Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-086

1986-086Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATT ORNEY GENERAL June 5, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 86
Charles R. Rayl
P.O. Box 640
302 Broadway
Cottonwood Falls, Kansas 66845
Re: Drainage and Levees -- Watershed Districts -- Use
of Absentee Ballots or Voter Proxy in Election of
Directors
Elections -- Absentee Voting -- Application to
Watershed District Elections
Synopsis: K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 24-1211, which provides for the
election of directors of a watershed district at an
annual meeting, states that elections shall be by
ballot and that qualified voters shall be entitled
to vote at any such meeting. Said statutory
language does not authorize absentee ballots to be
voted at said meeting, nor does it authorize the
use of proxy voting. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1985
Supp. 24-1211; G.S. 1961 Supp. 25-1102, Repealed,
L. 1967, ch. 208, §19; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 25-1115;
K.S.A. 25-1117; 25-1119.
Dear Mr. Rayl:
As attorney for South Fork Watershed Joint District No. 76 of
Chase, Butler, and Greenwood Counties, you request our
opinion on whether voter proxy or absentee ballots are
permitted to be voted by qualified voters at the annual
meeting of a watershed district.
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 24-1211, which provides for election of
directors at an annual meeting, states:
"In not less than twelve (12) months, nor
more than thirteen (13) months after the
recording of the certificates of
incorporation, and annually thereafter, a
meeting shall be held for the election of
directors whose terms expire . . . .
Elections shall be by ballot. Qualified
voters shall be entitled to vote at any
such meeting." (Emphasis added.)
The statute thus provides that an election for the directors
of a watershed district shall be by ballot, and that qualified
voters shall be entitled to vote at any such meeting.
However, it makes no provision concerning the use of absentee
ballots or the legality of a person voting by proxy at the
annual meeting.
In order to answer your question on absentee ballots, it is
necessary to examine Kansas case law and the general election
laws providing for absentee voting, K.S.A. 25-1101 et
seq. These statutes by their terms apply only to primary
and general elections and to question submitted elections.
In Wycoff v. Board of County Commissioners, 191 Kan. 658
(1963), plaintiffs contended that the Logan County Board of
County Commissioners had a mandatory obligation to inform
qualified electors absent in military service of their right
to register before a special election. The Supreme Court of
Kansas disagreed, noting that:
"[O]ur statute which permits voting by
citizens absent from the state does not
apply to a special election such as here
considered. It applies only to primary
and general elections and to the offices
specifically designated. (G.S. 1961
Supp., 25-1102.)" (Repealed by L. 1967,
ch. 208, §19.)
While the absentee voting statute cited in this case has been
repealed, the act in which it was contained has been replaced
by K.S.A. 25-1114 et seq., an act which also deals with
absentee voting. K.S.A. 25-1119 in particular contains broad
provisions which permit an absent registered elector the right
to vote an absentee ballot upon the day of any primary,
general or question submitted election, but makes no such
provision concerning a special election. Accordingly, we
conclude that the decision of the Kansas Supreme Court denying
a citizen the right to vote by absentee ballot at a special
election is still valid under our current election laws, and
is relevant for purposes of this opinion.
In 1967, an opinion was requested from Attorney General Kent
Frizzell as to whether residents of the state of Kansas
owning land in an irrigation district could vote by absentee
ballot at the election for directors of the irrigation
district. Attorney General Frizzell responded with a letter
to Mr. Clayton S. Flood stating:
"From the statutes directly involved and
the general election laws of Kansas it is
our conclusion that absentee ballots are
neither required nor authorized. The
general election laws providing for
absentee ballots, 25-1101 et seq. by
their terms apply only to certain
elections. These are the elections of
members of the legislature, state, county,
township, city, and school officers."
In our opinion, the rule which prevented the use of absent
voter ballots at an election for directors of an irrigation
district would also prevent the use of absent voter ballots at
an election for directors of a watershed district. Although
K.S.A. 42-706, a statute dealing with the board of directors
of irrigation districts, has since been amended at subsection
(f) to specifically allow for the election of directors by
absentee voting, no such amendment has been made to K.S.A.
1985 Supp. 24-1211. Thus, an election for the directors of a
watershed district must adhere to general election law
guidelines for absentee voting provided at K.S.A. 25-1101
et seq.
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 25-1115 defines general and primary
elections:
"'General election' means the election
held on the Tuesday succeeding the first
Monday in November of even-numbered
years, the elections held for officers on
the first Tuesday in April, and in the
case of special elections of any officers
to fill vacancies, the election at which
any such officer is finally elected."
"'Primary election' means the election
held on the first Tuesday in August of
even-numbered years, the election held
five weeks preceding the election on the
first Tuesday in April, and any other
preliminary election at which part of the
candidates for special election to any
national, state, county, city or school
office are eliminated by the process of
the election but at which no officer is
finally elected." (Emphasis added.)
K.S.A. 25-1117 defines a question submitted election:
"'Question submitted election' means any
election at which a special question is to
be voted on by the electors of the state
or a part of them." (Emphasis added.)
Because the annual election for directors of a watershed
district may be held at any time during the year, it cannot be
classified as a general or primary election. Furthermore,
such election clearly does not fall within the statutory
definition of a question submitted election. Thus, we
conclude an election to choose directors of a watershed
district must be classified as a special election. Once this
classification has been made, we must next determine whether
the Kansas general election laws prohibit the use of absent
voter ballots at a special election.
K.S.A. 25-1119 deals with the extent of the absentee voting
right. The statute allows any registered elector, whether
absent from the elector's voting place due to travel, sickness
or military service, the right to vote an absentee ballot on
the day of any primary, general or question submitted
election. Since the statute makes no specific reference to
special elections, we infer that the legislature did not
intend to confer absentee voting rights on qualified electors
of a special election. This inference is supported by two
Latin phrases frequently used in statutory construction. The
first, inclusio unius est exclusio alterius, means
"the inclusion of one is the exclusion of another;" the
second, unius est exclusio alterius, means "the
expression of one thing is the exclusion of another."
We conclude that, based on the Kansas Supreme Court decision
in Wycoff v. Board of County Commissioners, supra, a
letter from Attorney General Kent Frizzell prohibiting the
use of absentee ballots at special elections, and statutory
construction of Kansas general election laws pertaining to
absentee voting (K.S.A. 25-1101 et seq.), absentee ballots
are not permitted to be voted by qualified voters at the
annual meeting of a watershed district.
You also inquire whether a person may vote by proxy to elect
directors at the annual meeting of a watershed district. It
is our opinion that such proxy voting is not authorized.
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 24-1211 provides that qualified voters shall
be entitled to vote at any such meeting. Nowhere in this
section or any other laws pertaining to elections in the state
of Kansas is there any reference to the use of a proxy except
for the organization of the county central committee of a
political party.
In 1967, a similar question was asked of Attorney General
Kent Frizzell, in regard to irrigation district
elections. Attorney General Frizzell responded with a
letter to Mr. Arno Windscheffel stating:
"The irrigation district is a public
quasi-municipal corporation and as such
is not governed by the general corporation
laws. Therefore, the use of proxy votes
by stockholders of a private corporation
where the same is authorized by statute
and by the articles and bylaws of the
corporation is not analogous to or
authority for their use in the operation
of an irrigation district."
We concur with this result, and feel it is analogous to your
similar question regarding a watershed district. Thus, we
conclude the use of proxy votes by qualified electors at the
annual meeting of a watershed district is not authorized by
Kansas general election laws.
In summary, it is our opinion that K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 24-1211,
which provides for the election of directors of a watershed
district at an annual meeting, does not authorize absentee
ballots to be voted at said meeting, nor does it authorize the
use of proxy voting.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:BPA:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.