Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-137

1985-137Kanag

Full text

October 9, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85-137
The Honorable Jack H. Brier
Secretary of State
Capitol, 2nd Floor
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Notaries Public and Commissioners -- Notaries
Public -- Seal
Synopsis: K.S.A. 53-105 prescribes the requirements of a
notary seal in this state. Decisions of the Kansas
Supreme Court indicate that the fact that a notary
seal does not comply strictly with the statute will
not necessarily invalidate the document to which
the seal is affixed. Accordingly, the omission of
the required words "state of Kansas" in a notary
seal would not be construed to vitiate the effect
of the document to which the seal is affixed.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 53-105; 53-106; 53-118.
*
Dear Secretary Brier:
You have requested our opinion interpreting K.S.A. 53-105.
The statute in question provides:
"Every notary public shall provide a
notarial seal containing such notary's
name exactly as it appears on the
application for appointment as a notary
public, and the words 'notary public' and
'state of Kansas' and such seal shall
authenticate all official acts,
attestations and instruments therewith.
Every notary public shall add to such
notary's official signature the date of
expiration of appointment as a notary
public. The seal of every notary public
shall be either a seal press and the
impression thereof inked or blackened or a
rubber stand to be used with permanent ink
so that any such seal may be legibly
reproduced by photographic process. No
notary public shall use either such seal
unless an impression thereof has been
filed in the office of secretary of state."
You ask whether a notary seal which contains all of these
particulars except the words "state of Kansas" would impair
the effectiveness of the document to which it is attached. In
our opinion, Kansas case law indicates that such a defect in a
notary seal would not have such an effect.
We note that K.S.A. 53-106 establishes a penalty for a notary
public who shall "willfully neglect or refuse to attach to the
notary's official signature the date of expiration of
appointment, as provided in K.S.A. 53-105 . . . ." Such
offense is a class C misdemeanor. This penalty provision was
interpreted by the Kansas Supreme Court in Windmill Co. v.
Barker, 49 Kan. 434 (1892). There the court faced the
question of whether the omission of a notary public in failing
to attach to his signature the expiration date of his
appointment invalidated the affidavit to a lien (thereby
voiding the lien). The court construed the provisions of
K.S.A. 53-106 and concluded:
"The court below found as a fact that the
notary public before whom the affidavit
verifying the lien was made failed to
state after his official signature the
time when his commission would expire, and
upon such finding the court held, as a
matter of law, the lien was void. We do
not think such omission on the part of the
notary renders the lien void. The statute
requiring such addition on part of the
notary does not attempt to avoid the
affidavit taken by the notary on account
of such omission. It simply subjects the
notary to a penalty therefor. The omitted
matter constitutes no part of the
affidavit, not of the jurat thereto. It
is a statutory requirement to be observed
by the notary for the purpose of making
the instrument show that the notary taking
the affidavit is still in commission and
with power to do so." 49 Kan. at 440.
Similarly, in Matthewson v. Richards, 114 Kan. 500 (1923),
the validity of a deed was challenged on the grounds that the
name of the county was not stated in the caption of the
acknowledgment and that the deed was therefore defective. The
court rejected the argument that this omission was a
substantial defect. The court noted that to be sufficient a
certificate must follow substantially the requirements of the
statute, however, such certificates should be liberally
construed.
A general rule on this subject is noted in 66 C.J.S.
Notaries §8:
"The requisites of a notary's seal are
fixed and controlled by the law of the
locality from which he derives his
authority . . . . Statutory provisions
concerning the emblems, devices, and
legends to be borne by the seal have been
held to only directory, and want of
compliance therewith has been held not to
vitiate the seal or the certificate, but
other statutes have been held to require
compliance with their terms as a
prerequisite to the validity of the seal
or certificate."
It appears that the Kansas Supreme Court has taken the former
view, albeit some time ago, so that if the statutory
requirements regarding a notary seal are not strictly complied
with the validity of the document to which the seal is
attached will not be affected. We note as well that the
Kansas court in Windmill Co. v. Barker was construing a
provision which penalizes a notary for omitting one of the
statutory requirements. The legislature has not provided such
penalties for the omission of other requirements, such as the
words "state of Kansas." Although we would not attempt to
predict how the Kansas courts might rule on this question
today (much could depend on factual circumstances such as the
degree of non-compliance), it appears that under the current
law of the state non-substantial omissions of the
statutorily required portions of a notary seal will not
necessarily affect the validity of the document to which the
seal is attached.
This is not to say that the requirements of K.S.A. 53-105 may
be ignored without effect. We note that K.S.A. 53-118 gives
the secretary of state the discretionary authority to refuse
to appoint a person as a notary public or to revoke an
appointment on several grounds including the ". . . failure to
exercise the powers and duties of a notary public in
accordance with this act." This statute, coupled with the
requirement of K.S.A. 53-105 that an impression of each seal
be filed with the secretary of state, should make it possible
in most instances to insure compliance with the statutory
requirements.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mary F. Carson
Assistant Attorney General
MFC:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.