Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-184

1985-184Kanag

Full text

December 30, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 184
Marvin R. Webb, Director
Grain Inspection Department
235 S. Topeka
P.O. Box 1918
Topeka, Kansas 66601-1918
Re: Grain and Forage--Inspecting, Sampling, Storing,
Weighing and Grading Grain; Terminal and Local
Warehouses--Lost or Destroyed Receipts; Indemnity
Bonds
Synopsis: K.S.A. 34-257a establishes a procedure by which
a lost or destroyed negotiable warehouse receipt may
be replaced by a duplicate receipt. One of the
requirements which a claimant for a duplicate must
meet is the filing of a bond conditioned to indemnify
the warehouseman against any loss occasioned by the
issuance of such duplicate receipt. The statute does
not indicate the length of time for which such bond
must remain in effect. In that there is no time limit
during which a negotiable warehouse receipt must be
negotiated, the bond technically should be maintained
as long as the receipt is outstanding. Realistically,
however, storage fees and other expenses incurred by
the warehouseman will eventually consume the value of
the grain for which the warehouse receipt and its
duplicate were issued, so that the bond will no longer
be necessary for the warehouseman's protection.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 34-244; 34-254; 34-257a;
34-266; 34-276.
Dear Mr. Webb:
As Director for the Grain Inspection Department, you request our
opinion regarding the length of time for which an indemnity bond,
issued pursuant to K.S.A. 34-257a, must be maintained.
K.S.A. 34-257a provides in pertinent part as follows:
"Where a negotiable warehouse receipt has been
lost or destroyed, the warehouseman shall
issue a new receipt upon the same terms,
subject to the same conditions, and bearing on
its face the number and the date of the
receipt in lieu of which it is issued, and a
plain and conspicuous statement that it is a
duplicate receipt issued in lieu of a lost or
destroyed receipt, upon compliance by the
claimant with the following conditions:
"(a) Before issuing a duplicate receipt, the
warehouseman shall require the claimant
therefor to make and file with him .
"(2) a bond in the amount double the value, at
the time the bond is given, of the grain
represented by the lost or destroyed receipt.
Such bond shall be in the form approved by the
director and shall be conditioned to indemnify
the warehouseman or any holder or other person
entitled to the grain against all loss,
liability or expense which he may sustain by
reason of the issuance of such duplicate
receipt. Such bond shall have as surety
thereon a corporate surety company which is
authorized to do business under the laws of
the state of Kansas and is subject to service
of process in this state in a suit on the
bond." (Emphasis added.)
Neither this statute nor those immediately preceding or
subsequent to it indicate the length of time for which the
required bond must remain effective. Technically, the duplicate
warehouse receipt for which the bond is issued, just as any
original negotiable warehouse receipt, would remain negotiable
until canceled. See K.S.A. 34-244 and 34-254.
Cancellation does not occur until the warehousemen delivers the
grain for which he has issued the receipt. Given the purpose of
K.S.A. 34-257a, which is to protect warehouseman from any loss
occasioned by the issuance of a duplicate receipt, and the fact
that there is virtually no time limit during which a negotiable
warehouse receipt must be negotiated, the bond required by K.S.A.
34-257a should be maintained in perpetuity.
There is, however, a possible situation in which a negotiable
warehouse receipt may lose its negotiability short of
cancellation. K.S.A. 34-276 provides as follows:
"After the grain has been lawfully sold to
satisfy warehouseman's lien, or has been
lawfully sold or disposed of for any other
cause, the warehouseman shall not thereafter
be liable for failure to deliver the grain to
the depositor or owner of the grain, or to a
holder of a receipt given for the grain when it
was deposited, even if such receipt be
negotiable. After such lawful sale, the
proceeds of such sale, after deducting any
lawful liens, shall be held for the benefit of
the owner, or the holder of the receipt or
receipts."
Pursuant to K.S.A. 34-266, a warehouseman has a lien on grain
deposited for all lawful storage charges as well as other listed
fees and expenses. Thus, even if there are two receipts
outstanding for the same grain, eventually the value of the grain
for which the receipts were issued will be consumed by the unpaid
storage costs. If and when this occurs, there will no longer be
a need to maintain the bond because the warehouseman will be
relieved of liability under K.S.A. 34-276.
In conclusion, there are no Kansas statutes or case law which
clearly set the length of time for which an indemnity bond issued
in conjunction with a duplicate negotiable warehouse receipt must
be maintained. In that a negotiable warehouse receipt remains
negotiable until cancelled, it is our opinion that the bond
should remain in effect in perpetuity. Realistically, however,
storage fees and other expenses incurred by the warehouseman will
eventually consume the value of the grain for which the warehouse
receipt and its duplicate were issued, so that the bond will no
longer be necessary for the warehouseman's protection.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
JuleneL.Miller
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:JLM:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.