Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-174

1985-174Kanag

Full text

December 12, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 174
The Honorable Michael R. O'Neal
State Representative, 104th District
P.O. Box 1868
Hutchinson, Kansas 67504
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas --
Constitutional Amendment and Revision -- Proposals
by Legislature; Approval by Electors
Synopsis: As previously noted in Attorney General Opinion No.
85-110, a concurrent resolution containing a
constitutional amendment adopted by the legislature
during the 1985 session may be amended during the
1986 session prior to being submitted to the voters
in November, 1986. At present, Chapter 360 of the
Laws of 1985 provides for the submission to the
voters of an amendment to Article 15, Section 10,
which would allow liquor by the drink under certain
circumstances. The amendment must be approved by a
majority of the voters of the entire state in order
to be adopted and a majority of the voters in a
particular county before becoming effective in that
county. Such a "dual purpose" is clearly disclosed
in the explanatory statement which is to be printed
on the ballot with the proposed amendment.
Further, since the Kansas Constitution limits,
rather than confers, power, the people of the state
may amend the constitution in any manner they deem
appropriate, subject only to the limits of the
United States Constitution. Cited herein: K.S.A.
41-301; L. 1985, Chs. 360, 364; Kan. Const.,
Art. 14, §1; Art. 15, §10; Kan. Bill of Rights,
§§2, 20.
Dear Representative O'Neal:
As State Representative for the 104th District, you request
our opinion concerning language used in the proposed liquor by
the drink amendment adopted by the 1985 Legislature for
submission to the voters in November of 1986. L. 1985, Ch.
360. Specifically, you inquire about the effect of a "yes"
vote by a voter on the amendment. It is your understanding
that such a vote would have a dual effect, namely to help the
amendment receive the simple majority it needs across the
state in order to be approved, and also to allow liquor by the
drink in the individual county of the voter's residence. You
seek our opinion as to whether such a system is in fact
contemplated by the amendment, and, if so, whether this would
be constitutional.
As you note in your letter, this office has recently issued an
opinion concerning the ability of the legislature to amend a
proposed constitutional amendment prior to its submission to
the voters. In Attorney General Opinion No. 85-110, we
concluded that the legislature could, by two-thirds
affirmative vote, alter the terms of the proposed
classification amendment contained in Chapter 364 of the 1985
Session Laws. Accordingly, should we conclude that a defect
exists in the provisions of the liquor by the drink amendment,
the 1986 Legislature could, if it desired, remedy the problem
in time for the general election in the fall.
However, in examining this question, it is our opinion that no
defect exists in the language of the proposed amendment which
would require such action, although the legislature is
always free, as our prior opinion noted, to make whatever
changes it desires prior to submission to the voters. The
proposed amendment would alter the provisions of Article 15,
Section 10 of the state constitution, which was last changed
in 1948. At that time, language was inserted which forever
prohibited the "open saloon." This language has subsequently
been interpreted by the Kansas Supreme Court to prohibit any
arrangement whereby an establishment is open to the public,
without any limit on who may enter or purchase alcoholic
beverages which are to be consumed on the premises. State ex
rel. v. Kennedy, 225 Kan. 13, Syl. §13 (1978). The
proposed amendment would strike the reference to open saloons,
and would insert in its place the following:
"The sale of intoxicating liquor by the
individual drink in public places is
prohibited, except that the legislature
may permit, regulate, license and tax the
sale of intoxicating liquor by the drink
in public places in a county where the
qualified electors of the county approve,
by a majority vote of those voting on this
proposition, to adopt this proposition,
but such sales shall be limited to: (1)
Public places where gross receipts from
sales of food for consumption on the
premises constitute not less than 30% of
the gross receipts from all sales of food
and beverages on such premises; or (2)
public places for which a temporary permit
has been issued as authorized by law . . .
." (Emphasis added.)
Also on the ballot is to be this explanatory statement:
"This proposed amendment would authorize
the legislature to permit, license,
regulate and tax the sale of intoxicating
liquor by the drink in public places which
are located in a county where the voters
have approved such sale in their county.
"A vote for the proposed amendment would
permit the sale of liquor by the drink in
public places which are located in a
county where the voters approve such sale
in their county.
"A vote against the proposed amendment
would continue the current prohibition
against the sale of liquor by the drink in
public places." (Emphasis added.)
In our opinion, it is clear from a reading of both the
proposed amendment and the explanatory statement that a "dual
function" is in fact to be given to each person's vote in the
November, 1986 election. As is always the case for
constitutional amendments, the proposition itself must be
approved by a majority of those persons voting on the issue.
Kansas Constitution, Article 14, Section 1. At the same time,
an affirmative vote on the proposition by the residents of a
particular county will allow the sale of intoxicating liquor
by the drink in public places in that county, subject to
either the restriction for 30% food sales or under a temporary
permit. (The specifics of such permits will doubtless be
provided by future legislative action, in that the language
concerning such permits is not self-executing.)
In adopting such a course of action, the legislature intends
to avoid the need for a subsequent election in each county on
the same question. We note that a similar procedure was once
employed in a similar context, for when the voters in the 1948
general election approved the present language in Article 15,
Section 10, the legislature subsequently determined that no
city of the first or second class whose voters rejected the
amendment was authorized to issue licenses for the sale of
alcoholic liquor in retail outlets. K.S.A. 41-301. In this
way, a "no" vote on the 1948 proposition was given a dual
effect after the fact. The distinction in the present case
lies in the fact that such a dual effect is clearly disclosed
to the voters at the outset, but we find this difference to he
of no legal importance.
Nor can we conclude that the action of the legislature in
presenting the issue in this fashion is somehow
unconstitutional, or that the voters cannot approve it in this
format. The state constitution is the paramount and
fundamental law of Kansas, and limits the powers of the -
people's government, rather than conferring such powers.
Kansas Bill of Rights, §§2, 20; Lemons v. Noller, 144 Kan.
813, 816-17 (1936); Atkinson v. Woodmansee, 68 Kan. 71
(1904); Prohibitory Amendment Cases, 24 Kan. 700, 711-12
(1881). Accordingly, while a statute may be found to be
inconsistent with the grant of power made by the people to the
legislature, a constitutional amendment cannot be
unconstitutional, unless the procedures used in adopting it
themselves contravene those set forth in the constitution for
such amendments [Kansas Constitution, Article 14, Section 1;
Moore v. Shanahan, 207 Kan. 645, 651-55 (1971)], or the
amendment is in conflict with the Unites States Constitution
or the Federal Bill of Rights. Van Sickle v. Shanahan, 212
Kan. 426, 449-51 (1973). In such cases, the proposition
submitting the amendment to the people is void, and the
election of no effect. Moore, supra. Although you did
not inquire about the propriety of the procedures used to
adopt the concurrent resolution, we know of no defect along
these lines which would nullify it and so vitiate the results
of an election on the liquor by the drink question.
In conclusion, as previously noted in Attorney General Opinion
No. 85-110, a concurrent resolution containing a
constitutional amendment adopted by the legislature during the
1985 session may be amended during the 1986 session prior to
being submitted to the voters in November, 1986. At present,
Chapter 360 of the Laws of 1985 provides for the submission to
the voters of an amendment to Article 15, Section 10, which
would allow liquor by the drink under certain circumstances.
The amendment must be approved by a majority of the voters of
the entire state in order to be adopted and a majority of the
voters in a particular county before becoming effective in
that county. Such a "dual purpose" is clearly disclosed in
the explanatory statement which is to be printed on the ballot
with the proposed amendment. Further, since the Kansas
Constitution limits, rather than confers, power, the people of
the state may amend the constitution in any manner they deem
appropriate, subject only to the limits of the United States
Constitution.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Jeffrey S. Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.