Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-036

1987-036Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
February 24, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 36
The Honorable Ginger Barr
State Representative, Fifty-First District
State Capitol, Room 115-S
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: State Departments; Public Officers,
Employees--Civil Service--State Provided Housing,
Food Service or Other Employee Maintenance
Synopsis: Based upon the information you have provided, it is
our opinion that the Housing Maintenance Guideline
Agreement executed by certain Fish and Game
Commission employees (prior to July, 1986) is a
binding contract between the Commission and an
employee of the Commission who occupies
state-owned housing. Additionally, in our
judgment the termination of the Commission's
payment of utility services for state-owned
housing occupied by those employees has reduced
their salaries in contravention of applicable state
regulations. Cited herein: K.S.A. 75-2961a,
75-4321, 75-4322, 75-4330; K.A.R. 1-5-20, 1-19-1,
1-19-2, 1-19-3; 1-19-4; 26 U.S.C. §19.
*
Dear Representative Barr:
You request our opinion concerning the effect of a change in
housing policy implemented by the Kansas Fish and Game
Commission. You have provided the following background (which
we must accept as containing all relevant facts pertinent to
the questions you pose) regarding adoption and implementation
of the aforesaid policy:
1. On May 30, 1986, William Hanzlick, Director of the
Kansas Fish and Game Commission (Commission) , -issued a
memorandum to all of the Commission's employees who were then
occupying residences provided by the Commission, advising them
of a change in the Commission's housing policy. (A copy of
that memorandum is attached.) In the memorandum, Mr.
Hanzlick indicated that, upon his recommendation, "the
Commission amended the housing policy (H-1) to stipulate that
as of July 1, 1986, all employees living in state houses will
pay utilities."
2. A copy of the housing policy referenced in Mr. Hanzlick's
memorandum is attached. It took effect on July 1, 1986, and
establishes two categories of agency residences: (1)
essential; and (2) desirable. Essential residences are
defined as being "those designated by the director as
necessary to the operation of the agency," and desirable
residences are defined as being "those not designated
essential."
Pursuant to the Commission's new housing policy, all occupants
of both classes of residences are to pay for utility services,
with usage determined by meter, effective July 1, 1986;
whereas, effective January 1, 1987, occupants of desirable
residences also will be charged $150.00 per month as rent, in
addition to their payment of utility services.
3. Pursuant to his memorandum of June 10, 1986, Director
Hanzlick advised the Commission's fish hatchery personnel
that certain agency houses occupied by such personnel had been
designated as essential housing, pursuant to the Commission's
new housing policy. (A copy of that memorandum also is
attached.) Accordingly, pursuant to the new housing policy,
these employees were obligated to pay for utility services at
the state-owned housing they occupied as of July 1, 1986.
4. Prior to the adoption of the Commission's amended housing
policy, all of the persons listed in Mr. Hanzlick's
memorandum of June 10, 1986, had signed a "Housing Maintenance
Guidelines Agreement" (HMGA), as referenced in and required
by the Commission's prior and amended housing policies: (A,
copy of one such HMGA is attached.)
5. Under numbered paragraph 11 of the HMGA, the Commission
agreed to pay all utilities (other than telephone) for the
state-owned houses occupied by Commission employees, and
such payments were made by the Commission prior to July 1,
1986, the effective date of the amended housing policy.
6. Under numbered paragraph 10 of the HMGA, it is provided
that, even though employees occupying state-owned houses do
not pay rent, such employees will pay specified taxes on the
"rental" rate or amount, as determined by the State Division
of Accounts and Reports, pursuant to K.S.A. 75-2961a and
K.A.R. 1-19-9. Subparagraph a of paragraph 10 provides that
the cost of the utilities paid by the Commission are included
in the rental rate or amount.
7. It is the position of the personnel officer of the
Commission that employees of the Commission who are affected
by the new housing policy may not avail themselves of the
Commission's grievance procedure to protest the change in
policy or its conflict with the HMGA, because the housing
policy concerns a condition of their employment.
Your questions are as follows:
"1. Is the HMGA a binding contract between the Commission
and its employees who sign it, thereby precluding the
Commission from unilaterally changing the terms and conditions
thereof by the implementation of the Commission's amended
housing policy, which became effective on July 1, 1986?
"2. Irrespective of whether the HMGA is a binding contract
between the Commission and its employees who sign it, does the
implementation of the Commission's amended housing policy
constitute an impermissible reduction in the compensation paid
to the Commission's employees who had signed the HMGA prior
to July 1, 1986?"
In regard to the first question, there are a number of factors
suggesting that the HMGA is a contract. First, in the
Commission's policy regarding occupancy of Commission
dwellings (as amended July 1, 1986), the Commission describes
the HMGA as an agreement which details "the responsibilities
of the Commission and the employee with regard to state owned
housing."
Second, the HMGA describes the guidelines set forth therein
as "an agreement between the Commission and the employee
occupying a state-owned house."
Third, the subject matter of the HMGA is a proper subject
for a contract. K.S.A. 75-2961a authorizes any state agency
to furnish housing for any position in the classified or
unclassified services under the Kansas Civil Service System.
This statute has been implemented by regulations of the
Secretary of Administration (K.A.R. 1-19-1 et seq.).
While this statute and the implementing regulations do not
specifically authorize or require the benefits contemplated
therein to be provided pursuant to contract, they clearly
legitimize housing benefits being provided state employees,
thereby making this a proper subject of contract.
This is further evidenced by the Public Employer-Employee
Relations Act. In K.S.A. 75-4330, the legislature has
provided that, with certain exceptions which are not pertinent
here, the "scope of a memorandum of agreement may extend to
all matters relating to conditions of employment." Thus, even
though the occupancy of state-owned housing by an employee
of the Commission may be regarded as a condition of
employment, the legislature has declared that conditions of
employment are proper subjects of contract between a state
employer and its employees.
It should be noted that the term "conditions of employment,"
as used in K.S.A. 75-4330, is defined by subsection (t) of
K.S.A. 75-4322 to include such items as salaries, wages and
retirement benefits. As will be discussed subsequently,
paragraphs 10 and 22 of the HMGA clearly affect the
compensation of Commission employees who occupy state-owned
housing.
Thus, even though the HMGA is not the product of collective
bargaining between the Commission and an employee organization
that includes employees of the Commission, the provisions of
K.S.A. 75-4321 et seq. evidence that conditions of
employment, such as those contemplated in the HMGA, are
proper subjects of contract between a state agency and an
employee thereof.
Also, with respect to the subject matter of the HMGA, it
should be noted that it has substantial characteristics of a
lease agreement. Since the housing in question is under the
jurisdiction and control of the Commission, the Commission
occupies the position of "landlord," and it is entirely
appropriate that the Commission enter into contracts with the
occupants of these dwellings regarding the terms and
conditions of their occupancy.
As to other indicia of contracts present in the HMGA, it
should be recognized that there is a manifestation of mutual
assent. The Commission's housing policy provides that the
HMGA "must be processed with the employee through an Agency
Housing Committee appointed by the Director." Accordingly,
the director and the chairman of the housing committee have
executed the HMGA on behalf of the Commission. And, of
course, it also is executed by the affected state employee.
In addition, the mutuality of obligation established by the
HMGA provides sufficient consideration for the contract.
It would appear that, pursuant to the Commission's housing
policy, the employees of the Commission who occupy housing on
or immediately adjacent to the Commission's installations do
so as a condition of their employment. It might also be
argued that execution of the HMGA by the employee is a
condition of employment. Even so, such facts do not, in our
opinion, alter the characterization of the HMGA as a
contract. The requirements that an employee must occupy
housing provided by the Commission and execute the HMGA as a
condition of employment are distinguishable from the
substantive provisions of the HMGA itself. Even though the
execution of the HMGA by an employee of the Commission might
be regarded as a condition of employment, the fact remains
that the HMGA establishes the mutual obligations of the
parties regarding a particular dwelling.
There is no declaration within the HMGA that it is merely a
policy statement of the Commission, to be modified from time
to time by appropriate action of the Commission. To the
contrary, it is an agreement contemplated by the Commission's
housing policy. Also notably absent from the HMGA is any
provision regarding the unilateral modification of the
agreement by either party.
Accordingly, it is our opinion that the HMGA is a binding
contract between the Commission and an employee of the
Commission who occupies state-owned housing. The subject
matter of the HMGA is the proper subject of a contract, the
parties are proper parties to a contract of this type, both
parties have expressed mutual assent to the provisions of the
contract and the mutuality of obligation by the parties to the
HMGA provides adequate consideration. In our judgment, the
HMGA has all the necessary indicia for a binding contract,
and absent any provision therein, or in any statute or duly
adopted regulation, permitting the unilateral modification of
the contract by the Commission, such action appears to be a
breach of contract.
Thus, the Commission's implementation of its amended housing
policy appears to be a breach of the existing Housing
Maintenance Guidelines Agreements, since the Commission has
ceased to pay for utility services at state-owned housing,
as required by the HMGA, without consent of the affected
employees of the Commission.
Irrespective of the contractual nature of the HMGA, however,
the Commission had complied with the HMGA prior to the
effective date of the amended housing policy, by paying for
the specified utility services at state-owned housing
occupied by the Commission's employees. By terminating these
payments and requiring them to be made by these employees, the
Commission has effectively reduced the compensation of these
employees, to the extent of these payments.
As previously noted, paragraphs 10 and 11 of the HMGA
provide for the determination of the rental value to the
employee of occupying state-owned housing. Included therein
is the cost of the utilities provided by the Commission. As
so determined, the rental value to each employee constitutes
compensation paid to such employee, which is evidenced by a
consideration of various factors.
First, K.S.A. 75-2961a provides in pertinent part as follows:
"Whenever housing, food service or other
employee maintenance is furnished by any
state agency, the documents authorizing
the same shall specify the types of
employee maintenance to be provided and
the dollar value thereof that is to be
regarded as compensation, and the balance
of value in each case shall be regarded as
the expense of the state benefit from the
arrangement."
Implementing the foregoing legislative requirement are the
above-referenced regulations of the Secretary of
Administration (K.A.R. 1-19-1 et seq.). Specifically,
subsection (D) of K.A.R. 1-19-2 states:
"(D) Wage or salary for the purpose of
these regulations shall include the
regular cash salary plus any remuneration
provided in a medium other than cash,
which shall be computed on the basis of
the fair and prevailing value or cost of
such items in the locality at the time of
payment or as provided herein."
Consistent with that definitional provision, K.A.R. 1-19-3
recites the state policy, as follows:
"It shall be the state policy that where
agency's facilities or services are
available for providing housing, food
service or other employee maintenance,
they may be furnished to employees with
adjustments to the cash wages or salaries
of the position involved as provided
herein.
"Charges for the value of housing, food
service or other employee maintenance
which are deemed to be primarily for the
benefit of the employee will be deducted
from the employee's cash-salary or
collected in cash from the employee as
provided herein.
"The value of housing, food service or
other employee maintenance which are [sic]
deemed to be for the benefit of the
employer shall be provided without charge
to the employee as provided in regulation
1-19-4 (A) 4 [sic] and 1-19-4 (B) 4 [sic]."
The regulatory provision last referenced in the above-quoted
provision states:
"(4) A full deduction of the value
established for housing, lot rent, utility
meters or heating fuel sources which are
provided by the employer as a part of the
rental value shall be allowed from wages
and salaries to comply with internal
revenue code section 119, for income and
withholding tax purposes if the occupant
is required by the agency to be available
at the duty location twenty-four (24)
hours per day, every day -- except for
authorized time off -- to meet job
requirements. In order to qualify for
this reduction: (A) The lodging must be
furnished on the agency premises and at
the place of employment with the state
agency.
"(B) The lodging must be furnished because
the employee is required to be available
for duty at all times or because the
employee could not perform the services
required unless such lodging is furnished.
"(C) The employee is required to accept
such lodging as a condition of employment
in order to properly perform the job
duties.
"(D) The head of each agency shall certify
on the form prescribed those positions and
employees on [sic] such positions who are
required to live in the housing provided."
To fully understand the above-quoted provisions, reference
must be made to Internal Revenue Code §119 (26 U.S.C. §119).
Subsection (a) thereof provides as follows:
"(a) There shall be excluded from gross
income of an employee the value of any
meals or lodging furnished to him, his
spouse, or any of his dependents by or on
behalf of his employer for the convenience
of the employer, but only
if --
"(1) in the case of meals, the meals are
furnished on the business premises of the
employer, or
"(2) in the case of lodging, the employee
is required to accept such lodging on the
business premises of his employer as a
condition of his employment."
The important point to be derived from IRC §119, for
purposes of the issue considered here, is the fact that the
value of housing provided by an employer to its employee is
regarded as gross income under the Internal Revenue Code. If
such were not the case, there would be no need for IRC
§119. That is, if the value of housing provided by an
employer to its employee were not income, there would be no
need for a section providing for its exclusion from gross
income under prescribed conditions, for purposes of income
taxation. Moreover, the fact that such value is exempt from
income taxation, where the lodging is for the convenience of
the employer and is a condition of employment, does not alter
its character as income; and without the exemption provisions
of IRC §119, it would be taxable income.
Not only is it the stated purpose of K.A.R. 1-19-4(b)(4) to
establish regulatory provisions consistent with IRC §119,
such purpose is apparent from a comparison of its provisions
to the requirements of IRC §119. Moreover, it appears that
the Commission's housing policy (H-1) is designed to comply
with the Secretary of Administration's regulations and IRC
§119. For example, the Commission's housing policy identifies
the dwellings to be occupied by its employees as being located
on or immediately adjacent to Commission installations. It
also requires that the dwellings be occupied by permanent
employees and their immediate families, and it further
provides, as follows:
"Commission employees occupy these
dwellings as a condition of their
employment to provide security to
Commission installations, undertake
actions in the event of emergency or other
unscheduled situations, and to provide
public services beyond basic job
requirements."
This statement indicates that the persons occupying the
Commission's dwellings do so as a condition of their
employment and establishes the reasons that such occupancy is
for the convenience of the Commission, within the meaning of
the pertinent state regulation and IRC §119.
Finally, the Commission's housing policy also contains the
following statement:
"It is the opinion of the Commission that
occupants of these dwellings meet the
Internal Revenue Services [sic] Code,
section 119, for exemption, and it should
not be considered a part of the employees'
gross income."
The foregoing statement clearly expresses the Commission's
intention of complying with IRC §119. As previously noted,
the value of lodging provided by an employer to its employees
is gross income, but it is not subject to income taxation or
withholding, by virtue of IRC §119.
The provisions of numbered paragraphs 10 and 11 of the HMGA
also confirm that the value of the housing provided by the
Commission to its employees (including the value of the
utility services provided by the Commission) is compensation
to the employees who occupy such housing. For example, such
employees pay Social Security Tax (FICA) on the value of
such housing. Pursuant to FICA, such tax is levied upon
gross income.
In addition, such value is subject to the employees' state
retirement contributions. Again, such contributions are based
on the employees' gross income.
Similarly, withholding of amounts for workers' compensation
insurance and unemployment compensation insurance taxes are
applied to the value of the housing. Again, such taxes are
applicable to an employee's gross income.
In our opinion, the foregoing considerations establish that
the value of the housing provided to the Commission's
employees, including the value of utility services provided by
the Commission, constitutes compensation to the Commission's
employees who are required to occupy such housing as a
condition of their employment and as a convenience to their
employer. Accordingly, the Commission's implementation of its
amended housing policy, through its termination of payments of
utility services, has the effect of reducing that
compensation. And, irrespective of whether the Commission's
implementation of the amended housing policy constitutes a
breach of contract, such reductions in compensation are
without lawful authority.
In this regard, the provisions of K.A.R. 1-5-20 are pertinent,
since they provide the basis by which a state agency
(appointing authority) may reduce an employee's compensation.
Subsection (a) of that regulation provides, in part, as
follows:
"(a) The appointing authority may reduce
the salary of any employee one step (but
not below the minimum of the salary range)
by reason of less than satisfactory
performance according to a current
performance evaluation."
The pertinent attachments indicate that the Commission's
housing policy was amended solely for financial
considerations, and was not precipitated by unsatisfactory
performance by affected employees. Thus, in our judgment, the
adoption of the amended housing policy, and the termination of
the Commission's payment of utility services for lodging
occupied by the Commission's employees pursuant to such
amended policy, have resulted in a reduction in compensation
to such employees without lawful authority.
Thus, if the HMGA constitutes a contract between the
Commission and each of its employees who occupied
state-owned housing prior to the effective date of the
Commission's amended housing policy, the implementation of the
new housing policy constitutes a breach of those contracts.
But, in any event, it is our opinion that the termination of
the Commission's payments of utility services for
state-owned housing occupied by Commission employees has
reduced the salaries of those employees in contravention of
applicable state regulations.
Very truly yours,
ROBERTT.STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TRH:jm
Kansas Fish
kir Game HEADQUARTR
BOX 54A RTE 2
S
PRATT KS 67124 1316ianzlick
May 30, 1986
TO: All Employees in Agency !lousing
FROM: Director Hliaack
RE: Agency Housing
As you obviously have read by now, we are making rtaa serious effortto
reduce all possible expenditures within the a
we've institutgdncy so that walcan correct our fiscal situation. situation. As you read in my first memo, wemeitutewe'vedinstituted a
number of cost-saving measures, and ICommission for tipolicyme there would
be other issues brought before the Comrecommendationsicy decisions. One
such issue was discussed, and I made recannendations to the Commission, con-
cerning agency housing.
Upon my recommendation, the Commission amended the housing policy
(H-1) to stipulate that as of July 1, 1986, all employees living in state
houses will desirableies. Additionally, all personnel Hiring in what we
consider "desireable" housing will begin paying $150 a month rent starting
January 1, 1987 (list attached). When turn-over is experienced in employees
living in agency housing, a determination will be made as to whether the
house will remain or be removed fran the premises. The employee hired to
fill the vacant position will, if the house is.removed, have to make his
own housing arrangements. It was the concensus of the Commission that, if
"desireable" housing is to be available, these facilities will have to pay
for themselves--that is the purpose for instituting these housing policy
changes.
There will be more specific guidelines relating to this, but I wanted
you all to know as quickly as the decision was made so you could - make your
own personal plans accordingly. I am one of the agency housing occupants
and don't look forward to paying utilities and rent, but we must all do what
we can to alleviate the present fiscal situation weHEADQUARTERSelves in.
jlr
Att.
EQUAL OPPORTU(316)((316(316)672 59:1
The following is A list of personnel residing in agency housing as
of 6-30-86.
ADMINISTRATION:
James Gump, Rt. 2, Box 57, Pratt, KS 67124
I & E:
None
LAW ENFORCEMENT:
Paul Miller, Rt. 6, Manhattan, KS 66502
GAME:
Don Davis, Rt. 4, Norton, KS 67654
Karl Karrow, Rt. 2, Box 130, Pleasanton, KS 66075
Gary Reid, Rt. 1, Lecompton, KS 66050
Dalton Newberry, Rt. 1, St. Paul, KS 66771
Cliff Peterson, Rt. 1, Canton, KS 67428
Steve Schmidt, Rt. 2, Ellis, KS 67637
Phillip Dickerson, Rt. 2, Independence, KS 67301
Byron Walker, Penalosa, KS 67121
John Silovsky, Rt. 1, St. Paul, KS 66771
James Ross, Rt. 3, Box 188, Columbus, KS 66725
Stan Wood, Rt. 3, Box 301, Great Bend, KS 67530
* Kyle Austin, Pratt Hatchery, Pratt, KS 67124
* Thomas Dorzab, Rt. 3, Box 304, Junction City, KS. 66441
* Charles Helms, Meade Hatchery, Meade, KS 67864 (Paying rent)
* Harold Jagerson, Rt. 3, Box 304, - Junction City, KS 66441
* Mark Kumberg, Rt. 2, Box 56, Pratt, KS 67124
* Joe Lillie, Nye Route, Meade, KS 67864
* Chris Mammoliti, Rt. 2, Box 58, Pratt,.KS 67124
* Stephen Mense, Farlington Hatchery, Farlington, KS 66734
* Dan Mosier, Farlington Hatchery, Farlington, KS 66734
* Randy Nelson „Farlington Hatchery, Farlington, KS 66734
* Don Patton, Rt. 2, Box 61, Pratt, KS 67124
-*Scott Stuewe, Rt. 3, Box 304, Junction City, KS 66441
Larry Lentz, Rt. 1, Tonganoxie, KS 66086
Fred Lovelady, Rt. 1, Box 123, Toronto, KS 66777
Larry Mull, Rt. 5, Box 169, Manhattan, KS 66502
Bill Vering, RR2, Minneapolis, KS 67467 (Paying Rent)
Roger Wolfe, Rt. 4, Parsons, KS 67357
Jim Young, Rt. 1, Box 15, Kingsdown, KS 67858
* Considered essential houses.
Filing No. 1171
Effective ... 771785.
Page . 1 of 2
POLICY MANUAL
Kansas Fish and Game Commission
SUBJECT: OCCUPANCY OF CO MISSION DWELLINGS
The Kansas Fish and Game Counission has dwellings located on or immediate-
ly adjacent to Camission installations. These dwellings are occupied by
permanent employees of the Commission and their imnediate families.
Commission employees occupy these dwellings as a condition of their
employment to provide security to Commission installations, undertake actions
in the event of emergency or other unscheduled situations, and to provide
public services beyond basic job requirements. A "Housing Maintenance Guide-
lines Agreement" detailing the responsibilities of the Commission and the
employee with regard to state owned housing must he processed with the
employee through an Agency Housing Committee appointed by the director.
Prior to any employee occupying a state owned residence, the "Housing Main-
tenance Guidelines Agreement" must be signed by the employee and placed on
file with the Administrative Services Division at headquarters.
Dwellings determined by th:. Commission'to be unnecessary for the fore-
going purposes will be removed fran the property and fran the inventory
pursuant to applicable state laws, regulations and procedures.
It is the opinion of the Connti•;sion that occupants of these dwellings
meet the Internal Revenue Services Code, Section 119, for exenption, and
it should not be considered part of the employees' grossincome.
Filing No.
Effective
Page of 2
All agency residences will be placed into one of two categories:
(1) Essential--essential residences are those designated by the
director as necessary to the operation of the agency.
(2) Desireable--desireable residences are those not designated
essential.
Effective July 1, 1986, all occupants of essential and desireable
agency residences will be charged for utilities service with usage deter-
mined by meter.
Effective January 1, 1987, all occupants of residences designated
desireable will be charged $150.00 per month rent in addition to utilities
service.
The director may declare any agency residence surplus and, when the
premise becomes vacant, may make other disposition of the house.
- I
The acceptance of some positions will require the employee to live in
"essential" residences as a condition of employment. "Desireable" residences
will be offered to employees stationed in the area on 'a priority basis
established by the director.
All occupants of state housing will be required to sign the "Housing
Maintenance Agreement."
Kiall5a5 Fish
fbil Game HEADQUARTERS
BOX 54A. nr. 2. PRATT. KS 67124 13161 6725911
MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
SUBJECT:
Hatchery Managers and Fish Hat iery Assistants
Bill Hanzlick, Director
June 10, 1986
Declaration of "Essential" Housing as Per Policy H-1,
Effective Date 7-1-86
As per Kansas Fish and Game Commission Policy H-1, effective 7-1-86, I hereby
designate the following houses as being "essential."
Location Residence No. Current Resident Classification
Meade Hatchery 14 Joe Lillie Hatchery Manager
Pratt Hatchery 5 Don Patton Hatchery Manager
Pratt Hatchery 7 Chris Mammoliti Hatchery Asst.
Pratt Hatchery 4 _Kyle Austin Hatchery Asst.
Pratt Hatchery 6 :* * Mark Kumbergl Hatchery Asst.
Farlington Hatchery 16 Steve Mense Hatchery Manager
Farlington Hatchery 15 Randy Nelson Hatchery Asst.
Farlington Hatchery 17 Dan Mosier Hatchery Asst.
Milford Hatchery 36 (vacant) Hatchery Manager
Milford Hatchery 38 Harold Jagerson Hatchery Asst.
Milford Hatchery 37 Tom Dorzab Hatchery Asst.
Further, as previously notified upon hiring, Hatchery Managers and Hatchery
Assistants are required, as an employment condition, to reside in hatchery
residences, when provided.
EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER
KANSAS FISH AND GAME COMMISSION
HOUSING MAINTENANCE GUIDELINES
The following are guidelines on the subject of maintenance of state-owned
houses that will serve as an agreement between the Commission and the employee •
occupying a state-owned house.
A. Responsibility of the State.
1. Facilities should be conducive to family living.
a. Basic house should be structurally and attractively sound and
provide for the space needed to meet the basic needs of an
average-sized family.
b. Good basic heating unit; preferably forced air.
c. A window air conditioner of sufficient size to cool the majority
of the house. Additional air conditioners, if desired, will be
provided by the occupant. Window air conditioners cannot be
provided immediately, but will be purchased as monies allow.
d. Storm windows and doors for energy conservation where practical.
e. Insulation for energy conservation where practical.
f. Carpeting in rooms that do not have good hardwood floors or other
good floor covering.
g. Kitchen cabinets that provide adequate space for an average-
sized family.
h. Closets that provide adequate space for an average-sized family.
i. Garage or other storage facility, -At areas where no garage is
available, consider car ports or small sheds.
j.. Adequate, worable plumbing including bathroom and kitchen
fixtures such as stools, sinks and tubs or shower.
k. Adequate, workable electric system including attractive fixtures.
Occupant may add table lamps, floor lamps,.swag lamps, wall
mount lamsp, etc. that are equipped to be "plugged-in" rather
than "wired-in" without Committee authorization. However, the
occupant will patch, repair, and repaint any portions of walls,
ceilings, etc. where such lamps were attached or mounted prior
to his vacating the house. _-
1. TV antenna of sufficient quality to supply good image. When
antenna purchase by the agency is necessary, a quality combination
VHF/UHF/FM antenna will be purchased. If occupant of state-owned
house now owns an antenna it will remain in use until such time
as he vacates the house and at that time the Committee will offer
to purchase it or have employee remove it. Separate FM, CB, SW,
and other types of antennas as desired by the occupant will be
installed by the occupant (on his own time and with materials
purchased by him, not the state) only after authorization is
received from the occupant's supervisor.
2. House should have outside and inside paint as needed.
3. Roofing should be replaced as needed.
4. Inspection of all state houses as needed to determine the general
condition of the house, if the house is meeting the needs of the
occupants, if requested improvements are justified, etc. Inspections
will be conducted at least once per year by the employees' (occupants')
immediate supervisor and/or Housing Committee. Findings will
be reported to the appropriate division chief and the occupant.
The Committee will inform the occupant at least seven (7) days
in advance of any planned inspection and set a time and date
for such that is convenient with the occupant and his family.
All persons involved should keep in mind that such inspections are
NOT intended to impose feelings of being "checked up on" or that
personal living habits are being scrutinized. The main purpose of
the inspection is to insure that both the Commission and the
occupant are fulfilling their responsibilities as set forth in the
agreement. An inspection of the house is mandatory if an employee
vacates the house for any reason.
5 If the Committee determines that extensive repair work or costly
renovations are needed in a state-owned house, the division chief
budgeting expenses for upkeep of that house will be expected to
budget in the next fiscal year for the money needed for renovation.
B. Responsibilities of the Employee.
1. All care and maintenance of inside and immediate outside facilities.
a. Paint as needed with state supplied paint.
(1) Painting will be accomplished during normal working hours
as schedule allows.
b. Repair of facilities and reporting problems.
(1) Repair accomplished during normal working hours as schedule
allows (except where repair is of an immediate nature).
Occupant is authorized and requested to make such minor
repairs as leaky faucets or stools, window caulking, screen
replacement, wall crack patching, minor repainting, sealing
roof leaks, replacing broken windows, etc., when cost of
materials does not exceed .$100.00 with no report of such
repairs required. All repairs estimated to exceed $100.00
will be approved by the occupant's immediate supervisor
unless such repairs are of an emergency nature, such as
plugged sewers, broken water lines, gas leaks, power
failures, etc., `in which case it will be the occupant's
responsibility to see that such emergency repairs are
corrected immediately.to safeguard life and property.
A report of emergency repairs exceeding $100.00 should be
made to the Housing Committee and your supervisor. Repair
and maintenance exepnditures or needs should not be interpreted
to mean new floor coverings, new cabinets, or other new
improvements or renovations to the structure, inside or out.
If the occupant cannot make the forementioned repairs him-
self, he may contact local plumbers, carpenters, etc., for
the work keeping in mind that purchasing limitations, as set
forth for all types of local purchases, still apply.
2. Care and maintenance of immediate grounds around the house.
a. Now the grass as needed (off-duty hours) where a specified
maintenance crew does not mow it as part of their duties.
b. Attend to flower and/or vegetable gardens to maintain them in an
attractive condition. (off-duty hours).
c. Trim shrubbery, rake and general clean-up as needed (off-duty
hours).
3. If major additions or changes to the house are needed or desired,
send requests in a memo to the Housing Comittee with copies to
your immediate supervisor and the division chief. Requests might
include living space additions, cabinets, closets, shelving of a
permanent nature, new porch, roof, etc.
4. Any article built or purchased by the employee and which is attached
to the house, becomes the property of the state effective on and
after October 1, 1978.
a. This includes such things as permanent bookshelves, cabinets,
carpeting, wall shelves, etc.
b. It is the intent of the Connission to provide housing for
eligible agency personnel that is adequate for employee needs so
it will not be necessary for occupants of state houses to purchase,
at their own expense, such items as carpeting, closet space
additions, and other permanent fixtures.
5. Employees will provide their own draperies and all other window
curtains they feel are necessary. The agency will provide drapery and
curtain rods and roller type blinds (shades) throughout the house.
These items will stay with the house when the occupant leaves.
6. Damage to the state-owned house: The Commission realizes that from
time to time occupants of a residence will, by accident, cause damage to
that house. When this happens the occupant will make every attempt
to repair such damages at his expense and on his own time if he feels
that he or members of his family were at fault and that the accident
could have been avoided. If, however, the employee feels that the
accident and resulting damage was unavoidable on his part and was the
result of some inadequacy in the house itself, the occupant will
contact his immediate supervisor. The supervisor will determine if
the accident was a result of a hobsi'ng inadequacy or activities of the
occupant and therefore his responsibility.
7. Guests of occupants in state-owned housing, their welfare and actions,
will be the sole responsibility of the occupant of the house. Persons
outside of the employees' immediate family and/or those not considered
the employees' immediate dependents will not be boarded nor live for
extended and indefinate periods of time in a state-owned house.
8. Other or supplementary income' business conducted from state-owned
houses. --
a. Employees will not be allowed to use a state-owned house as a
base of operations for other (non-agency) business unless such
4s cleared and authorized by the employees' supervisor and the
Director. Some exceptions to this will be in the case of an employee
and/or spouse or other family member conducting business activities
that would not infringe upon the living quarters of the house
and/or business activities intended primarily to aid the family
income rather than a full-scale commercial type business having
full day hours, walk-in customers, etc. For example, such small
business activities as private music or arts and crafts lessons,
small scale child care or babysitting, hobby craft production and
sales, etc., may be conducted in the house without the previously
mentioned authorizations required. No modifications to a state-
owned house to conduct any type of business will be made unless
written authorization as previously noted is granted. Employees
are cuationed that no personal tax deductions may be claimed for
expenses toward any private business conducted in a state-owned house
when those expenses are paid by the state as normal operations
of that house, ie. gas, electricity, repairs, etc.
9. Pets in state-owned houses are allowed, but discretion must be used.
Large pets, not normally considered house pets, and large numbers of
pets that may add above normal wear and tear to the house and fixtures
will not be kept in the house. Dogs will be contained (pen or chain)
when not under direct observation outdoors.
77 10. Although employees occupying state owned houses do not pay rent, the
State requires that those employees pay Social Security tax, Retirement
and Workman's Comprehensive/Unemployement Insurance taxes on a
"rental" rate or amount, determined by the Division of Accounts and
Reports in Topeka under K.S.A. 75-2961A and K.A.R. 1-19-9, that is
representative of the value or benefit gained by the employee while
living in no-cost housing and is therefore subject to these taxes.
a. These rates or amounts are based upon an evaluation by house
size (square feet), cost, desirability, maintenance costs,
estimated reamining life of the house, general condition and a
rental factor rounded to the nearest dollar with all applied
uniformly statewide. Utilities rates are included and are based
on actual and/or estimated costs.
b. The deduction from the employees pay is at the following percentages
of the determined "rental" rate amount: Social Security 6.05%;
Retirement 4.0%; Workmans Comp./Unemployment Ins. .004%.
IE. If your state-owned house was valued at $100.00 per month
"rental" rate, your deductions would be $6.05, 54.00, $ .40, or a
total of $10.45. NOTE: These percentages are subject to change
with future regulation changes governing such, most of which you
would get back later in life through Social Security benefits
and retirement.
c. Employees will be notified each year of the rate or amount on
which he will be paying.	,77 11. The state pays all electricity, gas, water and sewer, etc. for state
owned houses. The employee, however, must pay for his own telephone
and related services.
12 The state carries no insurance of-any kind on state-owned houses and
attached or surrounding buildings. For this reason, it is advisable,
but not mandatory, that state house occupants purchase and maintain
a renters' insurance plan to cover the contents they own. The state
is not responsible for damages to the occupants or contents of any
state owned house.
24? ‘14\ U\ V Nx1
Allen'Stoops State-owned House Occupan
Housing Committee, Chairman
I) I .
1 I ; el f . 1 i / ' • o
. / . . .
!it'' 1.1 ... 1')( /1V‘A 41 . '...-..../ t 'L I I /• 4 I ... .,f3:11 . rcT7- 4: t. 1
House Number and Location
Frector
•
William P. Hanziick

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.