Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-064

1986-064Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
May 2, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 64
Lynn E. Ebel
Kansas State Board of Pharmacy
503 Kansas Avenue, Suite 328
Topeka, Kansas 66601
Re: Public Health -- Examination and Registration of
Pharmacists -- Rules and Regulations; Patient
Profile Records
Synopsis: The Board of Pharmacy does not have authority to
promulgate a regulation mandating patient profile
records as the proposed regulation goes beyond the
statutory authority conferred on the agency. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 65-1627; 65-1630; 65-1637; 65-1642;
65-1643; 74-1603; K.A.R. 68-2-21 (proposed to take
effect May 1, 1986). -
*
Dear Ms. Ebel:
As the attorney for the Board of Pharmacy for the State of
Kansas, you ask our opinion whether the Board has authority to
adopt a regulation requiring each pharmacy licensed in the
State of Kansas to establish and maintain patient profile
records.
You state that the Board of Pharmacy (Board) has adopted the
following permanent administrative regulation to become
effective May 1, 1986:
"68-2-21. Patient Profile Records.
Each pharmacy shall establish and maintain
a patient profile record for each patient
serviced by the pharmacy. The profile
shall contain sufficient information to
allow monitoring of patient drug therapy
including therapeutic incompatibilities,
drug interactions and potential allergic
reactions. (Authorized by K.S.A. 65-1630;
Implementing K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 65-1642;
Effective May 1, 1986.)"
You also inform us that the Joint Committee on Rules and
Regulations has reviewed K.A.R. 68-2-21 as proposed and is of
the opinion that the Board does not have statutory authority
to adopt the regulation.
A pharmacy must be registered before it may operate in the
state. K.S.A. 65-1643. The Board of Pharmacy, established by
K.S.A. 74-1603 et seg., has the authority to issue and the
power to revoke or suspend a registration. K.S.A. 65-1627(c),
65-1643(a). Pursuant to K.S.A. 65-1630, the Board is
authorized to "adopt and promulgate such reasonable rules and
regulations, not inconsistent with law, as may be necessary to
carry out the purposes and enforce the provisions of this act
The power of an administrative agency to adopt rules and
regulations is administrative in nature, not legislative, and
to be valid a rule or regulation must be within the statutory
authority confirmed upon the agency. Malone Oil Co. v.
Department of Health & Environment, 234 Kan. 1066, 1068
(1984); Wesley Medical Center v. Clark, 234 Kan. 13, Syl.
T5 (1983).
"An administrative rule and regulation
which goes beyond that which the
legislature has authorized, or which
violates the statute, or which alters,
extends, or limits the source of its
legislative powers, is void." Woods v.
Midwest Conveyor Co., 231 Kan. 763, Syl.
53 (1982).
See Lindstrom v. St. Francis Hosp. & Med. Center,
Inc., 6 Kan. App.2d 948, 951 (1981) rev. denied 230 Kan.
818 (1982). In Pork Motel, Corp. v. Kansas Dept of Health
& Environment, 234 Kan. 374, 378-79 (1983), the Kansas
Supreme Court stated:
"Administrative agencies are creatures of
statute and their power is dependent upon
authorizing statutes, therefore any
exercise of authority claimed by the
agency must come from within the
statutes. There is no general or common
law power that can be exercised by an
administrative agency.
. . . Those rules or regulations that go
beyond the authority authorized, which
violate the statute, or are inconsistent
with the statutory powers of the agency
have been found void. Administrative
rules and regulations to be valid must be
appropriate, reasonable and not
inconsistent with the law."
See Tew v. Topeka Police & Fire Civ. Serv. Comm'n.,
237 Kan. 96, 100 (1985); Halford v. City of Topeka, 234
Kan. 934, 939-40 (1984).
The question presented for our opinion is whether the
statutory authority asserted by the Board of Pharmacy as the
basis for K.A.R. 68-2-21 is broad enough to authorize the
regulation. K.S.A. 65-1642, which is listed in the proposed
regulation as the implementing statute, concerns pharmacy
equipment and records. The statute provides that each
pharmacy must be equipped with proper pharmaceutical utensils
and that the Board shall prescribe the minimum requirements.
In accordance with K.S.A. 65-1637(b), a pharmacist must record
all prescription orders in writing. K.S.A. 65-1642 requires
all prescription orders filled by the pharmacy to be kept for
a certain number of years:
"There shall be kept in every pharmacy a
suitable book or file, in which shall be
preserved for a period of not less than
three years, every prescription order
filled at the pharmacy prior to the
effective date of this act and for a
period of not less than five years, every
prescription order filled at the pharmacy
on or after the effective date of this
act, and the book or file of prescription
orders shall at all times be open to
inspection of the members of the board and
the secretary of health and environment
and the duly authorized agents or
employees of such board or secretary and
other proper authorities."
The Board is of the opinion that, even though there is no
express statutory authority concerning patient profile
records, the regulation is reasonable and is not inconsistent
with any statute. The Board maintains the regulation was
promulgated in the interest of the public and is not overly
restrictive as the pharmacy has some discretion to determine
what is sufficient information to allow monitoring of patient
drug therapy.
Even though K.A.R. 68-2-21 is not inconsistent with the
pharmacy statutes, it appears that the regulation extends
the source of its legislative powers. The proposed regulation
provides that the "profile shall contain sufficient
information to allow monitoring of patient drug therapy
including therapeutic incompatibilities, drug interactions and
potential allergic reactions." An argument could be made
that, since a pharmacy must keep written records of
prescription orders, the Board by virtue of its powers to
adopt rules and regulations to carry out its duties has
statutory authority to adopt a regulation requiring pharmacies
to keep patient profile records.
The provisions in K.S.A. 65-1642 concerning equipment and
records are quite different. The statute generally states
that each pharmacy must be properly equipped and that the
"board shall prescribe the minimum of such professional and
technical equipment . . . ." The provisions concerning
records, however, are more specific. K.S.A. 65-1642 does not
require pharmacies to keep records in general, but
specifically states that a pharmacy must keep a record of all
prescription orders. The proposed regulation does not
merely state how information required to be kept by a
pharmacy shall be recorded, the regulation mandates a pharmacy
to obtain more and different kinds of information not
preserved in written prescription orders. Even though patient
profile records would utilize the information contained in the
written prescription orders, the regulation would require a
pharmacy to solicit from its customers information other than
the prescription filled at that pharmacy for that customer.
While individual pharmacies may have some discretion as to the
detail and format of the profile records of its customers,
such a regulation would require pharmacies to create documents
that go beyond the information specifically limited by statute
that a pharmacy is required to keep.
The purpose and desirable goal of K.A.R. 68-2-21 cannot be
questioned. It is our opinion, however, that the Board of
Pharmacy does not have authority to promulgate a regulation
mandating patient profile records as the proposed regulation
goes beyond the statutory authority conferred on the agency.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.