Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-083

1988-083Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL June 20, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 83
Erick E. Nordling
Hugoton City Attorney
P.O. Box 250
Hugoton, Kansas 67951
Re: Cities of the Second Class--Miscellaneous
Provisions--Natural Gas Production and Sale;
Acquisition of Drilling Sites; Contracts
Cities and Municipalities--Public Utilities--
Acquisition and Operation of City Plants
Constitution of the State of Kansas--
Corporations--Cities' Powers of Home Rule
Synopsis: A city of the second class may, pursuant to K.S.A.
14-1041 et E2a ., contract with an individual
for the drilling of natural gas wells whereby the
wells become the property of the city and the
individual is fully reimbursed from any proceed?
therefrom. While K.S.A. 14-1042 prescribes that
the drilling of the well, in the first instance,
shall be without cost to the city, that statute is
part of an enactment which is not uniformly
applicable to all cities. Accordingly, where a
city of the second class seeks to secure additional
natural gas sources to provide fuel for its power
and light plant, it may adopt a charter ordinance
exempting itself from the restriction upon bearing
the cost of drilling and equipping a well.
Pursuant to the provisions of K.S.A. 12-842, a city
of the second or third class may purchase natural
gas at the wellhead from wells located outside the
city limits, and construct, operate, and maintain a
pipeline necessary to transport the gas either
directly to the city power plant, or to a pipeline
system which would transport the natural gas for
the city.
Under home rule powers granted by Article 12,
Section 5 of the Kansas Constitution, a city which
acquires an interest in a producing gas well
outside the city limits may take production from
the well "in kind" rather than receiving a cash
royalty. Additionally, a city may purchase spot
market gas for its power plant several months in
advance of its use. Cited herein: K.S.A. 12-842,
14-1041, 14-1042; Kan. Const., Art. 12, 55.
*
Dear Mr. Nordling:
You request our opinion concerning several questions relating
to the acquisition of new natural gas sources for the
municipal power and light plant of city of Hugoton. Our
responses to the questions you have posed are set forth below.
You indicate that the city of Hugoton is interested in
drilling a "deep" natural gas well pursuant to the provisions
of K.S.A. 14-1041 et seg., and request our
interpretation of K.S.A. 14-1042. Specifically, you ask
whether the deep well could be converted into a infill well
in the Chase formation (which includes the Hugoton field) if
the deep well were not successful. In this regard, you
indicate that the city already has a well (Fee No. 1) which is
in the Hugoton field pay zone, and that the city is able to
produce 100 percent of the allowable for said well.
Accordingly, if there were an infill well, you indicate that
the unit allowable (the original and the infill well) would
be prorated between the two wells; thus, during the period in
which the driller is recouping his costs and expenses from the
production from the infill well, the city would, in effect,
being paying for a portion of the new well because of the
reduced amount of natural gas that could be taken from the Fee
No. 1 well. In this context, you ask whether the restriction
upon the city bearing the cost of drilling, as set forth in
K.S.A. 14-1042, would be violated.
K.S.A. 14-1042 provides as follows:
"The drilling of a well as authorized in
this act shall be upon the further
conditions that some person shall be
willing to enter into an agreement with
the city whereby such person will drill
and equip the well at his or her own
expense, in the first instance, and
without cost to the city, and with the
understanding that such person shall be
repaid from the natural gas produced from
said well or the proceeds thereof, and
that after being fully reimbursed the city
shall then become the sole and exclusive
owner of the well.
"The governing body of the city shall
credit to the funds of the city, the
proceeds and income accruing to the city
by reason of the city's ownership of the
gas well, and in order to secure to the
common owners of the land situated within
the corporate limits of the city a
proportionate acquisition of, and benefit
from, the natural gas underlying said
land, all such proceeds shall be subject
to governmental uses and purposes of the
city as the governing body shall order
from time to time and to reduce and
eliminate, insofar as possible, all
property taxes of the city. Any well
drilled under authority of this act shall
be drilled within the corporate limits of
the city, except as hereinafter
provided." (Emphasis added.)
As the underscored portion of the above quoted statute
indicates, the drilling of the well, in the first instance, is
to be without cost to the city. In our judgment, if an
unsuccessful deep well was converted into an infill well,
under the circumstances set forth above, the reduced amount of
natural gas that could be taken from the Fee No. 1 well would
constitute a "cost to the city," thereby violating the
restriction set forth in the above quoted statute. However,
that statute is part of an enactment which is applicable only
to cities of the second class, and is therefore not uniformly
applicable to all cities. Accordingly, where the city of
Hugoton seeks to secure additional natural gas sources to
primarily provide fuel for its power and light plant, it could
adopt a charter ordinance, pursuant to the provisions of
Article 12, Section 5 of the Kansas Constitution, exempting
itself from the restriction upon bearing the cost of drilling
and equipping a deep well. Thus, through such a charter
ordinance the city could allow the person who drilled the well
to recoup his costs and expenses from the production from the
infill well.
The second question is whether the city may purchase natural
gas at the wellhead from wells located outside the city
limits, and whether it has authority to construct, operate,
and maintain a pipeline necessary to transport the gas either
directly to the city power plant, or to a pipeline system
which would transport the natural gas for the city.
K.S.A. 12-842 authorizes any city of the second or third class
to construct and operate a variety of public utility
facilities and provides as follows:
"Any city of the second or third class of
the state of Kansas is hereby granted full
power and authority, on behalf of such
city, to purchase, procure, provide and
contract for the construction of, and to
construct and operate, gas plants,
electric-light plants, electric power or
heating plants, waterworks, natural-gas
wells, and petroleum-oil wells, and to
secure by lease, contract or purchase
natural-gas lands, petroleum-oil lands,
and other real estate, and to contract
for and purchase natural gas, petroleum
oil, electric current, and water to be
delivered where purchased or elsewhere,
and to construct, maintain and operate
pipe lines, wires and other equipment for
the transportation of the same from the
place where such natural gas, petroleum,
electric current or water may be
delivered, to such points within or
without the city as may be deemed
advisable, for the purpose of supplying
said city, its citizens and others, with
water, light, gas, power, fuel or heat for
domestic use or other purposes, and said
cities are hereby authorized to place said
pipe lines, wires and other equipment for
said transportation upon and across any of
the public roads, highways and streets of
this state in such manner as not to
incommode the public in the use of such
roads, highways and streets." (Emphasis
added.)
Pursuant to the under-scored provisions of the above-quoted
statute, the city of Hugoton may purchase natural gas at the
well head from wells located outside the city limits, and
construct, operate, and maintain a pipeline necessary to
transport the gas either directly to the city power plant, or
to a pipeline system which would transport the natural gas for
the city.
Your next question is whether the city could take production
from a producing gas well "in kind" rather than receiving a
cash royalty, if it acquires an interest in such a well
located outside the city limits. In our judgment, the terms
under which a city acquires natural gas for its power plant is
clearly a "local affair" which the city could address by
ordinary ordinance under home rule powers granted by Article
12, Section 5 of the Kansas Constitution. Accordingly, in our
judgment, a city which acquires an interest in a producing gas
well outside the city limits may take production from the well
"in kind," rather than receive a cash royalty.
Your final question is whether the city may, in order to
secure a lower cost, purchase spot market gas for its power
plant several months in advance of its use. In our judgment,
such a purchase is for a public purpose, i.e., supplying the
municipal power plant, and does not constitute a "speculative
oil and gas venture." See City of Geneseo v. Gas
Company, 55 Kan. 358, 361 (1895); Attorney General Opinion
No. 83-90. Accordingly, it is our opinion that the city of
Hugoton may, pursuant to K.S.A. 12-842 and home rule powers,
purchase spot market gas for its power plant several months in
advance of its use.
In summary, a city of second class may, pursuant to K.S.A.
14-1041 et seq., contract with an individual for the
drilling of natural gas wells whereby the wells become the
property of the city and the individual is fully reimbursed
from any proceeds therefrom. While K.S.A. 14-1042 prescribes
that the drilling of the well, in the first instance, shall be
without cost to the city, that statute is part of an enactment
which is not uniformly applicable to all cities. Accordingly,
where a city of the second class seeks to secure additional
natural gas sources to primarily provide fuel for its power
and light plant, it may adopt a charter ordinance exempting
itself from the restriction upon bearing the cost of drilling
and equipping a well.
Pursuant to the provisions of K.S.A. 12-842, a city of the
second or third class may purchase natural gas at the well
head from wells located outside the city limits, and
construct, operate, and maintain a pipeline necessary to
transport the gas either directly to the city power plant, or
to a pipeline system which would transport the natural gas for
the city.
Under home rule powers granted by Article 12, Section 5 of the
Kansas Constitution, a city which acquires an interest in a
producing gas well outside the city limits may take production
from the well "in kind" rather than receiving a cash royalty.
Additionally, a city may purchase spot market gas for its
power plants several months in advance of its use.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TRH:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.