Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-072

1987-072Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL April 27, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 72
The Honorable Rick Bowden
State Representative, Ninety-Third District
State Capitol, Room 281-W
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas -- Suffrage --
Qualifications of Electors
Synopsis: 1987 House Bill No. 2273 defines "qualified
elector" for purposes of municipal bond elections
to include any person 18 years of age or over
owning land within the limits of the municipality,
even if that person is not a resident therein.
Applying this definition of "qualified elector" to
all municipal bond elections would violate Article
5, § 1 of the Kansas Constitution. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 10-120; K.S.A. 12-105; K.S.A.
1986 Supp. 19-27a03; K.S.A. 19-3802; 24-410;
24-507; 24-605; 82a-602; 82a-1021(e); Ks.
Const., Art. 5, § 1; Art. 11, § 7.
*
Dear Representative Bowden:
As state representative from the ninety-third district, you
request our opinion on the constitutionality of 1987 House
Bill No. 2273. The legal issue you raise is whether the
definition of "qualified elector" contained in the bill is
constitutional.
1987 House Bill No. 2273 amends K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 10-120 by
adding a new subsection (c) to the statute, which provides:
"Whenever any election is held in any
municipality upon the matter of the
issuance of bonds for any purpose by the
municipality, all qualified electors
shall be entitled to vote. As used in
this subsection:
"(1) 'Qualified elector' means any
qualified elector of the district and any
person 18 years of age or over owning land
within the limits of the municipality,
although not a resident therein, or
owning tangible personal property within
the district and having residence within
such district; . . . ." (Emphasis added)
By contrast, Article 5, § 1 of the Kansas Constitution
provides:
"Every citizen of the United States who
has attained the age of eighteen years and
who resides in the voting area in which
he or she seeks to vote shall be deemed a
qualified elector." (Emphasis added).
The Kansas Constitution requires that a person reside in the
voting area in which he or she seeks to vote to be deemed a
qualified elector. The definition of "qualified elector" in
1987 House Bill No. 2273 extends the voter franchise in
municipal bond elections to a greater number of individuals
than allowed by the constitution, by removing the residency
requirement for persons 18 years of age or older who own
property within the municipality in which the election is held.
To determine the issue of constitutionality which you raise,
it is necessary to examine the history of municipalities.
K.S.A. 12-105a defines "municipality" to mean:
"county, township, city, school district
of whatever name or nature, community
junior college, municipal university,
drainage district, cemetery district, fire
district, and other political subdivision
or taxing unit, . . . ."
The existence of some types of municipalities, such as
counties, townships, or cities, was clearly contemplated by
the framers of the constitution. However, other types of
municipalities were created by the legislature, and therefore
their existence could not have been contemplated by the
constitutional convention. These municipalities would include
drainage districts (K.S.A. 24-410; 24-507; 24-605); sewer
districts, which can be formed upon petition of property
owners (K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 19-27a03); groundwater management
districts (K.S.A. 82a-1021(e)); industrial districts (K.S.A.
19-3802); and rural water supply districts (K.S.A. 82a-602).
Relevant statutes dealing with elections in these
statutorily-created municipalities contain language which
deviates from Article 5, § 1 by removing the residency
requirement for a "qualified elector." For example, K.S.A.
24-410, the statute which addresses who may vote at drainage
district elections, provides:
"'Qualified elector' means any qualified
elector of the district and any person
eighteen (18) years of age or over owning
land within the district, although not a
resident therein, or owning tangible
personal property within the district and
having residence within such district."
(Emphasis added).
We note that this definition is nearly identical to that
contained in 1987 House Bill No. 2273, and that Attorney
General Curt T. Schneider was asked to opine on the
constitutionality of defining "qualified elector" in this
manner for purposes of drainage district elections when the
language was added to K.S.A. 24-410 in 1971. (See 1971
House Bill No. 1968). In a letter opinion to Representative
Roger Turner, dated January 31, 1972, General Schneider
determined that such an extension of the voter franchise in
drainage district elections was constitutional. However, in
our opinion, the reasoning used by General Schneider to
reach this conclusion cannot be applied on a broad basis to
all municipalities.
The letter opinion cited to the early Kansas Supreme Court
decision The State v. Monahan, 72 Kan. 492 (1905), in
which the court stated:
"The elections held to choose officers of
a drainage district or to pass upon the
expediency of proposed improvements
designed for protection against floods are
not merely other elections than those
provided for in the constitution; they
are of a different character from any
therein referred to, and so far dissimilar
in their nature that it cannot be supposed
that they were within the contemplation of
the constitutional convention when the
qualifications of electors were under
consideration by that body." 72 Kan.
at 501. (Emphasis added).
Since the Kansas Supreme Court had previously determined that
drainage district elections were not within the contemplation
of the constitutional convention when the qualifications of
electors were under consideration by that body, General
Schneider concluded that the legislature was free to provide
different or more restrictive qualifications for exercise of
the franchise in drainage district elections than those
prescribed by Article 5, § 1 of the Kansas Constitution, as
long as no other applicable state or federal constitutional
right was infringed upon. Therefore, he found the language in
1971 House Bill No. 1968, which allowed "qualified elector" to
include any person eighteen years of age or over owning land
within a drainage district, although not a resident therein,
to be constitutional.
We concur with General Schneider's opinion in regard to
drainage district elections, and believe similar reasoning can
be applied to other municipalities which are purely creatures
of the legislature and which were not within the contemplation
of the constitutional framers when they were considering the
constitutional qualifications of a "qualified elector."
However, 1987 House Bill No. 2273 seeks to extend the voter
franchise in all municipal bond elections by defining
"qualified elector" to include non-resident persons who own
land within the limits of the municipality. In our judgment,
such a broad application of this definition violates Article
5, § 1 of the Kansas Constitution, as it is clear that the
existence of some types of municipalities was contemplated by
the constitutional framers.
For example, Article 2, § 21 of the Kansas Constitution allows
the legislature to confer powers of local legislation and
administration upon political subdivisions. From this
constitutional provision, we draw two conclusions. First,
that the existence of certain municipalities, which are
political subdivisions of the State, was contemplated by the
constitutional convention, and second, that municipal bond
elections fall within the "powers of local legislation and
administration" which the constitution allows the legislature
to confer upon political subdivisions.
We also find it noteworthy to examine Article 11, § 7 of the
Kansas Constitution, which provides:
"No debt shall be contracted by the state
. . . unless the proposed law for creating
such debt shall first be submitted to a
direct vote of the electors of the state
at some general election; . . . ."
Thus, while the constitutional framers may not have
contemplated municipal bond elections, it is clear that they
anticipated elections on indebtedness by the State. Since a
municipality is a political subdivision of the State, it is at
least arguable that the framers contemplated some type of
indebtedness elections by municipalities.
In light of the aforementioned constitutional provisions, we
conclude that the residency requirement for a "qualified
elector" set forth in Article 5, § 1 of the Kansas
Constitution applies to those municipalities the existence of
which was contemplated by the constitutional convention.
Accordingly, we find the definition of "qualified elector"
contained in 1987 House Bill No. 2273, which attempts to
extend the voter franchise in municipal bond elections of all
municipalities, to be unconstitutional.
In summary, 1987 House Bill No. 2273 defines "qualified
elector" for purposes of municipal bond elections to include
any person 18 years of age or over owning land within the
limits of the municipality, even if that person is not a
resident therein. Applying this definition of "qualified
elector" to all municipal bond elections would violate
Article 5, § 1 of the Kansas Constitution.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:BPA:bas

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.