Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-119

1987-119Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL August 12, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 119
Fred W. Rausch, Jr.
Suite 201, Ambassador Building
220 Southwest 33rd Street
Topeka, Kansas 66611
Re: Schools -- Organization, Powers and Finances of
Boards of Education -- Interlocal Agreements;
Duration of Agreements; Constitutionality of 1987
House Bill No. 2482, amending K.S.A. 72-8230 (L.
1987, ch. 276, § 1).
Synopsis: 1987 House Bill No. 2482 amends K.S.A. 72-8230 (L.
1987, ch. 276, § 1) to nullify the duration
provisions in existing school district interlocal
cooperation agreements concerning special education
services. In our opinion, this provision is not
unconstitutional. For a retrospective law to be
invalid, it must either be proscribed by state
constitution, which is not the case in Kansas, or
it 'must violate a constitutionally vested right.
School districts have no vested rights in
interlocal agreements as both school districts
and interlocal agreements are creatures of the
legislature. Therefore, the legislature has
authority to alter the provisions of existing
interlocal agreements. Cited herein: K.S.A.
72-8230, as amended by L. 1987, ch. 276, § 1;
Kan. Const. Art. 6, § 5; U.S. Const., Art.
10; Amend. XIV.
Dear Mr. Rausch:
As attorney for the High Plains Educational Cooperative No.
611, the Atchison-Jefferson Educational Cooperative, and the
Three Lakes Educational Cooperative, you request our opinion
on the constitutionality of 1987 House Bill No. 2482 (L. 1987,
ch. 276, § 1), amending K.S.A. 72-8230.
K.S.A. 72-8230(a) authorizes the boards of education of two or
more school districts to enter into interlocal cooperative
agreements "for the purpose of jointly and cooperatively
performing any of the services, duties, functions, activities,
obligations or responsibilities which are authorized or
required by law to be performed by school districts in this
state. . . ." Recent amendments to this statute, which are
retroactive in nature, provide that the duration of an
interlocal agreement for special education services is
perpetual:
"The duration of a school district
interlocal cooperation agreement for
joint or cooperative action in providing
special education services shall be
perpetual unless the agreement is
partially or completely terminated in
accordance with this provision. This
provision applies to every school
district interlocal cooperation
agreement for the provision of special
education services entered into under
authority of this section after the
effective date of this act and to every
such agreement entered into under this
section prior to the effective date of
this act, and extant on the effective date
of this act, regardless of any provisions
in such an agreement to the contrary."
K.S.A. 72-8230(a)(5)(A), as amended by L.
1987, ch. 276, § 1. (Emphasis added).
Prior to this amendment interlocal cooperative agreements
for special education services were limited to a term of at
least three years but no more than five years. The amendments
added by the 1987 legislature include procedures for partial
or complete termination by which approval by the State Board
of Education is required. (L. 1987, ch. 276, §1). Several
school districts have raised questions whether the
legislature's amendments nullifying the duration provisions in
existing agreements are constitutional.
Neither the Federal Constitution nor the Kansas Constitution
expressly prohibits retrospective legislation. "In the
absence of such an express constitutional inhibition,
retrospective laws are not prohibited as such." 16A Am.
Jur. 2d Constitutional Law, § 662; See Cohen v.
Beneficial Industrial Loan Corp., 337 U.S. 541, 69 S.Ct.
1221, 93 L.Ed. 1528 (1948). In fact, the Kansas Constitution
specifically authorizes the legislature to alter or abolish
interlocal agreements:
"Local public schools under the general
supervision of the state board of
education shall be maintained, developed
and operated by locally elected boards.
When authorized by law, such boards may
make and carry out agreements for
cooperative operation and administration
of educational programs under the general
supervision of the state board of
education, but such agreements shall be
subject to limitation, change or
termination by the legislature. Kan.
Const., Art. 6, § 5. (Emphasis added).
The legislature has reserved this authority in K.S.A.
72-8230. At the time the cooperatives you represent were
organized, the statute read as follows:
"Any such agreement shall be subject to
change or termination by the legislature."
K.S.A. 72-8230.
A similar provision is contained in the law as amended:
"A school district interlocal cooperation
agreement shall be subject to change or
termination by the legislature." K.S.A.
72-8230, as amended by L. 1987, ch. 276, §1.
Thus, the legislature has clearly declared its intent in
enacting K.S.A. 72-8230 and the 1987 amendment that it retains
the right to change or terminate agreements creating special
education interlocal cooperatives.
The question remains, however, whether the reservation of
these rights by the legislature is itself unconstitutional.
Though retrospective laws are not per se unconstitutional,
they are invalid when they violate another constitutional
provision. When a law impairs a constitutionally vested
right, such as the right to the obligation of contracts (U.S.
Const., Art. 1, § 10), or the right to due process of law
(U.S. Const., Amend. XIV), the law is invalid. 16A Am.
Jur. 2d Constitutional Law §§ 663, 664, 666, 668. K.S.A.
72-8230(a), as amended by L. 1987, ch. 276, § 1, does not
violate any vested right.
In Schumacher v. Rausch, 190 Kan. 239, 244 (1962), the
Kansas Supreme Court stated:
"[T]hat which is purely a creature of the
legislature is subject not only to the
legislative power to create, but also to
the legislative power to modify, dissolve
or abolish."
See Leek v. Theis, 217 Kan. 784, 802 (1975). Numerous
Kansas cases have held that school districts have no vested
rights and are therefore subject to modification by the
legislature.
"School districts are purely creatures of
the legislature and subject not only to
its power to create but its power to
modify or dissolve.
"There are no vested rights in the
existence of a school district." State,
ex rel. v. School District, 163 Kan.
650, Syl. 51 2,3 (1947).
See Board of Riley County Comm'rs v. City of Junction
City, 233 Kan. 947, 957 (1983). School districts have only
those powers expressly given by statute. See Attorney
General Opinion No. 81-216. Interlocal cooperatives formed
by school districts pursuant to statutory authority are also
creatures of the legislature. Since interlocal agreements
are subject to modification by the legislature, school
districts have no vested rights to the duration of these
agreements.
In summary, 1987 House Bill No. 2482 amends K.S.A. 72-8230 (L.
1987, ch. 276, §1) to nullify the duration provisions in
existing school district interlocal cooperation agreements
concerning special education services. In our opinion, this
provision is not unconstitutional. For a retrospective law to
be invalid, it must either be proscribed by state
constitution, which is not the case in Kansas, or it must
violate a constitutionally vested right. School districts
have no vested rights in interlocal agreements as both are
creatures of the legislature. Therefore, the legislature has
authority to alter the provisions of existing interlocal
agreements.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:bas

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.