Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-051

1986-051Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL April 7, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 51
Gene Porter
Barton County Attorney
Barton County Courthouse
P.O. Box 881
Great Bend, Kansas 67530
Re: Elections -- Sufficiency of Petitions -- Contents
of Petition; Petition to Challenge Capital Outlay
Resolution
Synopsis: A petition, prepared and filed pursuant to K.S.A.
72-8801 which does not meet the requirements of
K.S.A. 25-3601 et seq., is invalid and has no
effect in preventing a capital outlay levy from
taking effect. Furthermore, even though a petition
is valid under the requirements of K.S.A. 1985
Supp. 25-3602, it must in addition correctly
identify the resolution which it challenges in
order to legally protest the resolution. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 25-3601; K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 25-3602;
K.S.A. 72-8801.
Dear Mr. Porter:
As county attorney for Barton County, you request our
opinion as to whether a petition recently submitted to the
county clerk is legally sufficient. Such petition, which
relates to a resolution passed by the Board of Education of
Unified School District #428 for a capital outlay levy, would
require the question to be submitted to a vote of the electors
of U.S.D. #428, pursuant to the provisions of K.S.A.
72-8801.
Initially, we note that the petition in question specifically
refers to a resolution adopted by the board of education on
January 15, 1986. However, this resolution was superseded by
a subsequent resolution passed on March 4, 1986. You first
inquire whether the submitted petition is sufficient to
challenge the resolution of March 4, even though the petition
specifically identifies the earlier resolution as that which
the petitioners wish to challenge. Second, assuming the
petition is sufficient to challenge the later rescolution, you
inquire whether the petition is legally sufficient, i.e.
whether it meets the requirements of K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 25-3602.
We will address your second question first. The sample
petition which you submitted to us states as follows:
"PETITION
The undersigned, electors of Unified
School District #428 of Barton County,
Kansas, and duly registered voters, hereby
state our opposition to the Capital Outlay
Levy as authorized by Resolution adopted
by U.S.D. #428 Board of Education on
January 15, 1986. In accordance with
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 72-8801, the County
Clerk is hereby petitioned to submit the
question of the proposed Capital Outlay
Levy to a vote of the electors of said
School District."
K.S.A. 72-8801 provides that a tax levy for capital outlay
funds may be authorized by resolution of a board of education
and is effective unless a valid petition in opposition to the
resolution is filed. The statute which lays out a sample
resolution, also states:
"The tax levy authorized by this
resolution may be made, unless a petition
in opposition to the same, signed by not
less than 10% of the qualified electors of
the school district, is filed with the
county election officer of the home county
of the school district within 40 days
after the last publication of this
resolution." (Emphasis added.)
The statute goes on to say:
"In the event that no petition as
specified above is filed in accordance
with the provisions of the notice, the
board of education may make the tax levy
specified in the resolution." (Emphasis
added.)
In determining whether a petition opposing the capital outlay
levy is valid, we must examine it in light of the general
requirements for a sufficient petition, set forth in K.S.A.
25-3601 et seq. K.S.A. 25-3601, in relevant part,
provides:
"Whenever under the laws of this state a
petition is required or authorized as a
part of the procedure applicable to any
county, city, school district or other
municipality, or part thereof, the
provisions of this act shall apply, except
as is otherwise specifically provided in
the statute providing for such petition."
K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 25-3602(b) provides in part:
"Each petition shall, unless otherwise
specifically required:
. . . .
"(3) contain the following recital above
the spaces provided for signatures: 'I
have personally signed this petition. I
am a registered elector of the state of
Kansas and of (here insert name of
political or taxing subdivision) and
my residence address is correctly written
after my name.'"
We note that the sample petition which you submitted does not
contain this recital, or anything similar, above the spaces
provided for signatures. Thus, the petition clearly deviates
from the requirements of K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 25-3602(b).
Furthermore, the opinions of this office have consistently
viewed the requirements of this statute as mandatory. See
Attorney General Opinion Nos. 77-303, 78-40, 81-230, 82-230
ZI
and 84-41. Past opinions have consistently concluded that any
substantial departure from the statutory form will render a
petition invalid. See Opinion Nos. 81-230 and 82-230. We
affirm this result, and conclude that the failure to comply
with the requirement of K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 25-3602(b)(3) is a
substantial irregularity which serves to invalidate the
petition in question.
We also call your attention to subsection (c) of K.S.A. 1985
Supp. 25-3602, which provides:
"Every petition shall contain, at the end
of each set of documents carried by each
circulator, a verification, signed by
the circulator, to the effect that the
circulator personally witnessed the
signing of the petition by each person
whose name appears thereon." (Emphasis
added.)
The verification contained in the sample petition states:
"that he knows that they signed the same
with full knowledge of the contents
thereof;"
Although the sample petition contains a verification, it is
unclear from the language whether the circulator actually
witnessed the signing of the petition. As stated earlier, any
substantial departure from the statutory form will render a
petition invalid. At the same time, a petition should not be
invalidated by unimportant irregularities or defects if it is
in substantial compliance with statutory requisites. See
Community Gas and Service Co., v. Walbaum, 404 P.2d 1014
(Okla., 1965); 26 Am.Jur.2d, Elections §189; 29 C.J.S.
Elections §69. In our opinion, however, this defect in the
verification is a substantial irregularity, as subsection (c)
specifically requires that the circulator personally witness
the signing of the petition by each person whose name appears
thereon. In that statutes governing the sufficiency of
petitions are to be strictly construed, and because the
requirements of K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 25-3602 are mandatory, we
conclude that the sample petition fails to comply with an
additional requirement of the statute.
In regard to the sufficiency of petitions, we emphasize that
the matter of circulating a petition to place a particular
question to a vote is a serious matter. Thus, it is important
that each of the clearly-stated requirements of K.S.A. 1985
Supp. 25-3602 be met. See Attorney General Opinion Nos.
79-290 and 82-230. Persons desiring to prepare and circulate
a petition can obtain a copy of the statutory requirements
from the county library or from this office, and may
additionally wish to seek the advice of private counsel.
Although the above conclusions are dispositive of the question
of sufficiency, you also inquire whether the submitted
petition is sufficient to challenge the resolution of March 4,
even though the resolution of January 15 is specifically
identified as the one which is challenged. In our opinion,
such a petition is defective under the requirements of K.S.A.
1985 Supp. 25-3602(b)(1), which requires a clear statement of
the question which is sought to be voted upon. Accordingly, a
petition which refers to a resolution different than the one
it opposes can have no effect on such a later resolution.
However, we find this question to be moot in the case at hand,
as the sample petition does not meet the other sufficiency
requirements set forth earlier.
In conclusion, a petition, prepared and filed pursuant to
K.S.A. 72-8801 which does not meet the requirements of K.S.A.
25-3601 et seq., is invalid and has no effect in
preventing a capital outlay levy from taking effect.
Furthermore, even though a petition is valid under the
requirements of K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 25-3602, it must in addition
correctly identify the resolution which it challenges in
order to legally protest the resolution.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:BPA:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.