Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-132

1985-132Kanag

Full text

September 27, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 132
Jon C. Christlieb
Aubry Township Trustee
17595 Mission Road
Stilwell, Kansas 66058
Re: Roads and Bridges -- County and Township Roads --
County Road Unit System; Effect on Townships
Synopsis: The county road unit system is one of two
alternative systems in Kansas designed for the
construction and maintenance of roads within a
county. Upon adoption of the county road unit
system, all townships within the county must
relinquish to the board of county commissioners all
money and equipment accumulated by the townships
for use in constructing and maintaining roads; the
townships additionally relinquish their powers and
duties associated with the construction and
maintenance of roads within the township. The
board of county commissioners is thus charged with
the establishment, laying out and opening of all
roads which are deemed by the board to be
practicable, necessary for public use, and
economically feasible, as well as their
maintenance. Cited herein: K.S.A. 68-101; 68-104;
68-106; 68-515b; 68-516; 68-516a; 68-516b; K.S.A.
1984 Supp. 68-526.
Dear Mr. Christlieb:
As Township Trustee for Aubry Township, you request our
opinion with respect to the effect of the county road unit
system on townships within a county adopting such system.
Specifically, you inquire (1) who, as between the township and
the county, has authority to open roads within a township; (2)
whether the entity having authority to open roads is obligated
to do so; and (3) whether the fact that the roads in question
are section line roads would alter the answers to the first
two questions.
In your letter, you indicate that Johnson County, Kansas has
adopted the county road unit system. Aubry Township is
located in Johnson County. K.S.A. 68-515b through 68-518 set
forth the procedures for the adoption, application and
abandonment of the county road unit system. Upon adoption of
the system, all townships within the county are to relinquish
to the board of commissioners all money and equipment
accumulated by them for road construction and maintenance
purposes. K.S.A. 68-516a and 68-516b. Thereafter, townships
within counties adopting the county road unit system have no
further authority to construct or maintain any roads, even
those within the boundaries of the township. See also K.S.A.
1984 Supp. 68-526.
K.S.A. 68-516 [particularly when compared with K.S.A.
68-101(4) and (5)], indicates that counties under the county
road unit system have abolished the classification of
"township roads." As townships have authority to open only
township roads (K.S.A. 68-115), under the county road system,
it appears that townships have no authority to open roads. In
any event, even if a township could open a road simply by
declaring it to be open, the township would have no authority
to construct or maintain it, leaving the act of opening
futile. Thus, it is our opinion that a county operating under
the county road unit system has sole authority to open roads
in that county.
Your second question concerns whether a county having sole
authority to open roads is obligated to do so. In Moore v.
City of Lawrence, 232 Kan. 353, 363 (1982), the court
discussed this question as applied to a city charged with the
authority to open roads:
“ . . . When a road is to be opened, or
put in condition for use by the public,
is within the discretion of the city's
governing body. A city is not required to
open all streets which have been formally
laid out or dedicated.” (Emphasis added.)
K.S.A. 68-106 indicates that the same rule applies to counties
under the county road unit system:
. . . said commissioners shall, if they
conclude that said road should be
established, altered, or vacated, and no
legal objections appear against the same,
and they are satisfied that such road
will be of public utility, enter an order
upon their records that said road, survey
and plat be recorded in the office of the
county surveyor and from thence forth said
road shall be considered a public highway,
and the county surveyor shall issue his
order to the trustees of the respective
townships in which said road is located,
directing them to cause the same to be
opened for the public travel at the time
and in the manner indicated by him; but
if the commissioners conclude that such
road as applied for is unnecessary or
impracticable, then no further proceedings
shall be had thereon . . . ." K.S.A.
68-106 (Emphasis added.)
Accordingly, the county is not obligated to open every road,
but only those which, in the discretion of the board of county
commissioners, are practicable, necessary for public use, and
economical. This discretion is not absolute, however. It is
tempered by the statutes providing for petition by
householders in applying for the opening of roads. K.S.A.
68-102 et seg.
Your final concern is whether the conclusions reached on these
points apply to section line roads. It appears that the only
statutory distinction between section line roads and other
roads appears at K.S.A. 68-104. This section provides that a
survey of section line roads may be dispensed with,
apparently because section line roads have already been
established by government survey. There is no difference,
however, in the procedure for laying out, opening,
constructing and maintaining such roads under the county road
unit system.
In conclusion, counties operating under the county road unit
system have sole authority to open all roads within the
county, and have wide, although not unlimited, discretion in
determining which roads to open. Section line roads are no
different from any other roads for these purposes.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JuleneL.Miller
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:JLM:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.