31, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 124
The Honorable Rick Bowden
State Representative, Ninety-Third District
433 Walnut
Goddard, Kansas 67052
Re: Schools -- School Unification Acts -- Board Member
District Boundaries; Adjustments
Synopsis: It is our opinion that school districts using the
member district system may make amendments to
member district boundaries to correct errors or to
make the boundaries more practicable. School
boards are required to make changes in member
district boundaries by adopting a resolution at the
October meeting preceding the general election if
such changes are appropriate. Appropriateness of
redistricting is to be determined on the basis of an
equal protection analysis, so that an elector's
vote is not diluted in comparison to other
electors. Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-204, 72-6769,
72-8127; L. 1965, ch. 420, sec. 6.
Dear Representative Bowden:
As State Representative for the Ninety-Third District, you
have requested our opinion regarding reapportionment of member
district boundaries of unified school districts.
Specifically, you ask whether the reapportionment provisions
of K.S.A. 72-6769 are mandatory or discretionary.
The statute in question states in relevant part:
"The board of education of any school
district may change the boundaries of
board member districts, if any, within its
school district, including any territory
added thereto. The board is directed to
make any appropriate changes in the member
districts of the school district by
resolution duly adopted at a meeting of
the board in the month of October next
preceding every regular election of board
members of the school district. . . ."
"Amendments to member district boundaries
may be made to correct errors therein or
to make the territory thereof more
practicable. . . ." K.S.A. 72-6769.
We do not believe the use of both permissive and mandatory
language creates any ambiguity in the statute.
The permissive language which appears in K.S.A. 72-6769
authorizes school boards to change member district boundaries
at times other than in October preceding the general election
to accomplish the purposes set forth in the second paragraph
of the statute. School districts are creations of the
legislature, and have only those powers which are conferred by
statute, specifically or clearly implied. Hobart v. U.S.D.
No. 309, 230 Kan. 375, 383 (1981). Without the grant of
authority contained in K.S.A. 72-6769, a school district would
not be empowered to alter district member boundaries to
correct errors or to make them more practicable. C.f., L.
1965, ch. 420, sec. 6 (original version of statute, used
phrase "is authorized to. . . .").
In contrast to discretionary redistricting, school boards are
directed to make appropriate changes in the October meeting
immediately preceding the general election. We have
previously considered a similar statute which requires
reapportionment of county commissioner districts at least once
every three years. See Kansas Attorney General Opinion No.
86-70 (construing K.S.A. 19-204). Based on Hayes v. Rogers,
24 Kan. 143 (1880) and The State, ex rel. v. Labette
County, 114 Kan. 726 (1923), we opined that the statute
does not require automatic redistricting every three years,
but rather it mandates that districts should be examined in
light of the statutory criteria, and redrawn if necessary. We
believe that the principles in our previous opinion apply to
the language of K.S.A. 72-6769. If changes are appropriate,
then the school board is directed to make those changes at the
stated time.
The statute does not give guidelines for determining what
changes are appropriate. We are guided, however, by the equal
protection standard of one-person, one-vote. In Reynolds v.
Sims, 377 U.S. 533, 12 L.Ed.2d 506 (1964), this principle
was extended to elections for state legislators. One-person,
one-vote also applies to political subdivisions of the state.
In Hadley v. Junior College District, 397 U.S. 50, 25
L.Ed.2d 45 (1970), the Court stated:
"If one person's vote is given less weight
through unequal apportionment, his right
to equal participation is impaired just as
much when he votes for a school board
member as when he votes for a state
legislator. While there are differences
in the powers of different officials, the
crucial consideration is the right of each
qualified voter to participate on an equal
footing in the election process." 397
U.S. at 55, 25 L.Ed.2d at 50.
As we have recently noted, the Court
"has been more flexible in variations from
ideal apportionment in state
representation than in federal
representation. Compare Kirkpatrick
v. Preisler, 394 U.S. 526, 531, 22
L.Ed.2d 519, 525 (1969) (Congressional
districts must be drawn to give one person
one vote, only limited and unavoidable
variances tolerated) with Mahan v.
Howell, 410 U.S. 315, 324, 35 L.Ed.2d
320, 330 (1973) (state redistricting plan
to be judged by equal protection test, not
by Kirkpatrick standard)." Attorney
General Opinion No. 88-111, at page 3.
In comparison, K.S.A. 72-8127 contains similar redistricting
language applicable to a school district in which there is
located at least two first-class cities. That section gives
guidelines for that type of district, stating:
"Such board of education shall maintain
such member district boundaries along
"Such board of education shall maintain
such member district boundaries along
precinct lines insofar as practicable, and
the territory of each member district
shall, giving due regard to the population
of each member district, correspond as
nearly as may be to attendance areas of
the senior high schools of the unified
school district for the succeeding year."
K.S.A. 72-8127.
In conclusion, it is our opinion that school districts using
the member district system may make amendments to member
district boundaries to correct errors or to make the
boundaries more practicable. School boards are required to
make changes in member district boundaries by adopting a
resolution at the October meeting preceding the general
election if such changes are appropriate. Appropriateness of
redistricting is to be determined on the basis of equal
protection analysis, so that an elector's vote is not diluted
in comparison to other electors.
Very truly yours,
ROBERTT	r.STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mark W. Stafford
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MWS:bas

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.