Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-101

1987-101Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
July 14, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 101
Phillip A. Burdick
Brown County Attorney
112 South 7th Street
Hiawatha, KS 66434
Re: Crimes and Punishment -- Code; Crimes
Against the Public Morals -- Pull Tab
Games on Indian Reservations
Synopsis: The term "lottery" includes pull tab games and any
game or combination of games involving
consideration, chance and a prize. The
constitutional amendment permitting a state owned
and operated lottery is civil/regulatory in nature
and therefore may not be enforced against Indians
conducting lottery games on Indian reservations
within Kansas. Cited herein: K.S.A. 21-4302; L.
1986, ch. 414; Kan. Const., Art. 15, §§3b, 3c.
*
Dear Mr. Burdick:
You request our opinion as to the effect Kansas Constitution
Article, 15, section 3c, the "lottery" amendment, will have on
the legality of pull tab gaming on the Iowa tribe Indian
reservation in Kansas.
Before we answer the question of legality, a more fundamental
question must first be answered. Does the term "lottery" as
used in the Kansas lottery amendment include "pull tab" type
games?
The constitutional provision as voted on and passed by the
Kansas electorate did not define or restrict the term lottery
nor did it define or restrict itself to any specific games.
Thus, definitional responsibility of defining lottery was
passed to the courts of the state. In construing
constitutional provisions, the Supreme Court of Kansas has
stated in State, ex rel. v. Highwood Services, Inc., 205
Kan. 821, 825 (1970):
"[A] constitution is not to be narrowly
or technically construed but its
language should be held to mean what
the words imply to the common
understanding of men; that in
ascertaining the meaning of
constitutional provisions courts should
consider what appears to have been the
intendment and understanding of the
people at their adoption." (Citations
omitted).
In Highwood, the court's research included lottery
definitions from Abbott's Law Dictionary (1879), Webster's
Third New International Dictionary, unabridged, (1964), the
Oxford Illustrated Dictionary (1962) and the Random House
Dictionary of the English language, the Unabridged Edition
(1976). Thus, in defining the term "lottery" the court has
adopted common usage definitions of lottery:
"'a scheme for the distribution of
prizes by lot or chance; esp.: a
scheme by which prizes are distributed
to the winners among those persons who
have paid for a chance to win them,
usu. as determined by the numbers on
tickets as drawn at random (as from a
lottery wheel).'"
The court further refined the various definitions into three
required elements in order to be recognized as a lottery in
Kansas. "The court has held that the essential elements of a
lottery are three: (1) consideration, (2) prize, and (3)
chance." Highwood, 205 Kan. at 823. Using this three
element definition the court had adhered to the constitutional
provision banning lotteries and struck down such efforts prior
to the enactment of Kan. Const. Art. 15, sec. 3c. The
State, ex rel v. Mercantile Association, 45 Kan. 351 (1891)
[distribution of prizes by chance]; In re Smith, Petitioner,
54 Kan. 702 (1895) [sale of lottery tickets]; State ex
rel., v. Fox Kansas Theatre Co., 144 Kan. 687 (1936)
[theater bank night]; City of Wichita v. Stevens, 167 Kan.
408 (1949) [punchboards]; State v. Brown, 173 Kan. 166
(1952) [punchboards].
In considering the lottery provision, numerous individuals and
state agencies advanced definitions for the term lottery.
Included in the minutes were reports that "new forms of
lottery games are constantly being invented," Minutes of the
House Federal and State Affairs Committee, January 16, 1986,
testimony of Russ Mills, Legislative Research Department,
Attachment A., and "there are currently several types of
lottery products being played ... weekly game or draw lottery
... instant lottery ticket ... online system ... numbers
game ... pick four." Minutes of the House Federal and State
Affairs Committee, January 16, 1986, testimony of Secretary of
Revenue Harley Duncan, Attachment B.
It was further presented that some states have restricted
their lottery to specific games. Minutes of the House Federal
and State Affairs Committee, January 21, 1986, testimony of
Patrick J. Hurley, Attachment C. The Kansas Legislature
did not preclude any specific game or games with the
language used in 1986 Senate Concurrent Resolution 1609, L.
1986, ch. 414. (Emphasis added).
In our judgment the game of "pull tabs" would fall within the
scope of the Kansas constitutional lottery amendment since it
is an unrestricted provision.
In Attorney General Opinion No. 87-38, this office indicated
that:
"The lottery could include both an
active game and a passive game. An
active game has been recognized as a
lottery game in which the player takes
action to determine the outcome by
choosing a number or set of numbers to
bet on, attempting to match the numbers
later drawn. A passive game is a
lottery game in which the player takes
no active part in determining the
outcome; the ticket sold is either a
winner or a loser, and no choices of
numbers are made. Minutes of the House
Federal and State Affairs Committee,
January 16, 1986, testimony of
Secretary of Revenue Harley
Duncan. Attachment B."
To be recognized as a lottery, three essential elements must
be present in either an active or a passive game, (1)
consideration, (2) prize and (3) chance. K.S.A. 21-4302)2).
In an earlier case, Iowa Tribe of Indians of Kansas and
Nebraska v. State of Kansas, 787 F.2d 1434 (10th Cir.
1986), the United States Court of Appeals defined "pull tabs"
as a game of chance wherein a factory sealed cover is removed
from a paper card to reveal what if any prize is won. Hence,
"pull tab" games squarely fit into the description of passive
game as set forth above and would constitute a lottery.
This office sees no great dissimilarity in removing a factory
sealed cover from a paper card as compared to scratching out a
latex box on a paper ticket similar to those currently used in
the Missouri, Iowa and Illinois instant lotteries.
Having determined the Kansas lottery amendment to be inclusive
of pull tab games, we now turn our attention to the legality
of these pull tab games on the Iowa tribe Indian reservation
in Kansas. The issue of legality turns on whether the lottery
amendment is prohibitory or regulatory in nature.
Prior to 1974, the operation of all forms of lotteries,
including bingo, was expressly prohibited under the provisions
of Article 15, Section 3 of the Kansas Constitution. State,
ex rel., v. Kalb, 218 Kan. 459, 465 (1975). In 1974, the
Kansas Constitution was amended to permit the playing of bingo
by certain specified organizations. In 1987 the Kansas
Constitution was again amended to permit not only a state
owned lottery but also to allow for parimutuel betting on
horse and dog racing.
In the recent case State of California, et al. v. Cabazon
Bank of Mission Indians, 107 S.Ct. 1083 (1987), the Supreme
Court upheld the right of Indian tribes to engage in, or
license and regulate, gaming activities on the reservations
free of state licensing and regulation. The court noted that
this right arises, under Federal Indian Law, where a state
permits this kind of activity and regulates it as a matter of
civil/regulatory law.
In Cabazon, supra, California had attempted to prohibit
bingo games on Indian Reservations in that state. The Federal
District Court held that neither the state nor the county had
any authority to enforce its gambling laws within the
reservations. The Court of Appeals affirmed.
In affirming the judgment of the Court of Appeals the Supreme
Court applied a shorthand test of whether the conduct at issue
violates the state's public policy. The Supreme Court relied
on the Court of Appeals reasoning that if the intent of a
state law is generally to prohibit certain conduct it will be
criminal/prohibitory in nature. However, if the state law
generally permits the conduct at issue, subject to regulation,
it will be classified as civil/regulatory and therefore
unenforceable on Indian reservations. In deciding that the
California bingo statute was civil/regulatory in nature, the
Supreme Court noted that California does not prohibit all
forms of gambling. The court noted further that California
operates a state lottery and encourages its citizens to
participate in this state run gambling. Also the court noted
that California permits parimutuel horse race betting.
Finally the court stated:
"In light of the fact that California
permits a substantial amount of gambling
activity, including bingo, and actually
promotes gambling through its state
lottery, we must conclude that California
regulates rather than prohibits gambling
in general."
With the adoption of the state "lottery" amendment, Kan.
Const., Art. 15, §§3b and 3c, Kansas now provides for state
owned and operated lotteries as well the regulation of
parimutuel betting on horse and dog racing. Adopting the
Supreme Court's rationale in Cabazon and applying it to
the Kansas "lottery" amendment we see that Kansas, like
California, no longer prohibits all forms of gambling. As in
Cabazon where California operated a state lottery and
encouraged its citizens to participate, so too will Kansas
operate a state lottery and encourage participation. The
court also noted in Cabazon that California allows
parimutuel betting on horse races. Similarly Kan.
Const., Art. 15, §3b allows parimutuel betting on horse
anddog racing.
With the passage of the state "lottery" amendment,
participation in this state-run gambling is no longer
contrary to the public policy of the state. The "lottery"
amendment now permits rather than prohibits, subject to
regulation, lotteries as well as parimutuel betting on dog and
horse racing in Kansas. Accordingly the "lottery" amendment
must be considered civil/regulatory in nature rather than
criminal/prohibitory. We are compelled by the ruling in the
Cabazon case to conclude that the Kansas lottery amendment
may not be enforced against Indians conducting lottery games
upon Indian reservations within the territorial boundaries of
the State of Kansas.
It is therefore our opinion that the definition of lottery
includes the game of pull tabs and any game or combination of
games as long as there is consideration, chance and prize
involved in each game. Further, it is our opinion that the
state lottery amendment is civil/regulatory in nature, and
therefore, provisions relating to the conduct of lottery games
by Indians on reservations may not be enforced.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Brenda L. Braden
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:BLB:cy

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.