Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-122

1985-122Kanag

Full text

September 17, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 122
Gary L. Flory, Esquire
McPherson County Counselor
Walnut at Marlin
P.O. Box 1103
McPherson, Kansas 67460
Re: Taxation -- Merchants and Manufacturers Inventories
-- Inventory of Merchant; Listing for Taxation
Synopsis: K.S.A. 79-1001a requires that each merchant submit
a statement to the county assessor showing the fair
market value of personal property which the
merchant holds as inventory. For the purpose of
establishing such a value, the merchant is to use
the average of the inventory held during the
preceding year, which figure is derived from the
federal income tax statement for that year. If the
assessor believes that the statement does not
accurately reflect the value of the inventory, he
or she may conduct an investigation pursuant to
K.S.A. 79-1461 et seq. Cited herein: K.S.A.
79-1001a; 79-1001b; 79-1004a; 79-1461.
Dear Mr. Flory:
You have requested our opinion on the statutory interpretation
of K.S.A. 79-1001a, which concerns the listing and valuation
of inventory for ad valorem tax purposes. K.S.A. 79-1001a
states as follows:
"Every merchant shall for the purpose of
taxation make and deliver to the assessor
a statement giving the fair market value
in money of personal property held as
inventory within the state of Kansas for
sale in his business as a merchant. For
the purpose of such statement the fair
market value in money of personal property
held by a merchant as inventory shall be
an amount equal to the average of the fair
market value in money of the personal
property held as inventory within the
state of Kansas for sale by such merchant
during his tax year (as established for
reporting for federal income tax
purposes) next preceding the time of
filing the statement of personal
property." (Emphasis added.)
Specifically, you ask whether the language in parenthesis "(as
established for reporting for federal income tax purposes)"
refers to the merchant's tax year, which is to be used
as a tax year for averaging purposes, or to the amount of
inventory shown on the taxpayer's federal income tax return,
which shall be used on the tax statement. Further, you ask
whether the county assessor may challenge the rendition if he
or she believes the taxpayer under-reported inventory on the
federal income tax return used to make the statement.
In our opinion, the second construction you suggest is
correct, namely that the parenthetical material within K.S.A.
79-1001a refers to the quantity of material which is held as
inventory and so reported to the Internal Revenue Service. We
believe the first suggested interpretation of the
parenthetical material in K.S.A. 79-1001a (i.e. that it is
the tax year, rather than the quantity of merchandise, which
is established by the federal return) is inconsistent with
other language of the act in which K.S.A. 79-1001a appears.
In particular, K.S.A. 79-100lb (which, as a part of the same
act as 79-1001a, is in pari materia) sets forth the
procedure for determining average fair market value. At
subsection (a), the first step is described as:
"Add the fair market value of personal
property held as beginning inventory by
such merchant on the first day of such tax
year, as reported for federal income tax
purposes for such year, to the fair
market value of personal property not
reflected in such beginning inventory
which is consigned to and held for sale by
such merchant on such date." (Emphasis
added.)
The underscored language makes it clear that it is the
inventory value, rather than the reporting period, which is
derived from the federal income tax return. See also K.S.A.
79-1004a, which requires each statement filed under K.S.A.
79-1001a to be accompanied by that portion of the federal tax
return which sets forth the inventory of personal property (or
by a sworn statement containing such information).
In response to your second inquiry, a county appraiser may,
pursuant to K.S.A. 79-1461, challenge the rendition if he is
"of the opinion that any form filed is not adequate or does
not truly represent the property to be appraised." K.S.A.
79-1462 et efa. sets forth the procedures to be followed
in making such a determination.
In conclusion, K.S.A. 79-1001a requires that each merchant
submit a statement to the county assessor showing the fair
market value of personal property which the merchant holds as
inventory. For the purpose of establishing such a value, the
merchant is to use the average of the inventory held during
the preceding year, which figure is derived from the federal
income tax statement for that year. If the assessor believes
that the statement does not accurately reflect the value of
the inventory, he or she may conduct an investigation pursuant
to K.S.A. 79-1461 et seq.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
JeffreyS.Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.