Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-125

1985-125Kanag

Full text

September 18, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 125
Gregory J. McDonald
City Attorney
City Administrative Center
301 N. 8th, P.O. Box 499
Garden City, Kansas 67846
Re: Cities and Municipalities--Ordinances of Cities--
Validity of Ordinance Imposing Discriminatory
License Fee
Synopsis: An ordinance which imposes a license fee of $25
per day (with a maximum of $100 per year) upon
"itinerant solicitors," but which imposes no such
fee upon solicitation by resident photographers,
is void as applied to an employee of a Tennessee
corporation who solicits orders for taking and
processing photographs in interstate commerce.
Cited herein: U.S. Const., Art. I, §8.
Dear Mr. McDonald:
You request our opinion as to whether Ordinance No. 1530 of the
City of Garden City, which imposes a license fee of $25 per day
(with a maximum of $100 per year) upon "itinerant solicitors," is
valid as applied to solicitors employed by a nationwide portrait
photography company. A copy of Ordinance No. 1530 is attached
hereto as Exhibit "A."
The operations of the photography company have been summarized as
follows:
"The corporation's principal office and
manufacturing plant are located in
Chattanooga, Tennessee. At this plant,
photographic film is developed, proofs are
prepared, and the finished portraits are
manufactured and mailed to customers.
"As the first step in the Olan Mills' sales
plan, telephone solicitors, under the
supervision of a traveling Olan Mills'
supervisor, operating out of a motel, call
local residents of the town and make an
advertising offer. This offer constitutes the
Olan Mills' Club Plan which is sold for about
$12-$15 depending upon the area involved. The
Club Plan entitles the purchaser to have three
sittings within the next twelve months and
receive an 8x10 natural color portrait of each
sitting at no extra charge. When a resident
purchases a Club Plan, the telephone solicitor
also schedules their first sitting, usually
several weeks later.
"As the second step, a traveling photographer
takes the pictures at a local motel according
to a previously arranged sitting schedule and
ships the exposed film to Chattanooga to be
developed. From these negatives, proofs are
printed and mailed to our temporary location
in a particular area.
"As the third step, these proofs are mailed
from Tennessee to a traveling portrait
salesperson who has established a temporary
office in a motel. The customers have been
notified by mail that they may view their
proofs at a designated time and place. The
salesperson presents them to customers for them
to make a selection for their advertising
offer, and order additional portraits if
desired.
"After viewing proofs, orders for finished
portraits are solicited and portrait
selections are made. Orders for finished
portraits are sent to Tennessee, and the
finished portraits are manufactured and mailed
to the customers' homes."
While a state or municipality has police power to regulate
soliciting and similar activities [Breard v. Alexandria, 441
U.S. 622, 95 L.Ed. 1233 (1951)], such power is subject to
limitations imposed by the Commerce Clause (Article I, Section 8)
of the United States Constitution. Specifically, a state statute
or municipal regulation which places an undue burden on or
discriminates against interstate commerce violates the Commerce
Clause. See Nippert v. Richmond, 327 U.S. 416, 90 L.Ed. 760
(1946); Emert v. Missouri, 156 U.S. 296, 39 L.Ed. 430 (1895).
In this regard, an ordinance imposing a license fee upon
itinerant photographers was held discriminatory and void in Olan
Mills, Inc. of Ohio v. City of Barre, 194 A.2d 385 (Vt. 1963).
The court noted the following constitutional defects in the
ordinance:
"The ordinance also requires that the
plaintiff, as an itinerant photographer pay a
license fee of $10 for one week, $20 for a
period of more than one week and less than
four weeks, and $75 for a period of more than
four weeks. No license fee of any kind is
required from resident photographers of Barre,
nor are such photographers required to file a
performance bond.
'While interstate commerce may be required
to pay its way, it must be placed on a
plane of equality with local trade and
commerce." Warren Kay Vantine Studios,
Inc. v. City of Portsmouth et al., 95
N.H. 171, 59 A.2d 475.
"Such a plane of equality does not exist under
the Barre ordinance between the resident
photographer, who pays no license fees or
regulatory costs, and the itinerant
photographer, engaged in interstate commerce,
subject to the various fees and costs stated
above. The existing ordinance is both unfair
and discriminatory." 194 A.2d at 390.
The Garden City ordinance attached hereto is very similar in
effect to the ordinance struck down in the Olan Mills case, i.e. a
a license fee of $25 to $100 is imposed upn itinerant solicitors
for out-of-state photography companies, but no such fee is
imposed upon solicitation by resident photographers.
Accordingly, we are compelled to conclude that Ordinance No.
1530 is void as applied to an employee of an out-of-state company
who solicits orders for taking and processing photographs in
interstate commerce.
In passing, we would note that a non-discriminatory license tax
imposed against transient photographers was upheld in
Dunbar-Stanley Studios v. Alabama, 393 U.S. 537, 21 L.Ed.2d 759
(1969).
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:TRH:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.