Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-110

1987-110Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL July 27, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 110
Charles V. Hamm
Special Assistant to the Secretary
Department of Health and Environment
Forbes Field
Topeka, Kansas 66620
Re: Public Health--Maternity Hospitals or Homes and
Homes for Children--Attorney General Opinion No.
86-163
Synopsis: The Kansas Department of Health and Environment
does not violate the due process rights of an
employee suspected of child abuse when it issues an
emergency order suspending a day care facility's
license, even though such action may result in the
employee being terminated from employment. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 38-1523(e); 65-504(d); 65-516, as
amended by L. 1987, ch. 233, § 1; 65-524
*
Dear Mr. Hamm:
As Special Assistant to the Secretary of the Department of
Health and Environment, you request our opinion regarding due
process. Specifically, you ask whether, in light of Attorney
General Opinion No. 86-163, the Kansas Department of Health
and Environment (KDHE) violates the due process rights of an
employee suspected of child abuse when it issues an emergency
order suspending a day care facility's license when that
action results in the employee being terminated from
employment. You explain the situation as follows:
"K.S.A. 05-524 authorizes the Secretary to:
'[S]uspend any license, certificate of
registration, or temporary permit issued
under K.S.A. 65-501 to 65-522, inclusive,
and amendments thereto prior to any
hearing when, in the opinion of the
secretary, the action is necessary to
protect any child in the boarding home for
children or family day care home from
physical or mental abuse, abandonment or
any other substantial threat to health or
safety. . . . 1
"K.S.A. 38-1523(e) requires the Department of Social and
Rehabilitation Services (SRS) to promptly report to KDHE
'any investigation involving a facility subject to licensing
or regulation by the secretary of health and environment.'
"If, after reviewing SRS's investigation report, the
Secretary determines that the presence in the day care
facility of an employee who is suspected of child abuse poses
a substantial threat to the health and safety of children in
the licensee's care, an order is issued immediately suspending
the license. The day care home provider is at this point
faced with the option of discharging or suspending the
employee or lose[ing] its license. In other words, an
employee could be fired from his/her employment based on an
investigation and prior to being given notice and an
opportunity to be heard."
In our opinion, the scenario you describe is distinguishable
from that discussed in Attorney General Opinion No. 86-163.
In that case, "validated" individuals were automatically
excluded from employment at these types of homes pursuant to
K.S.A. 65-516. That is, the licensee had no choice but to
fire the individual upon learning that the individual had been
validated. Failure to do so would have been in direct
violation of the statute, and would have subjected the
licensee to license revocation pursuant to K.S.A. 65-504(d).
In the instant case, however, a suspension order is issued in
order to protect the child or children from possible harm.
The licensee is afforded due process after the suspension,
pursuant to the emergency adjudicative proceedings of the
Kansas administrative procedure act. At this point, the
licensee merely needs to show that the danger no longer
exists. This end may be accomplished through many means. For
instance, the employee could be given a leave of absence until
such time as SRS concludes its investigation. Or, as an
alternative, if the licensee believes that the employee does
pose a threat to the safety of those children at the facility,
the licensee could fire the employee for cause. In either
case, the action affecting the employee is at the hands of the
licensee, not the State.
The due process rights of the employee do not attach unless
and until the employee is validated by SRS and then is
subsequently fired. Validation consists of SRS placing the
alleged perpetrator's name in a registry as a child abuser.
This registry is shared by government agencies for a variety
of purposes. Validation in conjunction with termination is
sufficient to pass the "stigma-plus" test, as discussed in
Paul v. Davis, 424 U.S. 693 (1976), thereby necessitating
that due process rights are afforded before validation.
See Attorney General Opinion No. 86-163. The first of these
two components, state action creating a stigma, is not present
in the situation you describe. To help insure that this is
so, any emergency hearing conducted by KDHE to temporarily
suspend a license should be conducted in a fashion consistent
with the Kansas Open Meetings Act, K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq.,
yet affording the individual employee sufficient privacy.
In conclusion, the Department of Health and Environment does
not violate the due process rights of an employee suspected of
child abuse when it issues an emergency order suspending a day
care facility's license, even if that action results in the
employee being terminated from employment.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T.
STEPHAN	AttorneyGeneralofKansas
Julene L. Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.