Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-112

1986-112Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN August 7, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 112
Norman E. Gaar
Gaar & Bell
14 Corporate Woods, Suite 640
8717 West 110th Street
Overland Park, Kansas 66210
Re: Bonds and Warrants--Refunding Bonds--Conditions and
Limitations; Refinancing Construction Accounts
Synopsis: A school district which has money remaining in a
construction account funded with proceeds of a bond
issue authorized by K.S.A. 72-6761 may, in
conjunction with the issuance of K.S.A. 1985 Supp.
10-427 et seq. general obligation bonds
designed to refund the outstanding bonds, transfer
the money in the construction account to an escrow
(as described in K.S.A. 10-427a) pledged for the
payment of principal and interest on the
outstanding bonds. A portion of the proceeds of
the issue not required for the escrow may then be
transferred to replenish the construction account.
The school district's original authority to issue
general obligation bonds pursuant to K.S.A. 72-6761
together with its authority to refund its
outstanding general obligation bonds pursuant to
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 10-427 permits such a
transaction to be accomplished without an election
or a repetition of the authority required by K.S.A.
72-6761. Pursuant to K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 10-427a
the issuance of such bonds will not increase the
school districts indebtedness for the purpose of
calculating statutory debt limitations. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 10-117; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 10-120;
K.S.A. 10-427; 10-427a; K.S.A. 72-6761.
Dear Mr. Gaar:
As bond counsel for the Board of Education of Unified School
District No. 231, Johnson County, Kansas, you seek an Attorney
General opinion on behalf of the District regarding a method
of refinancing which the District hopes to use in the near
future. You state the District's question as follows: "Can
the School District use money held in a K.S.A. 72-6761
authorized bond issue construction account, along with other
money, to fund an escrow for the payment of outstanding bonds
and issue bonds without an election to replenish the
construction account?"
You inform us that the District is considering refunding its
outstanding general obligation bonds pursuant to K.S.A. 10-427
et seq. in order to achieve interest cost savings and
provide a more economical program for retiring the District's
debt. The District presently has three series of bonds
outstanding. The Series A, 1977 bonds and the Series A, 1985
bonds were issued pursuant to K.S.A. 72-6761. The Series B,
1985 bonds are refunding bonds issued pursuant to K.S.A. 1985
Supp. 10-427 to refund the two earlier issues. At this time
a portion of the proceeds of the Series A, 1985 bonds remain
in .a construction account. The District now proposes to issue
general obligation refunding bonds to refund the Series B,
1985 bonds in order to achieve further cost savings on its
debt service obligations. It is our understanding that due to
various intricacies of the federal tax law, even greater cost
savings for the District will occur if the funds in the Series
A, 1985 construction account, along with other available funds
and a portion of the proceeds of the 1986 bonds to be issued,
may be placed in escrow for the payment of principal and
interest on the refunded Series B, 1985 bonds. The remaining
portion of the 1986 bond proceeds mould be used to replace the
money transferred to escrow from the Series A, 1985
construction account.
.4-
It is the opinion of the Board of Education that it has the
statutory authority to refund the District's debt as described
without repeating the steps p rescribed by K.S.A. 72-6761 to
replenish the construction fund, and that such a refinancing
would not increase the District's general obligation debt for
the purpose of calculating its statutory debt limitation. You
ask whether the Attorney General concurs with these
conclusions. Our review of the Kansas statutes relevant to
this inquiry reveals neither a specific prohibition nor
authorization of the refinancing proposed by the District. It
would appear, however, that the refinancing, structured as
described earlier, can be viewed as within the District's
statutory authority to both issue general obligation bonds and
to refund any outstanding bonds.
K.S.A. 72-6761 permits a school district to issue general
obligation bonds for the acquisition, construction, equipping,
furnishing, repair or remodeling of buildings to be used for
school district purposes. No bonds exceeding the principal
amount of $20,000.00 may be issued unless first authorized by
a vote of the qualified electors of the district in an
election held pursuant to K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 10-120. When
the District has issued bonds under this statute it is then
authorized and empowered by K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 10-427, as are
all Kansas municipalities (see K.S.A. 10-101), to refund its
outstanding bonds. K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 10-427 further
provides that the municipality may issue refunding bonds for
the purpose of refunding its outstanding bonds and that:
"The principal amount of any issue of any
refunding bonds shall not exceed the
aggregate amount of: (a) The principal
amount of the issue or issues or part
thereof being refunded; (b) the amount of
any interest which has accrued or will
accrue to the date of payment of the bonds
being refunded; (c) the amount of any
redemption premium required; (d) expenses
of the municipality deemed by the
governing body to be necessary for the
issuance of the refunding bonds; and (e)
in the event the proceeds from the sale of
the refunding bonds are to be placed in
escrow and invested, the interest to
accrue on the refunding bonds from the
date of delivery to the first or any
subsequent available redemption date or
dates selected by the governing body of
the municipality, or to the date or dates
of maturity, whichever is determined by
the governing body to be most advantageous
or necessary to the municipality."
The governing body of an issuer has both the authority and the
responsibility to determine whether a refunding will be
beneficial to the issuer and, if so, how such a refunding may
best be accomplished. The statutes do not require that such
action be authorized by the voters, nor that it is subject to
protest by the voters. As noted above, the generally
understood purpose of a refunding is to provide the issuer
with the ability to structure its outstanding debt in the most
efficient and economical manner. In most instances the result
of a refunding is to save the issuer significant sums of money
on its debt service obligations. In this sense we believe
that the authority to refund may be viewed as a part the
District's overall authority and responsibility to accomplish
the projects for which it is authorized to issue general
obligation bonds in the most efficient and economical manner
possible.
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 10-427a provides the following guidance
regarding the issuance of refunding bonds to refund
outstanding bonds.
"(a) Refunding bonds issued under the
authority of K.S.A. 10-427, and amendments
thereto, may be sold or exchanged for the
bonds being refunded either as a whole or
in installments at any time either at,
before or after the maturity of the bonds
being refunded. Such bonds shall be
exempt from statutory limitations of
bonded indebtedness and shall not be
included in computing the total bonded
indebtedness of the municipality for the
purpose of applying any statute limiting
the bonded indebtedness of the
municipality.
"(b) If refunding bonds are sold more
than six months prior to the maturity or
earliest prior redemption date of the
bonds being refunded, the proceeds derived
from the sale, together with any other
moneys on hand, shall be placed in escrow
under a trust agreement with a Kansas bank
having full trust powers. The proceeds
and moneys shall be invested in direct
obligations of, or obligations the
principal of and the interest on which are
unconditionally guaranteed by, the United
States of America and which shall mature
or be subject to redemption by the holders
thereof not later than the respective
dates when the proceeds of the obligations
together with the interest accruing
thereon and any other moneys or
investments held in escrow will be
required for the purpose intended. The
trust agreement shall pledge or assign the
moneys and investments held in trust for
the payment of the principal of and the
interest on the bonds being refunded and
any redemption premium and shall contain
provisions for protecting and enforcing
the rights and remedies of the holders of
the bonds." (Emphasis added.)
As is apparent from the emphasized language, in an advance
refunding, the statute contemplates the use of funds other
than the proceeds of the refunding bonds to fund the escrow
necessary for the payment of principal and interest on the
refunded bonds. The statute does not designate the source of
"other moneys on hand" but presumably refers to any moneys
lawfully available for that purpose.
We are not unmindful that a strict construction of K.S.A. 1985
Supp. 10-427a could be argued to require that all proceeds
of refunding bonds issued under the circumstances there
described be placed in escrow under a trust agreement for
payment of the refunded bonds. Such a construction would thus
preclude the use of a portion of the bond proceeds to
replenish a construction fund which, in turn, has been placed
in escrow to be used for the payment of principal and interest
on refunded bonds. We believe that under the present
circumstances such a strict construction of the statute is
neither warranted nor required.
It is apparent both from the statute and common practice that
all the proceeds of a refunding issue are not required to be
placed in escrow solely for the payment of the refunded
bonds. An issuer is permitted to use a portion of the
refunding bonds for the payment of the cost of issuance and
such proceeds are not placed in the escrow required by K.S.A.
1985 Supp. 10-427a despite the fact that statute presumably
refers to all proceeds of such bonds.
Although the use of such proceeds to replenish a construction
fund is somewhat different and likely to involve larger sums
we do not believe that K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 10-427a should be
read to prohibit such a transaction as it may be viewed both
as part the original bond issue which funded the construction
fund and of the refunding of that issue. In other words, it
is our opinion that the restrictions found in K.S.A. 1985
Supp. 10-427a(b) are intended to prevent the diversion of
refunding bond proceeds to purposes unrelated to the
accomplishments of a successful refunding and to prevent the
r refunding transaction from failing to provide for the payment
of the refunded bonds.
Similarly, we do not believe that the proposed refinancing
runs afoul of K.S.A. 10-117, which prohibits the diversion of
proceeds of a bond issue to any purpose than that for which
the bond issue was intended. If the District's authority to
issue bonds to accomplish the purposes permitted by K.S.A.
72-6761 is considered in conjunction with its authority to
refund those bonds to accomplish cost savings pursuant to
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 10-427, the proposed refinancing falls
well within the District's statutory authority. The transfer
of the construction fund, i.e., proceeds of the original
issue, to the escrow to refund the original issue is clearly
concerned with the most economical accomplishment of the
original project. The construction money is not diverted to
any unrelated purpose and the construction fund will be
simultaneously replenished to continue the project without
creating further indebtedness for the District.
This is true because the refunding bonds are, by statute,
exempt from statutory limitations of bonded indebtedness and
thus not included in computing total bonded indebtedness of a
municipality. See 10-427a. The 1986 bonds simply replace
the debt defeased by the refunding transaction. This is not
altered by the use of a portion of the 1986 bond proceeds to
replace the construction fund since the debt represented by
the construction fund is refunded and defeased by the proposed
refinancing.
In our opinion, the initial authority to issue general
obligation bonds for some lawful purpose, read in conjunction
with an issuer's authority to refund its outstanding bonds,
permits an issuer to use available funds and authority to
accomplish the project and the financing/refinancing thereof
in the most efficient and economical manner. Under the plan
proposed by the District, the purpose of a successful
refunding is not defeated by the transfer of the construction
fund to the escrow for the refunded bonds and the replacement
of the construction fund with proceeds of the 1986 bonds. The
escrow will be fully funded and pledged for the payment of
principal and interest on the outstanding bonds. The purpose
for which the outstanding bonds were authorized and issued
will be accomplished without creating further indebtedness.
Thus, neither the purpose of the refunding bond issue nor the
purpose of the original issuance pursuant to K.S.A. 72-6761
will be defeated by the proposal. In fact, due to the
vagaries of federal tax law, for a short time, the proposed
transaction will substantially enhance the savings
accomplished by the refunding thus reducing the overall
expense of the original project to the issuer.
It is our opinion that the proposed refinancing is well within
the District's statutory authority as described in this
opinion. Obviously any such transaction which diverted bond
proceeds from the lawful purposes of accomplishing the project
and refunding the bonds issued for the project would run afoul
of K.S.A. 10-117 and 10-427a. We find no such difficulty,
however, with the refinancing proposed by the District as
described in your letter.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Mary F. Carson
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MFC:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.