Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-174

1987-174Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL December 1, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 174
Mr. Dennis W. Moore
Johnson County District Attorney
Johnson County Courthouse
P.O. Box 728 - 6th Floor Tower
Olathe, Kansas 66061
Mr. George R. Laughead, Chairman
Board of Commissioners
Housing Authority
407 E. Bend Avenue
Dodge City, Kansas 67801
Re: Procedure, Civil -- Immunity From Liability For
Volunteers of Certain Nonprofit Organizations --
Limitations; General Liability Insurance
Requirements
Synopsis: The intent of L. 1987, ch. 215 is to encourage
individuals to serve as volunteers for certain
nonprofit organizations by granting to the
volunteer immunity from liability for negligent
acts or omissions. There are limitations to this
immunity. For the act to apply, the organization
must carry general liability insurance which will
pay on behalf of the insured when an individual
suffers loss for which the insured is liable. The
exact amount and type of insurance required is to
be determined in light of the exposure to liability
which arises out of the organization's activities.
Cited herein: L. 1987, ch. 215, sec. 1 (to be
codified at K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 60-3601).
Dear Mr. Moore and Mr. Laughead:
As District Attorney for the Tenth Judicial District and as
Chairman of the Board of Commissioners, Dodge City Housing
Authority, respectively, you have each requested our opinion
regarding 1987 Senate Bill No. 28, L. 1987, ch. 215 (to be
codified at K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 60-3601). Your requests have
been consolidated to avoid duplicity. Specifically, you
inquire as to what insurance coverage can be cancelled by
nonprofit organizations in light of Senate Bill No. 28.
Protection from liability by Senate Bill No. 28 is afforded to
volunteers of those organizations which meet two criteria.
First, the organization must be a nonprofit organization. A
nonprofit organization is defined by L. 1987, ch. 215,
sec. 1(a)(1) as an organization "exempt from federal income
tax pursuant to section 501(c) of the Internal Revenue Code of
1986. . . ." The second threshold test is that the
organization must carry general liability insurance.
The term "general liability insurance" is not defiend by the
act. The courts have had occasion to construe general
liability insurance policies, however, their analysis has been
limited to whether indemnity is required by individuals'
specific insurance policies. We do not find a description of
what a general liability insurance policy is, or how it is
distinguished from policies which are not "general".
Given the purpose of Senate Bill No. 28, the legislature's
silence as to what constitutes general liability insurance is
no surprise. The act was not a means to restructure the
insurance coverage for nonprofit organizations. Rather, the
purpose of the act was to assist those organizations on
attracting qualified persons to serve as volunteers in various
capacities. The Special Committee on Tort Reform and
Liability Insurance noted that nonprofit organizations were
having difficulty finding and retaining persons to serve as
volunteer directors because of the fear of liability. Report
on Kansas Legislative Interim Studies to the 1987 Legislature
565, 583 (December 1986). By establishing immunity for
volunteers' negligent acts when liability insurance exists,
the committee believed that individuals would be encouraged to
act as volunteers, and yet the rights of injured plaintiffs
would be preserved. Committee Report, at 593.
Bearing in mind the legislative intent of the act, we believe
that the term "general liability insurance" cannot be given a
precise definition which can be used in all situations. Some
general guidelines are available, however. The Kansas
Commissioner of Insurance has discussed the act in Kansas
Nonprofit Organizations - What Should You Know About Senate
Bill No. 28, pp. 4-7 (June 1987). The commissioner notes
that the term "general liability insurance" includes coverage
for premises and operations liability, products and completed
operations liability, contract liability, personal injury
liability, and special events liability. Not included in
these types of coverages are insurance for losses in civil
rights claims, employment disputes, professional malpractice
suits, automobile and aircraft liability, fiduciary liability,
and workers' compensation claims. We believe that the exact
type and amount of insurance required should be determined in
light of the exposure to liability related to the
organization's functions.
Upon meeting the two threshold requirements, Senate Bill No.
28 provides for immunity from liability in two ways. First,
the volunteer is not liable for damages resulting from his own
acts or omissions. Section 1(b) of Chapter 215 provides that
this immunity does not apply if the volunteer's misconduct was
willful or wanton or intentionally tortious. If the volunteer
is insured against those types of acts, the individual is
liable only to the extent of coverage. In addition, if the
individual is required to be insured by law, then the immunity
does not apply, but the individual is liable only to the
extent of the insurance coverage. The second type of immunity
involves the volunteer's liability for acts or omissions of
others. Section 1(c) of Chapter 215 provides immunity for the
volunteer for acts or omissions of others unless the volunteer
authorizes, approves, ratifies or participates in willful or
wanton conduct or intentionally tortious conduct. In
addition, the immunity is not given if the volunteer is
required by law to be insured against such acts.
The grant of immunity does not extend to the organization
itself. The organization remains liable for damages, and the
percent of fault attributable to the volunteer is imputed to
the organization. Committee Report, at 593.
In conclusion, it is our opinion that the legislative intent
of L. 1987, ch. 215 is to encourage individuals to serve as
volunteers for certain nonprofit organizations by granting to
the volunteer immunity from liability for negligent acts or
omissions. There are limitations to this immunity. For the
act to apply, the organization must carry general liability
insurance which will pay on behalf of the named insured when
an individual suffers loss for which the insured is liable as
a result of their action which caused the loss. The exact
amount and type of insurance required is to be determined in
light of the exposure to liability which arises out of the
organization's activities.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mark W. Stafford
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MWS:bar

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.