Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-168

1985-168Kanag

Full text

November 12, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 168
Philip S. Harness
Johnson County Counselor
110 S. Cherry, Suite 8
Olathe, Kansas 66061
Re: Counties and County Officers -- Powers and Duties
-- Public Letting of Contracts; Prequalification
of Bidders
Synopsis: Where a county is required to let contracts to the
lowest and best, or to the lowest responsible
bidder, such bidding must be open to all who wish
to offer bids. Prequalification of bidders for
the construction of public buildings and county
roads would be contrary to both Kansas statutes and
to public policy. However, as the statutes
providing for the bidding of contracts for the
construction of bridges are contained in an act
which is not uniform as to all of its sections, a
county may employ a charter ordinance to exempt
itself from these provisions and substitute
language which allows prequalification of
bidders. Cited herein: K.S.A. 19-101a, as amended
by L. 1985, Ch. 208, §1; 19-214; 19-215; 68-521;
68-1113; 68-1115.
*
Dear Mr. Harness:
As County Counselor of Johnson County, Kansas, you inquire
whether the county may devise a method or plan for
prequalifying bidders pursuant to statutes governing the
public letting of contracts for: (1) the construction of
county or public buildings; (2) the construction, servicing,
repairing or maintaining of any county road; (3) and the
construction of bridges. For the reasons stated below, in our
opinion prequalification of bidders for the first two of these
types of contracts is not permissible, although for the third
(i.e. bridges) it is possible under the scope of county home
rule.
Home rule powers of county government are broad. However,
such powers are limited by K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 19-101a, as
amended by L. 1985, Ch. 208, 51, which states in pertinent
part:
"(a) The board of county commissioners may
transact all county business and perform
all powers of local legislation and
administration it deems appropriate,
subject only to the following limitations,
restrictions or prohibitions: (1)
Counties shall be subject to all acts of
the legislature which apply uniformly to
all counties."
This opinion is limited to a discussion of all acts of the
legislature which are applicable to counties. For a
discussion of bidding procedures for municipalities in
general, see Attorney General Opinion No. 85-121.
Several Kansas statutes are relevant to the determination of
the proper procedures for county bidding practices. K.S.A.
19-214 deals in general with the awarding of contracts for the
construction of public buildings, and states:
"(a) Except as provided in subsection (b),
all contracts for the expenditure of
county moneys for the construction of any
courthouse, jail or other county building,
or the construction of any bridge in
excess of $10,000, shall be awarded, on a
public letting, to the lowest and best bid
K.S.A. 68-521 concerns improvement of county roads, and
provides:
"The board shall conduct the letting of
all contracts in such a manner as to give
free, open competition, and all bidders
shall be given an equal opportunity to bid
upon the plans and specifications on file
Finally, K.S.A. 68-1115 regarding bridge construction
specifies:
"All bids shall be considered, and
accepted or rejected. In case the work is
let at such public letting, contract shall
be awarded to the lowest responsible
bidder . . . ."
The above statutory language indicates that prequalification
of bidders was not contemplated by the legislature. However,
this does not mean that a county is without safeguards in
selecting a valid bid from a qualified and responsible
bidder. It is clear that, in the absence of arbitrariness,
oppressiveness or fraud, counties are not required to accept
the lowest hid. Inclusion of the term "responsible" in the
phrase "lowest responsible bidder" has been construed to imply
"skill, judgment and integrity necessary to the faithful
performance of the contract, as well as sufficient financial
resources and ability." Williams v. City of Topeka, 85 Kan.
857, 863 (1911). Further, the requirement that performance
bonds be posted is another protection for the county against
an irresponsible bidder. See K.S.A. 68-521. The interests
which justify prequalification are adequately protected by
the statutory language and by judicial interpretation of that
language. 20 C.J.S. Counties §189 (1940).
This conclusion is further supported by the provisions for
publication of notice of the letting of bids. K.S.A. 19-215
states that notice shall be published in some newspaper
printed in the county, or if there is no newspaper, by
conspicuous posting. While this section applies to the
provisions regarding county and public buildings, K.S.A.
68-521, regarding roads, requires at least two consecutive
weekly publications of notice of the letting. The requirement
in the bridge and culvert section is less specific, but the
language mandates that the county furnish proposal blank
forms, and that "all bidders shall be given an equal
opportunity to bid upon the plans and specifications on
file." K.S.A. 68-1113.
Strong policy reasons mitigate against prequalification of
bidders. Competitive bidding protects the public from
"collusive contracts; [prevents] favoritism, fraud,
extravagance, and improvidence . . ." and promotes "actual,
honest and effective competition . . . so that all such public
contracts may be secured at the lowest cost to taxpayers." 64
Am.Jur.2d, Public Works and Contracts, .537 (1972) at 889;
Williams v. City of Topeka, supra, 85 Kan. at 861.
Competitive bidding also affords fairness of opportunity to
participate in public contracts for businesses. 64 Am.Jur.2d
at 889. The legislature has clearly expressed these policies
in the aforementioned statutes.
However, as noted above, K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 19-101a, as
amended, requires counties to be subject to acts of the
legislature which are uniform in their application to all
counties. While the legislative intent behind the statutes
governing the letting of contracts for the construction of
bridges (K.S.A. 68-1113 and 68-1115) is as clear as it is for
the other two types of construction discussed herein, they are
contained in an act (L. 1975, ch. 427) which contains other
sections which are not uniformly applicable to all counties.
Section 73, for example, amends K.S.A. 68-151k, which by its
terms applies only to counties having a population of over
175,000. While K.S.A. 68-1113 and 68-1115 remain uniformly
applicable to all counties, under holdings of the Kansas
Supreme Court any non-uniformity renders the entire act,
including these two sections, subject to charter resolution.
City of Junction City v. Griffin, 227 Kan. 332, 337
(1981). As a result, Johnson County may, if it desires,
establish standards for prequalification of bidders for
bridge projects.
In conclusion, it is our opinion that where a county is
required to let contracts to the lowest and best, or to the
lowest responsible bidder, such bidding must be made available
to all who wish to offer bids. Prequalification of bidders
for the construction of public buildings and county roads
would be contrary to both the Kansas statutes and to public
policy. However, as the statutes providing for the bidding of
contracts for the construction of bridges are contained in an
act which is not uniform as to all of its sections, a county
may employ a charter ordinance to exempt itself from these
provisions and substitute language which allows pre-
qualification of bidders.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
Barbara P. Allen
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:BPA:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.