Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-097

1985-097Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
August 7, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 97
Kenneth M. Wilke
Chief Counsel
Board of Agriculture
109 S.W. 9th Street
Topeka, Kansas 66612-1208
Re: Agriculture -- Sale and Distribution of
Agricultural Seeds -- Unlawful Acts; Sale of
Agricultural Seed on Grower's Premises
Synopsis: K.S.A. 2-1421(c), as amended by L. 1985, ch. 10,
§4, permits a grower of agricultural seed to sell
on his or her own premises seed which the grower
has produced and which is free of noxious weed
seed, without first having the seed tested and
labeled as provided by K.S.A. 2-1416, as amended by
the same act. The term "sell" as used in
subsection (c) includes advertising and exposing
for sale of the seed. Such activities, along with
the actual sale of agricultural seed, are not
permitted by anyone who is not a grower unless the
seed has been tested and labeled pursuant to K.S.A.
2-1415 et seq. cited herein: K.S.A. 2-1415,
2-1416, 2-1417, 2-1421, all as amended by L. 1985,
ch. 10; 50-624.
*
Dear Mr. Wilke:
As Chief Counsel for the Kansas State Board of Agriculture,
you request our opinion on a question concerning the scope of
K.S.A. 2-1421, as that statute has been amended by Laws of
1985, chapter 10, section 4. Specifically, you inquire
whether a grower of agricultural seed may advertise the same
for sale, when the seed is being offered on his or her
premises, has been produced by the grower and is free of
noxious weed seed.
Chapter 10 of the Session Laws of 1985 relates to the sale of
agricultural seed, and amends K.S.A. 2-1415,-2-1416, 2-1417
and 2-1421. As amended by section 2 of the act, K.S.A. 2-1416
provides that "except as provided in subsection (c) of K.S.A.
2-1421, and amendments thereto, it shall be unlawful for any
person to offer or expose for sale, sell or exchange any
agricultural seed for planting or seeding purposes that has
not been tested or labeled." K.S.A. 2-1421(c), as amended, in
turn provides that:
"it shall not be a violation of this act
for the grower of agricultural seed to
sell on the grower's premises for planting
or seeding purposes, agricultural seed
which is not tested and labeled when the
seed is produced by the grower and is free
from noxious weed seed."
This subsection acts as an exception to the general rule
stated in subsection (a) of the same statute, wherein it is
made unlawful for any person to "sell, offer for sale or
expose for sale any agricultural seed for seeding purposes"
unless it has first been properly tested and labeled.
As set forth in your letter, the Board of Agriculture believes
that the exemption from testing and labeling provided in
K.S.A. 2-1421(c), as amended, applies only to the sale of
seed. The following statement of statutory construction from
the case of Lakeside Village Improvement District v.
Jefferson County, 237 Kan. 106-(1985) is offered in support
of this conclusion:
"It is a fundamental rule of statutory
construction, to which all others are
subordinate, that the purpose or intent of
the legislature governs when the intent
can be ascertained from the statute, even
though words, phrases or clauses at some
place in the statute must be omitted or
inserted." Syl. §3.
In that the legislature used only the word "sell" in the
exception to the general requirements of testing and labeling,
the board feels that the additional activities listed above,
which involve essentially the advertising of seed prior to
sale, should still be prohibited.
However, we do not believe that the issue is so clear cut as
to allow only the application of the above rule of
construction. The word "sell" is capable of-being interpreted
as including activities prior to the actual transfer of
consideration for the item being offered, as has been
previously recognized by Kansas courts. Brown v. Gilpin,
75 Kan. 773, 783 (1907); Orr v. Rieger, 133 Kan. 558
(1931). Additionally, the fact that the legislature added the
activities of offering or exposing seed for sale in the
general prohibition of K.S.A. 2-1421(a), as amended, merely
indicates that the legislature wished to make criminal even
those actions which did not involve an actual sale. See,
e.g., K.S.A. 50-624(c), which defines "consumer transaction"
to include both sales and solicitations for sales. Since
K.S.A. 2-1421(c) can be interpreted more than one way on its
face, we may employ other extrinsic aids in determining the
scope of the language therein [Hunter v. Haun, 210 Kan. 11
(19721), one of which is the legislative history of the bill.
As noted above, the statute was extensively amended by the
1985 Legislature. During the course of the session, the act
amending K.S.A. 2-1421 was considered by the Agriculture and
Small Business Committee of the House of Representatives. At
hearings on the bill, two separate amendments were proposed to
subsection (c) by the Kansas Seed Dealers Association. One
had the effect of specifically prohibiting both the
advertising and exposing of the seed for sale in any manner,
while the second allowed only the erection of a sign
advertising the seed upon the premises of the grower. Both
were presented to the committee, and both were not included in
the bill as passed. In considering this historical background
in determining the intent of the legislature, we do not
believe that an interpretation should be placed in the statute
which was not formally adopted by the legislature when it had
an opportunity to do so. In short, when given not one but two
different ways in which to specifically prohibit advertising
of seed by growers, the legislature declined to do so. We
accordingly conclude that K.S.A. 2-1421, as amended, permits
the advertising and exposing for sale by growers of seed which
meets the requirements set forth therein.
In conclusion, K.S.A. 2-1421(c), as amended by L. 1985, ch.
10, §4, permits a grower of agricultural seed to sell on his
or her own premises seed which the grower has produced and
which is free of noxious weed seed, without first having the
which is free of noxious weed seed, without first having the
seed tested and labeled as provided by K.S.A. 2-1416, as
amended by the same act. The term "sell" as used in
subsection (c) includes advertising and exposing for sale of
the seed. Such activities, along with the actual sale of
agricultural seed, are not permitted by anyone who is not a
grower unless the seed has been tested and labeled pursuant to
K.S.A. 2-1415 et seq.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
JeffreyS.Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.