Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-121

1987-121Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
August 17, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 121
Robert C. Foulston
700 Fourth Financial Center
Broadway at Douglas
Wichita, Kansas 67202
Re: Courts--Supreme Court--Qualifications of Justices
Courts--Court of Appeals--Qualifications of Judges
Synopsis: K.S.A. 20-105 provides that to be qualified to hold
the office of justice of the supreme court or judge
of the court of appeals, a person must have been
regularly admitted to practice law in Kansas and
have engaged in the active and continuous practice
of law for a period of at least ten years prior to
the date of appointment as justice or judge.
Though the strict definition of "active practice"
would require that the legal activities of the
person in question be pursued on a full-time basis
and constitute his regular business, the general
rule that statutory provisions imposing
qualifications for office should be construed in
favor of those seeking to hold office would serve
to soften this requirement. Thus, a potential
nominee need not be a full-time trial attorney to
be considered as actively engaged in the practice
of law, and is not automatically disqualified
merely for holding a position which does not
require legal expertise. Cited herein: K.S.A.
20-105; 20-3002; K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 22-3707.
Dear Mr.Foulston:
As Chairman of the Supreme Court Nominating Commission, you
request our opinion regarding the qualifications of several
potential nominees. Your specific questions are as follows:
"1. Is an administrative law judge working for the United
States performing duties as a hearing officer in and out of
Kansas qualified?
"2. Is a Systemic Branch Chief and Legal Analysis [sic], U.S.
Department of Housing and Urban Development qualified?
"3. Is an Equal Employment Specialist, U.S. Department of
Energy qualified?
"4. Is a Director of the Kansas State Equal Employment Office
qualified?
"5. Is the Special Assistant to the Regional Administrator
for the General Service Administration qualified?
"6. Is the Vice Chairman of the Kansas Parole Board qualified?
"7. Is a U.S. Army Judge Advocate teaching school courses in
military criminal law, procurement and industrial law
qualified?
"8. Does a Kansas attorney whose sole practice has been with
the U.S. Army Judge Advocate Corp outside of Kansas qualify?"
You inquire as to whether the potential nominees who are or
were engaged in these positions would be considered as
actively practicing law.
K.S.A. 20-105 prescribes qualifications for justices of the
Kansas Supreme Court [which qualifications also apply to
judges of the Kansas Court of Appeals (K.S.A. 20-3002)], and
provides as follows:
"No person shall be qualified to hold the
office of justice of the supreme court,
unless such person shall have been
regularly admitted to practice law in the
state of Kansas and has engaged in the
active and continuous practice of law,
as a lawyer, judge of a court of record
or any court in this state, full-time
teacher of law in an accredited law school
or any combination thereof for a period
of at least ten (10) years prior to the
date of appointment as justice."
(Emphasis added.)
In a previous opinion this office noted that the common
definition of the word "practice" is "to do or perform
habitually or customarily; to acquire or polish a skill; to
work at, especially as a profession "[The American Heritage
Dictionary, New College Edition (1976)], and that, consistent
with this definition, the Kansas Supreme Court construed the
term "actively performed legal services" contained in Supreme
Court Rule 703(a)(3) as requiring that the legal activities of
the person in question be pursued on a full-time basis and
constitute his regular business [In re Application of
Stormont, 238 Kan. 627, 629 (1986)]. See Attorney
General Opinion No. 86-160. It was also noted, however, that
had the Court been interpreting K.S.A. 20-105, a statute, it
may not have applied such a strict construction as it did to
its own rule. We stated that, as a general rule, "statutory
provisions imposing qualifications for office should be
construed [liberally] in favor of those seeking to hold
office;" citing 67 C.J.S., Officers §17 (1978). Thus, it
was concluded that an attorney need not be a trial lawyer to
be considered as actively engaged in the practice of law, and
that a nominee is not automatically disqualified merely for
holding certain positions. In other words, it is not the
position held which is determinative, but rather the functions
performed by the potential nominees while in those positions
and the degree of legal activity. Attorney General Opinion
No. 86-160.
Turning to your specific questions, we will address them in
the order in which they were asked.
"Is an administrative law judge working for the United States
performing duties as a hearing officer in and out of Kansas
qualified?"
K.S.A. 20-105 provides that the qualifying experience may be
gained as a lawyer, a judge of a court of record or any court
in this state, or a full-time teacher of law in an accredited
law school, or any combination of these three. For purposes
determining whether a federal administrative law judge is a
judge of a court of record or any court in this state, there
are two issues to be addressed: First, whether an
administrative body may be a court of record and second,
whether this experience must have been gained in the State of
Kansas. In Attorney General Opinion No. 86-7 we indicated
that "the grammatical structure of the statute leads one to
conclude that the qualifying experience as a judge must be
acquired in this state, while experience as a lawyer or law
school professor may be acquired outside the State of
Kansas." However, there is no indication that judicial
experience must be gained exclusively in the State of Kansas.
If the judge in question hears cases on a regular basis in
this state, hearing cases in other states as well should not
preclude him from consideration. However, we do not believe a
federal administrative law judge is a judge of a court of
record or any court in this state. The general definition of
a court of record is a court that is required to keep a record
of its proceedings, and that may fine or imprison. Black's
Law Dictionary, 319 (5th ed. 1979). Additionally, "[t]he
phrase 'court of record,' as employed in state statutes, has
been construed as restricted to state or federal courts within
the state in question." 21 C.J.S. Courts 55 (1940). Though
federal administrative law judges may be required to keep
records of the proceedings before them, we do not believe such
an administrative body may be classified as a "court" within
this state which may fine or imprison, at least for purposes
of qualifying as a judge of a court of record under K.S.A.
20-105.
This does not, however, necessarily preclude this individual
from being a qualified potential nominee. It is the opinion
of this office that a federal administrative law judge may
meet the qualification as a lawyer. The functions performed
by a hearing officer include analyzing legal arguments, making
conclusions of law, and drafting legal opinions. If the
Commission finds that these functions were performed on a
regular and continuous basis, it may find that the potential
nominee was engaged in the active practice of law as a
lawyer.
"Is a Systemic Branch Chief and Legal Analys[t], U.S.
Department of Housing and Urban Development qualified?"
As mentioned previously, the fact that a potential nominee has
held a particular position does not automatically qualify or
disqualify him. What is important is whether in a particular
position, the legal activities of the potential nominee were
pursued on a full-time basis and constituted his regular
business, i.e. whether he actively engaged in the practice
of law while holding that position. The nominee in question
here has stated that he performed legal analysis while engaged
in this position; indeed, the position title would indicate
that legal analysis is in the job description. Legal
analysis, legal research, and the giving of legal advice are
considered as much the practice of law as litigation. The
question here becomes the degree to which legal analysis was
made in this position; if on a regular basis, the practice was
active, if only incidentally, it was not.
"Is an Equal Employment specialist, U.S. Department of Energy
qualified?"
The above-considerations also apply here, however, it is our
opinion that the degree of legal analysis, research and advice
need not be as high as in the previous situation because the
position now in question was held for only a four month period.
"Is a Director of the Kansas State Equal Employment Office
qualified?"
Again, if the potential nominee can demonstrate continuous and
active legal research or legal analysis, the mere holding of
this position would not disqualify him. The potential nominee
states that no legal advice is given in this capacity, but
adds that the matters handled by him nevertheless draw upon
his legal training and experience. This also appears to be a
question of degree.
"Is the Special Assistant to the Regional Administrator for
the General Service Administration qualified?"
For purposes of this question, it is important to note that
the potential nominee clearly was engaged in the active and
continuous practice of law from September, 1972 to May, 1987.
It is only the last three months of the potential nominee's
career which is in question. We note also that K.S.A. 20-105
does not explicitly require that the 10 years of experience
immediately precede the appointment as justice or judge of
the appellate courts, though the spirit of the statute would
dictate that the experience be maintained up to the time of
appointment. The potential nominee states that his
appointment as Special Assistant entails legal and
administrative duties. Considering the circumstances outlined
above, it is our opinion that this particular short-term
appointment which requires some legal functions would not
serve to disqualify this potential nominee.
"Is the Vice Chairman of the Kansas Parole Board qualified?"
This potential nominee lists the duties of parole board
members as follows:
"We determine paroles for all inmates in
Kansas prisons; parole revocation
hearings; clemency and pardon
recommendations to the Governor; discharge
of parole and initial hearings. Case load
involves approximately 350 inmates monthly
with three Parole Board members. During
the hearings, we question the inmate,
review the facts of each case, programming
of inmate, and determine suitability of
the inmate to spend the remainder of his
sentence in society. We must weigh the
seriousness of the crime and societal
views and safety in this important
discretion."
Parole board members are not required to have legal
expertise. K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 22-3707. However, as stated in
Attorney General Opinion No. 86-160, "[t]hough the position
does not require legal expertise, it certainly does not
preclude one holding that position from practicing law and in
fact provides an ideal forum for one to do so." In Opinion
No. 86-160, we were discussing the position of Kansas
Corporation Commissioner who functions as a "hearing
officer." That instance is similar to the one now before us
in which the entire Parole Board sits as a kind of "hearing
officer" during revocation hearings and discharge of parole
and initial hearings. It is our understanding that the Parole
Board members make conclusions of law as well as findings of
fact in these hearings. While a Parole Board member may
practice law while in this position, the Nominating Commission
may desire additional information to determine whether this
particular Parole Board member actually did engage in the
active practice of law while employed in this position.
"Is a U.S. Army Judge Advocate teaching school courses in
military criminal law, procurement and industrial law
qualified?"
This office has not been provided with sufficient information
to adequately address this question. It would appear,
however, that if this potential nominee teaches law on a
full-time basis, and if the school for which he teaches is an
accredited law school, then he would be qualified. If not, he
may still qualify as a lawyer engaged in the active practice
of law, depending upon the degree of his legal activities.
"Does a Kansas attorney whose sole practice has been with the
U.S. Army Judge Advocate Corp. outside of Kansas qualify?"
It seems apparent that the functions performed by this
potential nominee from 1973 to present constitute the practice
of law and, judging from the nominee's statement, the practice
was active and continuous. The question appears to be whether
the fact that this person practiced in a state other than
Kansas has any bearing on his qualifications. In Attorney
General Opinion No. 86-7 we concluded that an attorney who has
been regularly admitted to practice law in the State of
Kansas, and who has engaged in the active and continuous
practice of law in Kansas or any other state for a period of
at least 10 years prior to his or her appointment as a justice
(or judge), is qualified to hold the office of justice of the
Kansas Supreme Court, or judge of the Kansas Court of
Appeals. We concur with that conclusion.
In summary, K.S.A. 20-105 provides that to be qualified to
hold the office of justice of the supreme court or judge of
the court of appeals, a person must have been regularly
admitted to practice law in Kansas and have engaged in the
active and continuous practice of law for a period of at least
ten years prior to the date of appointment as justice or
judge. Though the strict definition of "active practice"
would require that the legal activities of the person in
question be pursued on a full-time basis and constitute his
regular business, the general rule that statutory provisions
imposing qualifications for office should be construed in
favor of those seeking to hold office would serve to soften
this requirement. Thus, a potential nominee need not be a
full-time trial attorney to be considered as actively engaged
in the practice of law, and is not automatically disqualified
merely for holding a position which does not require legal
expertise.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.