Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-070

1986-070Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORN EY GENERAL
- May 9, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 70
Larry E. Scheller
Leavenworth County Clerk
Courthouse
4th and Walnut
Leavenworth, Kansas 66048
Re: Counties and County Officers -- County
Commissioners; Powers and Duties -- Rearrangement
of Commissioner Districts
Synopsis: The Leavenworth County Board of County
Commissioners has the authority to rearrange its
commissioner districts by county resolution, as
long as the commissioners comply with the broad
guidelines for redistricting contained in K.S.A.
19-204 and Kansas case law. The statute requires
the board of commissioners to divide the county
into commissioner districts which are "as compact
and equal in population as possible." As stated in
the statute, the commissioner districts are subject
to rearrangement at least once every three years.
Additionally, the Kansas Supreme Court has imposed
the requirement that the integrity of the
boundaries of voting precincts be maintained. If a
county adheres to these guidelines in rearranging
its county commissioner districts, the fact that
the redistricting shifts some electors from one
commissioner district to another, with the result
that certain electors' ability to vote or run for
the office of county commissioner is affected, will
have no bearing on the legality of the county
resolution. Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-204; Gen.
Stat. 1915, §2539; Kan. Const., Art. 4, §2.
Dear Mr. Scheller:
As county election officer in Leavenworth County, you
request our opinion as to the legality of a resolution passed
by the Leavenworth County Board of County Commissioners
which rearranges their districts to make the districts more
equal in population. The resolution redistributes the
population in the following manner: 1st district - 32.09%;
2nd district - 33.95%; and 3rd district - 33.96%. The
result is that some electors are shifted from one commissioner
district to another. As certain electors' ability to vote or
run for the office of county commissioner is affected by the
redistricting, you inquire whether such action is legal.
The Kansas Constitution provides at Article 4, §2:
"Not less than three county commissioners
shall be elected in each organized county
in the state, as provided by law."
K.S.A. 19-204, which sets out the Kansas requirements for the
redistricting of county commissioner districts, provides at
subsection (a):
"The board of county commissioners
shall, on the day of the organization of
the board or as soon thereafter as may be
possible, meet and divide the county into
three commissioner districts or such
number of districts as is prescribed by
resolution of the board, as compact and
equal in population as possible, and
number them, subject to alteration at
least once every three years."
Accordingly, the board of commissioners is statutorily
required to divide the county into at least three commissioner
districts which are as compact and equal in population as
possible. In addition, the statute specifically states that
the districts are subject to alteration at least once every
three years. In addressing the issue of whether the
resolution passed by the Leavenworth County Board of County
Commissioners is legal, it is helpful to examine relevant
Attorney General Opinions and Kansas Supreme Court cases.
These opinions and cases analyze the meaning of "compact and
equal," and discuss when a county must reapportion its
commissioner districts in order to meet the statutory
requirements of K.S.A. 19-204.
In a letter to Merle Duncan Jr. dated March 7, 1986, the
Attorney General gave a general analysis of the law regarding
the redistricting of county commissioner districts. The letter
stated that K.S.A. 19-204 does not require an automatic
redistricting every three years. Rather, the statute merely
sets the guideline that commissioner districts should be
examined in light of the stated criteria "as compact and equal
in population as possible" at least once every three years.
(See also letter to Jan Banker from the Attorney General dated
January 27, 1966.) Further, the letter provided the Kansas
courts have no timetable for redistricting other than the
broad guidelines set out in the statute. However, it referred
to the Kansas cases annotated under K.S.A. 19-204 as providing
reasonable guidelines for what our Kansas courts consider to
be "as equal in population as possible."
Additionally, the Attorney General's letter referred to the
United States Supreme Court cases of Avery v. Midland
County, Texas, 390 U.S. 474, 88 S.Ct. 1114, 20 L.Ed.2d 45
(1968), and Reynolds v. Sims, 377 U.S. 533, 84 S.Ct. 1362,
12 L.Ed.2d 506 (1964), which dealt with the redistricting of
state legislatures to units of local government. In those
cases, the Supreme Court stated that its doctrine of "one man,
one vote" applied to local units of government through the
Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. The
Supreme Court went on to describe the criteria for
establishing "one man, one vote":
"We hold today only that the Constitution
permits no substantial variation from
equal population in drawing districts for
units of local government having general
governmental powers over the entire
geographic area served by the body."
(Emphasis added.)
The letter from the Attorney General concluded that based on
the relevant Kansas Supreme Court cases and the two
aforementioned United States Supreme Court cases, county
commissioners were advised to begin the process of
redistricting if the population of each commissioner district
was not substantially equal.
Several Kansas cases describe the Kansas Supreme Court's view
of what a county must do to meet the requiremehts of K.S.A. 19-
204. An early case dealing with the issue of redistricting is
The State, ex rel., v. Osage County, 112 Kan. 256 (1922),
an original proceeding in mandamus to compel the board of
county commissioners of Osage County to redistrict the
county into three commissioner districts. The wording of the
statute upon which the action was based (Gen. Stat. 1915,
§2539) is nearly identical to present day K.S.A. 19-204. The
court stated that the duty of determining how nearly the
proposed districts shall approximate equality in population
and compactness of territory is vested in the board of county
commissioners. The Court went on to provide:
"The rule adopted by the courts generally
is that if men of judgment and discretion
may fairly differ with respect to relative
weight of difference of population and
compactness, the question belongs to the
legislature and the courts will not
interfere." (p. 261.)
Emphasizing that the legislature had placed the discretion in
the board of county commissioners to determine the compactness
of a district, the court concluded that the plaintiff had
failed to show that there had been such an unreasonable
deviation, either in population or compactness of territory,
as would justify mandamus to compel further action. Clearly,
the court would not interfere with the commissioners' decision
absent an intentional abuse of discretion.
In The State, ex rel., v. Labette County, 114 Kan. 726
(1923), the Supreme Court of Kansas again addressed the issue
of rearranging commissioner districts. In that case, the
question for consideration was whether or not a public duty
rested upon the county commissioners to redistrict the
county. In determining that the commissioners did have a
definite duty to redistrict, the court quoted Hayes v.
Rogers, 24 Kan. 143 (1880):
"'Full power of rearranging the county
into commissioner districts is given, with
the limitations that they shall be compact
districts, and as equal in population as
possible. In the very nature of things,
the changes of population in some of our
new and growing counties would require
very radical changes of territory in order
to make the districts equal in population
. . . The alterations can be made as
often as the commissioners see fit. The
statute evidently contemplates one every
three years.' (p. 145.)" (Emphasis
added.)
The court went on to find no apparent reason why the City of
Parsons could not be divided, placing a portion, if necessary,
in each of the three districts. Quoting The State, ex rel.,
v. Osage County, supra, the court reasoned:
"'We think the word "compact" as used in
the statute means that the territory shall
be closely united, and not necessarily
that the residents of each district shall
be united in interest. Besides, we can
conceive of no reason why a city may not
be divided so that part of it lies in one
commissioner district and part in
another. In fact, that condition obtains
in many of the counties where there are
large cities. The city of Kansas City,
Kansas, lies in three different
commissioner districts. The boundary
lines of the district in every case follow
the boundary lines of the city wards so as
not to interfere with the voting
precincts.' (p. 260.)" (Emphasis added.)
The court concluded it was the duty of the county
commissioners to redistrict the county so that the districts
would be as compact and equal in population as possible.
Further, a district could contain only part of a city, as long
as the boundary lines of the district always followed the
boundary lines of the city wards, so that the division would
not interfere with the voting precincts.
The Supreme Court of Kansas reinforced its decision that a
city could be divided so that part of it lies in one
commissioner district and part of it lies in another in the
case of State, ex rel., v. Montgomery County Comm'rs., 125
Kan. 379 (1928). The court stated:
"'The fact that an apportionment of a
county on the basis of population may not
be practical without placing parts of a
city in more than one district will not
prevent such a division if the boundary
lines of the districts do not divide city
wards nor interfere with voting
precincts.' (Syl. 53.)"
In Simone v. McPhail, 291 F.Supp. 697 (D.Kan. 1968), the
United States District Court was called upon to examine the
apportionment of Kansas senatorial districts and the county
commissioner districts in Crawford County under the equal
protection clause of the 14th Amendment to the United States
Constitution.
Relying on the Kansas Constitution, Article 4, Section 2 and
K.S.A. 19-204, and taking judicial notice of the powers,
duties, and authorized functions of the Board of County
Commissioners set forth in Chapter 19 of the Kansas Statutes
Annotated, the court found:
"[T]hat the Board of County
Commissioners of a Kansas county performs
some functions normally thought of as
'legislative' and that it has power to
make a number of decisions having broad
impact on all the citizens of the
county. (p. 699.) See Avery v.
Midland County, Texas, 390 U.S. 474, 482-
483, 88 S.Ct. 1114, 20 L.Ed.2d 45
(1968)." (Emphasis added)
The most recent occasion in which the Kansas Supreme Court
addressed the issue of when a county must rearrange its
commissioner districts was the 1971 case of Andrews v. Board
of County Commissioners, 207 Kan. 549. In that case, the
court once again focused on the meaning of the phrase "as
compact and equal in population as possible." (K.S.A. 19-
204.) Appellants claimed that the statutory requirements as
to compactness and equality of population had not been met by
the current division of commissioner districts. The court
noted that, in the rearrangement of commissioner districts,
one other primary factor must be kept in mind in addition to
compactness and equality of population. The court stated:
"In dividing a county into three
commissioner districts the boundaries of
the districts must follow the boundaries
of voting precincts. The people in one
voting precinct cannot be divided or
placed in two or more commissioner
districts." (p. 550.)
The court emphasized that what has been declared as the policy
of the federal courts regarding reapportionment (i.e. "one
man, one vote"), has long been recognized as the policy of the
state courts, via K.S.A. 19-204. That is, when called upon,
the Kansas courts have consistently enforced the requirement
of the statute that each county be rearranged into
commissioner districts which are "as compact and equal in
population as possible." In discussing the meaning of
compactness, the court referred to State ex rel., v. Osage
County, supra, quoting:
"'The word "compact" has various shades
of meaning when used in this connection,
and permits the consideration in good
faith of existing lines, topography, means
of transportation and other factors. It
means that the territory shall be closely
united, and not necessarily that the
residents of each district shall be united
in interest.' (Syl ¶4.)" (Emphasis
added.)
This decision by the Kansas Supreme Court reiterated the
court's long-standing policy that county commissioner
districts can divide a city and still meet the statutory
requirement of compactness. Furthermore, in order to comply
with the statutory guidelines for redistricting, the court
stated it must consider not only the requirement of
compactness, but also the requirement that the integrity of
the boundaries of voting precincts be maintained.
In conclusion, it is our opinion that the Leavenworth County
Board of County Commissioners has the authority to rearrange
its commissioner districts by county resolution, as long as
the commissioners comply with the broad guidelines for
redistricting contained in K.S.A. 19-204 and Kansas case law.
The statute requires the board of commissioners to divide the
county into commissioner districts which are "as compact and
equal in population as possible." As stated in the statute,
the commissioner districts are subject to rearrangement at
least once every three years. Additionally, the Kansas
Supreme Court has imposed the requirement that the integrity
of the boundaries of voting precincts be maintained. If a
county adheres to these guidelines in rearranging its county
commissioner districts, the fact that the redistricting shifts
some electors from one commissioner district to another, with
the result that certain electors' ability to vote or run for
the office of county commissioner is affected, will have no
bearing on the legality of the county resolution.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:BPA:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.