Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1986-044

1986-044Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
March 31, 1986
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 86- 44
David G. Shriver
Attorney for U.S.D. No. 418
1016 North Main Street
P.O. Box 1313
McPherson, Kansas 67460
Re: Schools -- Teachers' Contracts -- Due Process
Procedure; Notice to Discontinue Contract;
Negotiability of Date
Synopsis: Terms of teachers' contracts which are mandatorily
negotiable are listed in K.S.A. 72-5413(1). Other
matters are permissively negotiable if the parties
agree they are properly related to professional
service, the parties are willing to negotiate, and
the matter is not controlled by statute. Pursuant
to K.S.A. 72-5437, a teacher must give timely
notice of his intent not to return the following
school year. Accordingly, the date by which a
teacher must notify the board of education of his
decision not to continue is not negotiable and
cannot be modified by contract. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 72-5411; 72-5413(1); 72-5414; 72-5437.
*
Dear Mr. Shriver:
As the attorney for Unified School District No. 418,
McPherson, Kansas, you ask our opinion regarding the
negotiability of a term in a teacher's contract.
Specifically, you ask whether the date (specified in K.S.A.
72-5437) a teacher must notify the school board of his intent
not to return the following school year is negotiable.
You inform us that the contract in question is worded as
follows:
"1. PROCEDURE FOLLOWING A BINDING AGREEMENT
RATIFIED ON OR BEFORE May 10.
"In the event of failure to give notice that
the teacher does not desire continuation of the
contract in accordance with K.S.A. 72-5437, the
Board may report said default to the Professional
Teaching Practices Commission for action pursuant to
K.S.A. 72-8506 and K.S.A. 72-8507.
"2. PROCEDURE FOLLOWING A BINDING AGREEMENT
RATIFIED AFTER MAY 10.
"In the event that a negotiated agreement had
not been reached by May 10, the penalty clause
described in paragraph II.B.1. above shall commence
fifteen days following ratification of the
negotiated agreement, or June 15, whichever occurs
first."
Under Kansas law, a teacher's employment contract is deemed to
continue for the following school year unless the board of
education notifies the teacher in writing of its intention to
terminate or not renew the contract, or the teacher gives
written notice of his desire not to continue the contract.
K.S.A. 72-5411; 72-5437. Notice given by a teacher must be
timely, as specified in K.S.A. 72-5437:
"A teacher shall give written notice to
the board that the teacher does not desire
continuation of the contract on or before
May 10 or, if applicable, not later than
15 days after final action is taken by the
board upon termination of professional
negotiation absent a binding agreement
under article 54 of chapter 72 of Kansas
Statutes Annotated, whichever is the later
date." See K.S.A. 72-5411.
By statute, teachers have the right to join employees'
organizations which negotiate with the board of education "for
the purpose of establishing, maintaining, protecting or
improving terms and conditions of professional service."
K.S.A. 72-5414. The phrase "terms and conditions of
professional service" is defined by K.S.A. 72-5413(1) as
follows:
. . . (1) salaries and wages, including
pay for duties under supplemental
contracts; hours and amounts of work;
vacation allowance, holiday, sick,
extended, sabbatical, and other leave, and
number of holidays; retirement; insurance
benefits; wearing apparel; pay for
overtime; jury duty; grievance procedure;
including binding arbitration of
grievances; disciplinary procedure;
resignations; termination and nonrenewal
of contracts; reemployment of professional
employees; terms and form of the
individual professional employee contract;
probationary period; professional employee
appraisal procedures; each of the
foregoing is a term and condition of
professional service, regardless of its
impact on the employee or on the operation
of the educational system; and (2) matters
which relate to privileges to be accorded
the recognized professional employees'
organization, including but not limited
to, voluntary payroll deductions, use of
school or college facilities for meetings,
the dissemination of information related
to the professional negotiations process
and related matters to members of the
bargaining unit on school or college
premises through direct contact with
members of the bargaining unit, the use of
bulletin boards on or about the facility,
and the use of the school or college mail
system to the extent permitted by law,
reasonable leaves of absence for members
of the bargaining unit for organizational
purposes such as engaging in professional
negotiating and partaking of instructional
programs properly related to the
representation of the bargaining unit
Items included under K.S.A. 72-5413(1) are mandatorily
negotiable contract terms. U.S.D. No. 501 v. Secretary of
Kansas Department of Human Resources, 235 Kan. 968 (1984).
When proposed by either party, mandatorily negotiable items
must be negotiated in good faith by both parties. Tri-
County Educators' As'sn. v. Tri-County Special Ed., 225
Kan. 781, 783 (1979). "Permissively negotiable" items are
those which the parties to collective negotiations mutually
agree are properly related to professional service and are
willing to negotiate. NEA-Parsons v. U.S.D. No. 503, 225
Kan. 581, Syl. T1 (1979). Matters controlled by statute,
however, are not negotiable. Id. at 586; Tri-County
Educators' As'sn. v. Tri-County Special Ed., 225 Kan. at
784.
The contract provision that you submitted to us provides that,
if a negotiated agreement is not reached by May 10, a teacher
has fifteen days following ratification of the negotiated
agreement, or June 15, whichever occurs first, to notify the
board of education that he does not desire to continue the
contract. In our opinion, the date by which a teacher must
give notice is not mandatorily negotiable, as it is not an
item listed under K.S.A. 72-5413(1). In addition, this term
is not permissively negotiable because the time that notice
must be given is set by statute. K.S.A. 72-5437 provides that
a teacher must give notice by May 10 or not later than
fifteen days after final action is taken by the board upon
termination of professional negotiation absent a binding
agreement, whichever is the later date. Parties to the
negotiation of teachers' contracts, therefore, can not modify
this rule by providing that teachers must notify the board by
June 15, even though negotiations have not terminated.
In summary, terms of teachers' contracts which are mandatorily
negotiable are listed in K.S.A. 72-5413(1). Other matters are
permissively negotiable if the parties agree they are properly
related to professional service, the parties are willing to
negotiate, and the matter is not controlled by statute.
Pursuant to K.S.A. 72-5437, a teacher must give timely
notification of his intent not to return the following school
year. Accordingly, the date by which a teacher must notify
the board of education of his decision not to continue is not
negotiable and cannot be modified by contract.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:RLN:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.