Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-078

1986-078Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL May 29, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 78
The Honorable Joan Finney
State Treasurer
700 Harrison, 3rd Floor
P.O. Box 737
Topeka, Kansas 66601
Re: Taxation--Mortgage Registration and Intangibles--
Application of Mortgage Registration Fee
Requirements to Federal Land Banks
Synopsis: Federal law prescribes that federal land banks are
exempt from state taxation, except for those taxes
on real estate held by a federal land bank. In
that federal law supersedes inconsistent state law,
and that the Kansas mortgage registration fee is a
tax on an intangible, the federal land bank must be
allowed to register its validly executed mortgages
in Kansas without being required to pay mortgage
registration fees, and such mortgages are
enforceable in Kansas courts. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 79-3101, 12 U.S.C. §§931, 2011, 2055.
*
Dear Mrs. Finney:
As the Treasurer of the State of Kansas, you have requested
our opinion regarding whether federal land banks must pay
intangibles taxes and are thus subject to the provisions of
the Kansas mortgage registration tax act found at K.S.A. 79-
3101 et seq.
You cite in your letter that federal land banks are
"considered to be private corporations and not governmental
agencies." Federal Land Bank at Wichita v. Read, 237 Kan.
751 (1985). That statement is not entirely in context. While
it is true the land bank was determined to be a private
corporation in Kansas, it was construed as such for the
purposes of due process under the 5th amendment to the U.S.
Constitution. The Kansas Supreme Court cited DeLaigle v.
Federal Land Bank of Columbia, 568 F.Supp. 1432 (S.D. Ga.
1983) with approval in Read. The language the Supreme Court
accepted was
" . . . the Court holds that the Federal
Land Bank of Columbia is a private
corporation without sufficient
governmental involvement to support a
cause of action under the federal due
process clause of the Fifth Amendment."
568 F.Supp. at 1439.
These cases are an attempt to establish that federal land
banks are not subject to the administrative hearing
requirements imposed by the Fifth Amendment. The courts have
thus tried to allow the land banks to operate in the market
place.
For most purposes, federal land banks are federal
instrumentalities. 12 U.S.C. §2011. As such, the land bank
comes under regulation of the federal government and is
granted protections and privileges afforded by federal
statutes. One such protection is from the plenary power of
the state to tax; one such privilege is that of immunity from
state taxation at the discretion of Congress. Federal Land
Bank v. Board of County Comm'rs, 368 U.S. 146, 149, 82
S.Ct. 282, 7 L.Ed.2d 199 (U.S. Kan. 1961). Kansas has held
that this protection and privilege extends to
instrumentalities to exempt them from paying taxes on
mortgages offered for registration. Home Owner's Loan Corp.
v. Anderson, 145 Kan. 209 (1937). These protections and
privileges are codified for land banks at 12 U.S.C. §2055
(essentially a recodification of 12 U.S.C. §931) which states:
"Every federal land bank and every federal
land bank association and the capital,
reserves and surplus thereof, and the
income derived therefrom shall be exempt
from federal, state, municipal, and local
taxation, except taxes on real estate held
by a federal land bank or a federal land
bank association to the same extent,
according to its value, as other similar
property held by other persons is taxed."
Thus, the only state tax the Federal land bank is required to
pay is one placed on real estate.
The Kansas mortgage registration fee is a tax. Berger v.
Bierschbach 201 Kan. 740, 745 (1968). It is not a fee
charged for the administrative work necessary to protect land
titles with mortgages. Home Owners' Loan Corp. v. Anderson,
145 Kan. 209, 210. The mortgage registration tax is
imposed upon the mortgage instrument. See, Attorney
General Opinion No. 79-84. In that the federal land bank is a
federal instrumentality immune from state taxes other than
those placed upon real property, 12 U.S.C. §2055, and the
mortgage registration tax is imposed upon the instrument
evidencing debt upon the real property, but not on the
property itself, the land bank is not required to pay
mortgage registration fees on mortgages it holds.
The state is not bound, however, to provide a registry for the
land bank for free. The state may charge a reasonable fee to
meet the administrative expenses of the registry. Federal
Land Bank of New Orleans v. Crosland, 261 U.S. 374, 378, 43
S.Ct. 385, 67 L.Ed. 703 (U.S. Ala. 1923), Home Owners Loan
Corp. v. Anderson, 145 Kan. at 211. The state, though, has
not recognized the fee as a registration fee, but rather as a
tax. 145 Kan. at 211. If it attempted to disguise the
mortgage registration tax by confusing it with an
administrative fee, then courts may be called upon to
determine how far the charge is in excess of administrative
expenses. The legislature has never attempted to do this,
however, impliedly adopting the court-imposed interpretation
of the mortgage registration fee as a tax.
Although the tax could conceivably be considered optional, the
law of Kansas makes it a necessity to record such mortgages to
alert third party purchasers without notice. The fee is
required in practicality for access to Kansas courts. Since
federal law supersedes inconsistent laws of the state, it is
our judgment that the federal land bank must be allowed to
register its mortgages in Kansas without being required to pay
mortgage registration taxes and is protected from the usual
consequences for failure to pay mortgage registration taxes.
It is our opinion, therefore, that all validly executed
federal land bank mortgages may be filed without payment of
the mortgage registration fee, and such mortgages are
enforceable in Kansas courts.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.