Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-068

1986-068Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL May 2, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 68
The Honorable Lee Hamm
State Representative,
One Hundred Eighth District
State Capitol, Room 285-W
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Agriculture--Grain Commodity Commissions--
Collection and Disposition of Assessments;
Authorized Expenditures
Synopsis: Grain commodity commissions have power to recommend
policy and action to the secretary of the State
Board of Agriculture. The commissions may override
a determination made by the secretary based on
those recommendations by a two-thirds vote of its
members. As funds of the commission are to be used
to implement the administration of the grain
commodity commissions act, by implication, the
commissions may determine how the funds are to be
used. Cited herein: K.S.A. 2-3001; 2-3005; 2-
3008; 75-3701; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 75-3717; K.S.A.
75-3717a.
Dear Representative Hamm:
You have requested the opinion of our office regarding the
authority of the legislature to determine how grain commodity
commissions' money is to be used.
The grain commodity commissions were established pursuant to
K.S.A. 2-3001 et seq. Specifically, K.S.A. 2-3002
establishes three separate commissions, the Kansas corn
commission, the Kansas grain sorghum commission, and the
Kansas soybean commission. Each commission is attached to and
part of the division of markets of the state board of
agriculture. Each commission has express powers and duties,
as provided in K.S.A. 2-3005. These powers and duties include
making recommendations to the secretary of the state board of
agriculture regarding their respective interests and advising
and cooperating with Kansas State University regarding
research and development.
A mill levy is assessed on each bushel of the respective
grains when marketed through commercial channels. K.S.A. 2-
3008 provides that the moneys collected shall be deposited in
the state treasury. Twenty percent of each deposit is to be
credited to the general fund, and the balance is to be
credited to each of the respective commission funds
proportionally as derived from the assessment of each
respective grain. Your question concerns these funds.
For purposes of budget formulations, each grain commodity
commission is a state agency. K.S.A. 75-3701(3) states:
"'State agency' means any state office or
officer, department, board, commission,
institution, bureau or any agency,
division or unit within any office,
department, board, commission or other
state authority or any person requesting a
state appropriation."
This broad definition makes the provisions regarding
preparation of budgets, K.S.A. 75-3701 et seq.,
applicable to the grain commodity commissions.
Preparing budgets is a function of the state agencies. K.S.A.
1985 Supp. 75-3717(a) ptovides in pertinent part:
"As provided in this section, each state
agency, not later than October first of
each year, shall file with the division of
the budget its budget estimates, and all
amendments and revisions thereof, in the
form provided by the director of the
budget, including a full explanation of
its requests for any appropriations for
the expansion of present services and the
addition of new services."
It would appear, therefore, that there is a legislative intent
to allow each agency to determine how its funds are to be
expended within the bounds of its statutory duties and
powers. However, this general provision is limited by K.S.A.
75-3717a, which provides:
"Nothing in this act shall be construed to
limit or be contrary to any inherent
prerogative of the executive department
or the legislature." (Emphasis added.)
In other words, allowing each agency to determine how its
funds are to be expended is the grant of a privilege, not an
exclusive right.
In their present form, the statutes indicate that at least
impliedly, the commissions may determine how their funds are
to be used. As previously mentioned, the commissions have
express powers and duties. K.S.A. 2-3005(a) states:
"In the administration of this act each
said commission shall have the following
duties, authorities and powers:
"(1) To recommend to the secretary policy
regarding marketing, campaigns of
development, education and publicity for
the Kansas grain commodity and products
made therefrom represented by it,
"(2) to recommend to the secretary the
acceptance of grants and donations;
"(3) to recommend the secretary enter into
such contracts as may be necessary or
advisable for the purposes of this act;
"(4) to recommend that the secretary
cooperate with any local, state, national
or international organization or agency,
whether voluntary or created by the law of
any state or by federal law, engaged in
work or activities similar to the work and
activities of each said commission, and to
direct the division to enter into
contracts with such agencies or
organizations for carrying on campaigns of
development, education or publicity;
"(5) to be advisory to and cooperate and
work with Kansas state university or other
educational or research facilities
regarding research and development
connected with the grain commodities
represented by each said commission."
While these powers are advisory in nature, the commissions
may, by a two-thirds vote of its members, disapprove of any
determination made by the secretary of the board of
agriculture regarding their recommendations. In effect, as
long as the action of the commission does not abrogate, limit
or otherwise affect the power of the secretary to administer
the internal operations of the division, recommendations of
the commission may be implemented. See K.S.A. 2-3005(b).
The use of the funds is limited by K.S.A. 2-3008(b), which
provides:
"All money so credited to the [respective
commissions' funds] shall be expended for
the respective commissions in the
administration of this act, and for the
payment of claims based upon obligations
incurred in the performance of the
activities and functions set forth in this
act, and for no other purpose."
In short, the legislature has given powers to the commissions
to make recommendations, to override disapproval of those
recommendations, and has further provided that commission
funds are to be used for the administration of the act. It is
our opinion that the legislature has impliedly given the
commissions authority to implement their recommendations, as
limited by the provisions of K.S.A. 2-3008(b).
However, the legislature does possess an inherent prerogative
to determine how the money is to be spent. "The power to
appropriate money belonging to the state and rightfully in the
state treasury and over which the legislature has the rightful
control is a legislative power, and, except as is restricted
by the constitution, the legislature has the exclusive power
to direct how, when and for what purpose the public funds
shall be applied in carrying out the objects of the state
government." State, ex rel, v. Fadely, 180 Kan. 652,
Syl. 54 (1957). Attorney General Opinion No. 82-20 opined
that "there can be little question that the submission of
budget requests by state agencies . . . are part of the
appropriation process," p. 10. In that the commodity
commissions funds are derived from a mill levy, the
legislature has authority to direct how the money is to be
used. Thus, if the legislature were to amend the applicable
statutes, it could formulate the budgets for the commissions.
However, unless and until the legislature chooses to amend the
statutes, in our opinion the commissions may determine how
their moneys are to be spent.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.