Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-070

1988-070Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL May 20, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88 - 70
The Honorable Vincent K. Snowbarger
State Representative, Twenty-Sixth District
1451 Orleans Drive
Olathe, Kansas 66062
Re: Accountants, Certified Public--General Provisions--
Client Communications, Privileged, Exception
Synopsis: Though the Kansas appellate courts have not
construed the accountant-client privilege in K.S.A.
1-401, the language of the statute clearly creates
an absolute privilege between a certified public
accountant and his client regardless of judicial
process. The only limitations to the
statutorily-created privilege include instances
where the communication is material to the defense
of an action against a certified public accountant
[K.S.A. 1-401(b)] and where the communication is
material to a peer review against the accountant's
accounting and auditing practices, where such
disclosure is not tantamount to a waiver of the
privilege [K.S.A. 1-401(c)]. Cited herein: K.S.A.
1-401.
Dear Representative Snowbarger:
As a member of the Kansas House of Representatives you inquire
about the accountant-client privilege in K.S.A. 1-401.
Specifically, you ask whether this statute creates an absolute
privilege regardless of the issuance of summons, subpoena,
order for attendance or other judicial process. Secondly you
ask whether a certified public accountant can be compelled to
disclose any confidential information without the consent of
his client.
The accountant-client privilege found in K.S.A. 1-401(b)
states:
"(b) No certified public accountant
shall be examined through judicial process
or proceedings without the consent of the
client as to any communication made by
the client to the certified public
accountant in person or through the media
of books of account and financial records,
or as to advice, reports or working papers
given or made thereon in the course of
professional employment, nor shall a
secretary, stenographer, clerk or
assistant of a certified public accountant
be examined without the consent of the
client concerned, concerning any fact the
knowledge of which any such person has
acquired in such capacity or relationship
with the certified public accountant.
This privilege shall exist in all cases
except when any such communication is
material to the defense of an action
against a certified public accountant and
as otherwise provided by this section.
(Emphasis added.)
Under common law there is no privilege that attaches to an
accountant-client relationship. 1 Am. Jur. 2d Accountants
§13 (1962). K.S.A. 1-401 was thus enacted in derogation of
common law. Though the statute has never been construed by
the Kansas appellate courts, generally the reason for enacting
an accountant-client privilege statute is to encourage free
and open communications between a client and his accountant,
33 A.L.R. 4th 539, 541 (1984), and to protect the client's
expectations of confidentiality. The language in K.S.A. 1-401
is clear and unambiguous, providing its purpose with
reasonable certainty. The statute states "no certified public
accountant shall be examined through judicial process or
proceedings without the consent of the , client. . . ." When a
statute is clear on its face the court must give effect to the
intent of the legislature as expressed. U.S. v. O'Brien,
686 F.2d 850 (C.A. Kan., 1982); State v. Haug, 237
Kan. 390 (1985); City of Overland Park v. Nikias, 209
Kan. 643 (1972). The statutory language clearly establishes
an absolute privilege against disclosure of information by a
certified public accountant without his client's consent.
Accordingly, it is our opinion that the statutory
accountant-client privilege exists between a client and his
certified public accountant in any judicial proceeding
regardless of the issuance of summons, subpoena, order of
attendance or other judicial process. The statute defines a
certified public accountant in K.S.A. 1-401(d) as ". . . a
person who holds a permit from the board of accountancy to
engage in practice as a certified public accountant in this
state . ." Thus the privilege would not extend to an accountant
or a public accountant. See Dees v. Scott, 347 So.2d
475 (Fla. App. 1977).
Your second question regarding whether a certified public
accountant can be compelled to disclose any confidential
information without the consent of the client involves the
limitations of the accountant-client privilege in K.S.A.
1-401.. The only limitations on the privilege are found in
K.S.A. 1-401(b) and (c):
"This privilege shall exist in all cases
except when any such communication is
material to the defense of an action
against a certified public accountant and
as otherwise provided by this section."
"Nothing in subsection (b) shall
prohibit a certified public accountant
or anyone employed by a certified public
accountant from disclosing any data to
any other certified public accountant or
anyone employed by a certified public
accountant in connection with peer
reviews of such certified public
accountant's accounting and auditing
practice nor shall such disclosure waive
the privilege. Persons conducting such
peer reviews shall be subject to the same
duty of confidentiality in regard to such
data as is applicable to certified public
accountants under this section."
Thus the statutorily-created privilege is absolute, subject
only to the limitations imposed by the statute itself. The
instances where an accountant could be compelled or allowed to
testify without the consent of his client are first where the
communication is material to the defense of an action against
a certified public accountant and second where the
communication is material to a peer review against the
accountant's accounting and auditing practices, where such
disclosure is not tantamount to a waiver. (We note that your
inquiry does not include nor have we addressed the issue of
whether the accountant-client privilege in K.S.A. 1-401 would
apply in cases involving "federal question" jurisdiction or a
conflict of law question.)
In conclusion, though the Kansas appellate courts have not
construed the accountant-client privilege in K.S.A. 1-401, the
language of the statute clearly establishes an absolute
privilege between a certified public accountant and his
client, regardless of judicial process. The only limitations
to the statutorily-created privilege include instances where
the communication is material to the defense of an action
against a certified public accountant and where the
communication is material to a peer review against the
accountant's accounting and auditing practices, where such
disclosure is not tantamount to waiver.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Guen Easley
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:GE:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.