Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-048

1987-048Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
March 19, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 48
The Honorable Ron Fox
Representative, Twenty-First District
State Capitol, Room 112-S
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Intoxicating Liquors and Beverages -- General
Provisions -- Single-Classification Beer
Synopsis: According to Kansas case law, the Kansas
legislature has the power to define all beer
containing less than 5% alcohol by weight as a
cereal malt beverage (CMB). The legislature may
allow the sale of this "5% CMB" by all entities
currently allowed to sell CMB, as well as by
retail liquor stores currently restricted to the
sale of "strong" beer. Whether a county voted for
or against the 1986 constitutional amendment
allowing liquor-by-the-drink in certain
establishments open to the public has no bearing on
this conclusion. Cited herein: K.S.A. 41-101;
41-102; 41-103; 41-211; 41-2701 et seq.; L.
1937, ch. 214; L. 1949, ch. 242, §§ 1-125;
Kan. Const., Art. 15, § 10.
Dear Representative Fox:
As Representative for the Twenty-First District, you request
our opinion regarding legislative powers. Specifically, you
ask whether the legislature has the power to (1) redefine all
beer, containing less than 5% alcohol by weight, as cereal
malt beverage (CMB), and (2) allow this "5% CMB" to be
sold by all entities currently allowed to sell CMB, as well
as by those establishments which currently are restricted to
the sale of "strong beer." You cite the December 8, 1986
KBI laboratory report regarding the differences between 3.2%
CMB and "strong" beer, and state that the difference between
the two is "almost insignificant." You also indicate that a
constitutional question regarding the voters' "common
understanding" of the definition of "alcoholic beverage" may
be at issue.
"Laws prohibiting the sale and use of intoxicating liquors
were cradled in Kansas." U.S. v. Robason, 38 F. Supp.
991, 997 (D. Kan. 1941). "Kansas has been one of the
pioneers, first in the regulation, and second in the
prohibition of the beverage liquor traffic. Indeed as early
as 1855, her Territorial Legislature passed acts regulating
such traffic." Robason, at 992. The history of Kansas'
treatment of alcohol is important to an understanding of the
application of case law to proposed single-classification
legislation. An appropriate and interesting historical review
is provided in: The Intoxicating Liquor Cases, 25 Kan.
751 (1881) (Justice Brewer); State, ex rel., v. Owston,
138 Kan. 173 (1933); State, ex rel., Schneider v.
Kennedy, 225 Kan. 1, 13; "Wyatt Earp and the
Winelist: Is a Restaurant an 'Open Saloon?'," Barkley
Clark, 47 J.B.A.K. 63 (1978); and Prohibition in Kansas: A
History, Robert Smith Bader, University of KS Press
(1986).
K.S.A. 41-102 states in part:
"As used in [the liquor control] act,
unless the context clearly requires
otherwise:
"(b) 'Alcoholic liquor' means alcohol,
spirits, wine, beer and every liquid or
solid, patented or not, containing
alcohol, spirits, wine or beer and capable
of being consumed as a beverage by a human
being, but shall not include any beer or
cereal malt beverage containing not more
than 3.2% alcohol by weight.
"(c) 'Beer,' when its meaning is not
enlarged, modified, or limited by other
words, means a beverage, containing more
than 3.2% alcohol by weight, obtained by
alcoholic fermentation of an infusion or
concoction of barley, or other grain, malt
and hops in water and includes beer, ale,
stout, lager beer, porter and similar
beverages having such alcoholic content."
K.S.A. 41-2701(a) states:
"As used in this act unless the context
otherwise requires:
"(a) 'Cereal malt beverage' means any
fermented but undistilled liquor brewed
or made from malt or from a mixture of
malt or malt substitute, but does not
include any such liquor which is more than
3.2% alcohol by weight."
The question whether 3.2% beer should be deemed by the courts
as intoxicating has been addressed many times by the Kansas
Supreme Court. See, e.g., City of Topeka v. Zufall, 40
Kan. 47 (1888); State v. Schaefer. 44 Kan. 90 (1890).
The most current view taken by the courts emerged in The -
Intoxicating Liquor Cases, 25 Kan. 751 (1881), where the
Court made the distinction between beverages "containing
enough alcohol to produce intoxication . . . but
. . . not [considered an] intoxicating liquor," and those
beverages which are deemed to be intoxicating, 25 Kan. at
766. The Intoxicating Liquor Cases Court stated that "[t]he
courts ma not sa as a matter of law that the presence of a
certain per cent of alcohol brings the compound within the
prohibition, or that any particular ingredient does or does
not destroy the intoxicating influence of the alcohol, or
prevent it from ever being an alcoholic beverage," 25 Kan.
at 768. (Emphasis added.)
In State v. Owston, 138 Kan. 173 (1933), the defendants were
enjoined from selling a beverage commonly known as 3.2% beer.
The Kansas Supreme Court held, under the state law then in
effect, that this malt beverage was presumed to be
intoxicating, but that this presumption could be met by
evidence that it was not intoxicating as a matter of fact.
State v. Miller, 92 Kan. 994 (1914), was cited by
Owston: "The defendant in that case was asking the court
to overlook what everybody knew -- that is, that Jamaica
ginger was commonly sold and used as an intoxicating liquor,
[j]ust because in [The Intoxicating Liquor Cases, decided]
some thirty years previously, the court had predicted that
tinctures such as Jamaica ginger would never be used as
beverages. The [Miller] court refused to do this and simply
held that plain whisky, brandy, gin, wine or beer or other
spiritous, malt, vinous or fermented liquors of the kind
specifically mentioned in the statute shall be construed and
held to be intoxicating. At the time that opinion was
written, the beer commonly sold was intoxicating and every
grown person knew it. That opinion, however, could not be
cited as an authority that a defendant charged with selling
beer could not offer evidence to prove that what he sold was
not intoxicating." 138 Kan. at 181, 182. (Emphasis added).
In dicta, the Owston court invited the legislature to define
those beverages to be deemed as intoxicating. The court
considered a statement made in City of Topeka v.
Heberling, 134 Kan. 330 (1931), which reads: "Such a
liquid, when containing three or more per cent of alcohol,
would be considered as intoxicating." 134 Kan. at 330. The
Owston court determined that:
"It was not intended by the district court
or by this court to fix a percentage
standard for determining intoxicating
quality without regard to fact. What the
sentence meant was that, for the purposes
of the case on trial, such a liquid, when
containing three or more percent of
alcohol, would be considered -- this is,
presumed -- to be intoxicating, in the
absence of proof to the contrary.
"Many cases have been cited wherein it has
been held that beer was presumed to be
intoxicating, but never one that has held
that this presumption could not be
contradicted by evidence. Throughout the
years this has been the law as announced
by this court . . . . Had the
legislature been dissatisfied with that
interpretation of the statute it would
have been changed before this. The matter
could have been settled by the legislature
providing just what per cent of alcoholic
content would render a beverage
intoxicating. The legislature could
easily have provided that any malt liquor
should not be sold regardless of whether
it was intoxicating. Neither has been
done." 138 Kan. at 183. (Emphasis
added).
The 1937 Kansas legislature responded to the above-quoted
Owston dicta. Prior to 1937, all beer was presumed to be
intoxicating. Owston reiterated this rule. In 1937, the
legislature defined "intoxicating liquor" as excluding 3.2%
beer. L. 1937, ch. 214, now codified as K.S.A. 41-2701
et seq. This legislation was not affected by the 1948
constitutional amendment to Kansas prohibition (Article 15, §
10 of the Kansas Constitution, as adopted by the people of
Kansas on November 2, 1948), nor the 1949 Kansas Liquor
Control Act (L.1949, ch. 242, c§ 1-125). The "3.2% CMB"
laws have been upheld before and after the 1948 "open saloon"
constitutional provision. See Johnson v. Reno County
Commissioners, 147 Kan. 211, 216 (1938); Horyna v. Board
of County Commissioners, 194 Kan. 445 (1965); Lindquist
v. City of Lindsborg, 165 Kan. 212, 216 (1948); and
Schneider v. Kennedy, 225 Kan. 1, 13 (1978).
"Implicit in these decisions is the conclusion that a tavern
selling 3.2% beer is not an 'open saloon,' because the -
legislature has determined that 3.2% beer is not an
'intoxicating liquor.' And yet, will anyone deny that 3.2%
beer is an intoxicating liquor?" "Wyatt Earp and the Wine
List," 47 J.B.A.K. at 75.
No one can deny that 3.2% beer is intoxicating. However, the
issue is not what alcoholic liquor actually is, nor what
people may think it is, but that the court has allowed the
legislature to define what it is, within reason. Based on
this precedent, it is our opinion that the legislature has the
power to redefine all beer containing less than 5% alcohol by
weight as a non-intoxicating cereal malt beverage. Seek
e.g. Tenn. Code Ann. § 57-3-101 (1986) (excludes 5% beer
from its definition of "alcoholic beverage"); Iowa Code §
123.3(a). (It should be noted that if a 5% CMB definition
is challenged, the Court could set aside its earlier line of
reasoning due to current societal concerns with driving under
the influence, etc. If this were to happen, the legislature
may lose the 3.2% definition as well.)
As a consequence of this power to define 5% beer as
non-intoxicating, other issues arise, such as whether "5%
CMB" may be sold at liquor stores as well as grocery stores
and beer taverns. It is our opinion that this could be done,
though the statutory restrictions proscribing CMB sales in
certain establishments would have to be altered by
legislation, i.e. K.S.A. 41-103. Also, the question arises as
to whether there are any limits to this legislative power.
The legislature is limited by the standard of reasonableness.
Would "5% CMB" legislation fall reasonably within the
parameters of Article 15, Section 10, and 3.2% CMB case
law? While a truly reasonable definition would include as an
intoxicating liquor any beverage containing any alcohol that
has the effect of intoxication, the applicable standard is one
of mere reason, one that survives the above-cited
constitutional and case law. A definition of 5% beer as
cereal malt beverage, in our opinion, meets the current
applicable standards.
In reference to the law in effect prior to the November, 1986
constitutional amendment and subsequent implementing
legislation thereof, the issue arises as to the effect of the
"open saloon" prohibition and "liquor by the drink" enactments
when a person purchases a glass of beer. The argument could
be made that the voters in 1948 and in November, 1986
understood at the time they cast their respective ballots that
3.2% CMB is not intoxicating. This argument is defeated by
the concept that (1) everyone knows that 3.2% CMB is -
intoxicating, and (2) aside from fact and common knowledge,
the legislature's power to change the percentage definitions
existed both before and after each of these elections. Thus,
this question has no bearing on the power of the legislature
to define CMB.
CMB sales used to be allowable to 18-year olds. By July
1, 1987, when any legislation regarding 5% CMB would likely
go into effect, only those persons 21 years and older will be
able to purchase CMB or other intoxicants. See K.S.A.
41-2701(g). Again, though persuasive in determining whether
5% beer should be classified as a CMB, this issue has no
bearing on the question of the legislature's ability to define
5% beer as a CMB.
In conclusion, the Kansas Supreme Court has never defined
"intoxicating liquor" for purposes of Art. 15, § Sec. 10 of
the Kansas Constitution. The Kansas Supreme Court in
Owston indicated that the legislature may define
intoxicating liquor and cereal malt beverage, within reason.
Kansas courts have not found the legislature's definition of
3.2% beer as non-intoxicating to be invalid.
Based upon the preceding, it is our opinion that the Kansas
legislature has the power to define all beer containing less
than 5% alcohol by weight as a non-intoxicating cereal malt
beverage (CMB). The legislature may allow the sale of this
"5% CMB" by all entities which currently sell CMB, as well
as by retail liquor stores currently restricted to the sale of
"strong" beer.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Thomas R. Lietz
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TRL:bas

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.