Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-042

1987-042Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
AT TO RNEY GENERAL March 5, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 42
The Honorable Dale M. Sprague
State Representative, Seventy-Third District
State Capitol, Room 112-S
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Public Health -- Healing Arts; Kansas Healing Arts
Act -- Doctors of Chiropractic; "Chiropractic
Physicians"
Synopsis: Under the Kansas statutes the term "physician"
means a person licensed to practice medicine and
surgery unless it is defined otherwise. See,
e.g., K.S.A 65-2869. In addition, when
"physician" is used in conjunction with another
word, the health care provider is deemed to be one
licensed to practice medicine and surgery. See
65-2870; 65-2897a. Chiropractors are specifically
prohibited by statute from practicing medicine and
surgery. K.S.A. 65-2871. Thus, the term
"chiropractic physician" is misleading to the
public as it implies that a chiropractor is
licensed to practice beyond the scope of the
statutory definition of chiropractic. Therefore,
it is our opinion that doctors of chiropractic
cannot use the term "chiropractic physician."
Cited herein: K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 8-1001; 17-2707;
K.S.A. 40-2101; 40-3103; 44-508; K.S.A. 1986
Supp. 59-2902; K.S.A. 60-427; 65-1,114; 65-448;
65-5a01; 65-6b01; 65-2401; 65-2801; 65-2802;
65-2803; 65-2869; 65-2870; 65-2871; 65-2892;
65-2892a; 65-2893; 65-28,102; 65-2897a; 65-2901;
65-3209; K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 65-4003; K.S.A.
65-4202; 65-4301; K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 65-5501;
K.S.A. 72-5208; 74-4916; K.A.R. 28-34-1.
Dear Representative Sprague:
As State Representative for the Seventy-Third District, you
request our opinion whether doctors of chiropractic licensed
by the State of Kansas may call themselves "chiropractic
physicians." It is our understanding that the Board of
Healing Arts in October, 1986 reaffirmed its policy that it
would not discipline a doctor of chiropractic for using the
term "chiropractic physician."
All practitioners of the healing arts must be licensed by the
State Board of Healing Arts (Board). K.S.A. 65-2801; K.S.A.
65-2803. "Healing arts" is defined by statute as follows:
"The healing arts include any system,
treatment, operation, diagnosis,
prescription, or practice for the
ascertainment, cure, relief, palliation,
adjustment, or correction of any human
disease, ailment, deformity, or injury,
and includes specifically but not by way
of limitation the practice of medicine and
surgery; the practice of osteopathic
medicine and surgery; and the practice of
chiropractic." K.S.A. 65-2802(a).
Medicine and surgery, osteopathic medicine and surgery, and
chiropractic are three branches of the healing arts. K.S.A.
65-2869 provides as follows:
"For the purpose of this act the
following persons shall be deemed to be
engaged in the practice of medicine and
surgery:
"(a) persons who publicly profess to be
physicians or surgeons, or publicly
profess to assume the duties incident to
the practice of medicine or surgery or any
of their branches.
(b) Persons who prescribe, recommend or
furnish medicine or drugs, or perform any
surgical operation . . . .
(c) Persons who attach to their name the
title M.D., surgeon, physician, physician
and surgeon, or any other word or
abbreviation indicating that they are
engaged in the treatment or diagnosis of
ailments, diseases or injuries of human
beings." (Emphasis added).
"Physicians," then, are persons engaged in the practice of
medicine and surgery. By statute, osteopaths are licensed to
practice medicine and surgery:
"For the purpose of this act the following
persons shall be deemed to be engaged in
the practice of osteopathy or to be
osteopathic physicians and surgeons:
"(a) Persons who publicly profess to be
osteopathic physicians, or publicly
profess to assume the duties incident to
the practice of osteopathy, as heretofore
interpreted by the supreme court of this
state, shall be deemed to be engaged in
the practice of osteopathy.
"(b) Osteopathic physicians and surgeons
shall mean and include those persons who
receive a license to practice medicine and
surgery pursuant to the provisions of
this act." K.S.A. 65-2870. (Emphasis
added).
The practice of chiropractic is defined as follows:
"For the purpose of this act the following
persons shall be deemed to be engaged in
the practice of chiropractic: (a) Persons
who examine, analyze and diagnose the
human living body, and its diseases by the
use of any physical, thermal or manual
method and use the X-ray diagnosis and
analysis taught in any accredited
chiropractic school or college and (b)
persons who adjust any misplaced tissue of
any kind or nature, manipulate or treat
the human body by manual, mechanical,
electrical or natural methods or by the
use of physical means, physiotherapy
(including light, heat, water or
exercise), or by the use of foods, food
concentrates, or food extract, or who
apply first aid and hygiene, but
chiropractors are expressly prohibited
from prescribing or administering to any
person medicine or drugs in materia
medica, or from performing any surgery,
as hereinabove stated, or from practicing
obstetrics." K.S.A. 65-2871. (Emphasis
added).
As emphasized in the above statute, chiropractors may not
practice medicine or surgery. See Kansas State Board of
Healing Arts v. Burwell, 5 Kan. App. 2d 357, rev.
denied 228 Kan. 807 (1980) (Chiropractors may not
prescribe or administer laetrile, as such constitutes the
practice of medicine.)
The Kansas Chiropractic Association (KCA) has submitted
material to us in support of their contention that
chiropractors have the right to refer to themselves as
"chiropractic physicians." It is argued that the term
"physician" is not limited to a particular branch of the
healing arts and that several Kansas statutes recognize a
chiropractor as a physician. Another argument is that the
word "physician" used in conjunction with the term
"chiropractic" is not misleading to the public. The KCA
also maintains that doctors of chiropractic are qualified as
physicians.
Several Kansas statutes define the term "physician" to include
chiropractors. For example, for purposes of the
physician-patient privilege, a physician is "a person
licensed or reasonably believed by the patient to be licensed
to practice medicine or one of the healing arts . . . ."
K.S.A. 60-427(a). Under the workmen's compensation act, the
term physician means any "person licensed . . . to practice
medicine and surgery, osteopathy, chiropractic, dentistry,
optometry or podiatry." K.S.A. 44-508(i).
It has been contended that the term "physician" is a general
term which applies to all branches of the healing arts unless
specifically limited by statute. Examination of the Kansas
statutes, however, shows that "physician" is a specific term
unless applied in a general manner. It is reasonable to
conclude that one would look to chapter 65 (Public Health) of
the Kansas statutes to determine the meaning of "physician."
In the following statutes the term physician is specifically
defined to mean a person licensed to practice medicine and
surgery: K.S.A. 65-5a01(c) (care of crippled and chronically
ill children); 65-2897a(b) (physician's assistants);
65-28,102(d) (Natural Death Act); 65-2901 (practice of
physical therapy); 65-3209(g) (Uniform Anatomical Gift Act);
K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 65-4003(17) (Alcoholism and Treatment
Act); K.S.A. 65-4202(b) (practice of mental health
technology); 65-4301 et se q . (Emergency Medical Services
Act); 65-1,114(a) (concerning diabetes); 65-6b01(a)
(prescribing and administering laetrile); K.S.A. 1986
Supp. 65-5502(e) (Respiratory Therapy Practice Act).
Various statutes outside chapter 65 also limit the term
physician to mean a person licensed to practice medicine and
surgery. See K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 8-1001(c) (withdrawal of
blood for chemical blood test); 17-2707(b) (professional
corporations); 59-2902(j) (Treatment Act for Mentally Ill
Persons); K.S.A. 72-5208(e) (school health tests and
inoculations); K.A.R. 28-34-1(12) (hospital regulations).
The KCA argues that, to the extent statutes define physician
so as to exclude chiropractors, the designation "chiropractic
physician" would not bring chiropractors within these
statutes. Hence, the scope of chiropractic is not enlarged
and the public would not be misled. However, not all statutes
concerning public health which use the word "physician" limit
it to mean persons licensed to practice medicine and surgery.
Chiropractors, then, are not specifically excluded. See
K.S.A. 65-448 (examining victims of sex offenses); 65-2401
et sew . (vital statistics, duty of physician attending
births and deaths); 65-2892 (examination and treatment of
minors for venereal disease); 65-2892a (examination and
treatment of minors for drug abuse); 65-2893 (performing
autopsies). The content of these statutes makes it clear that
"physician" can only mean persons licensed to practice
medicine and surgery. Thus, the term physician has a specific
meaning unless it is defined otherwise, such as in the
worker's compensation statute (K.S.A. 44-508) and the
patient-physician privilege rule of evidence (K.S.A.
60-427).
The KCA maintains that only when the word "physician" is
used standing alone does it mean a person who practices
medicine and surgery; therefore, chiropractors may be called
chiropractic physicians. In the Kansas statutes "physician"
is used in conjunction with another word in at least two
instances: "physician's assistants" and "osteopathic
physicians." There is an important distinction between these
terms and "chiropractic physician." Physician's assistants
may practice medicine and surgery under the direction and
supervision of a physician licensed to practice medicine and
surgery. K.S.A. 65-2897a. Osteopaths are also licensed by
statute to practice medicine and surgery. K.S.A. 65-2870.
Chiropractors, however, may not practice medicine and
surgery. K.S.A. 65-2871. Under the Kansas statutes, when the
term "physician" is used in conjunction with another word, the
health care provider is one licensed to practice medicine and
surgery.
Kansas recognizes "the practice of chiropractic as one of the
healing arts in certain special areas of examination and
treatment related to the human body, including X-ray
diagnosis." Tayler v. Maxwell, 197 Kan. 509, 511
(1966). K.S.A. 65-2871 provides that the practice of
chiropractic includes examination, analysis, and diagnosis of
the human living body. See K.S.A. 40-2101 (if included in
an insurance policy, any service within the lawful scope of
chiropractic must be reimbursed or indemnified); 40-3103(k)
(chiropractic is a medical benefit under the Automobile Injury
Reparations Act); 44-508(i) (chiropractic benefits are
authorized for accidental injuries arising out of and in the
course of employment); 74-4916 (a chiropractor may perform
physical examinations to qualify public employees for
disability compensation).
The KCA argues that doctors of chiropractic qualify as
physicians because chiropractic is a healing art, they are
authorized to perform examinations, and they must complete an
extensive education in health care. There is no doubt that
today's chiropractor is well-trained to practice his or her
profession. However, the fact that a chiropractor can
examine, diagnose, and treat within the scope of
chiropractic does not qualify a chiropractor as a physician.
Since the practice of medicine and surgery is beyond the scope
of chiropractic, the term "chiropractic physician" is
contradictory and misleading. It is inconsistent to say that
when used alone the term "physician" means a person licensed
to practice medicine and surgery, but that when used with
another word means a person licensed to practice the healing
arts.
The term "physician" is defined in Black's Law Dictionary
1033 (rev. 5th ed. 1979) as follows:
"A practitioner of medicine; a person duly
authorized or licensed to treat diseases;
one lawfully engaged in the practice of
medicine."
A definition of "chiropractor" is found in 70 C.J.S.
Physicians and Surgeons §1:
"One who practices the system of
chiropractics. Chiropractors are not
physicians, and ordinarily are not
specialists regarding the diseases of the
internal organs."
The common meaning of physician is medical doctor or surgeon.
As used in the Kansas statutes, physician means a person
licensed to practice medicine and surgery. The term
"chiropractic physician," then, implies that a doctor of
chiropractic is licensed to practice beyond the scope of the
statutory definition of chiropractic. This is misleading to
the public. For this and the other reasons stated in this
opinion, we must conclude that doctors of chiropractic may not
represent themselves as "chiropractic physicians."
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:bas

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.