Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-019

1985-019Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
Feruary 18, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 19
James B. McKay, Jr.
City Attorney
P.O. Box 49
El Dorado, Kansas 67042
Re: Cities of the Second Class--The Board of Commissioners--
Mayor or Commissioners Holding Other Office
Elections--City Elections--Candidate for Office
Elected at Large; Filing of Petition or Statement
of Candidacy
Synopsis: K.S.A. 14-1302 provides, in part, that no member of
the board of commissioners of a second class city
may hold any other city office. That prohibition
does not, however, preclude a city commissioner from
becoming a candidate for the office of mayor.
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 25-2110 provides, in part, that
any person desiring to become a candidate for a
city office elected at large must file a statement
of candidacy with the city clerk before the filing
deadline. The requirement that the statement be
filed with the city clerk is mandatory, and a person
who files a statement of candidacy (for a city office)
with the county election officer may not have his
or her name placed on the ballot. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 14-1302, 25-308, K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 25-2110.
Dear Mr. McKay:
You request our opinion concerning two questions arising from
the efforts of a person holding the office of El Dorado Cit-
Commissioner tad become a candidate for the office of Mayor.
First, you ask whether the commissioner, whose term of office
will expire in 2 years, may become a candidate for mayor and
retain his position as a commissioner. Second, you ask if
the county clerk may place the commissioner's name on the
ballot notwithstanding deficiencies (set forth below) in
filing his statement of candidacy.
In regard to your first question, K.S.A. 14-1302 provides,
in part, that no member of the board of commissioners of a
second class city shall hold any other city office. However,
an authority, on the law of municipal corporations indicates
that such a prohibition does not extend to seeking nomination
to more than one office:
"The statutory or constitutional provision
prohibiting one person from filling two
offices at one time does not preclude a
candidate from seeking or accepting nom-
ination for more than one office, in the
absence of prohibition thereof . . . It
has also been held that the prohibitory
laws that one person shall not hold two
offices at the same time relate not to
the situation on election day but on the
day he qualifies to perform the duties of
the office. Accordingly, an officer may
be elected to another office and resign
the first and then qualify for the second
office." 3 McQuillin, Municipal Corporations
(3rd Ed.) §12.66.
In accordance with the above-quoted authority, it is our opinion
that the prohibition against holding another city office set
forth in K.S.A. 14-1302 does not preclude a city commissioner
from becoming a candidate for the office of mayor.
In regard to your second question, you advise that the commis-
sioner filed his statement of candidacy for the office of mayor
with the county clerk, instead of the city clerk as required by
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 25-2110. You indicate that the county clerk
"accepted such filing and the filing fee by mistake and is now
using the procedure provided under K.S.A. 25-308 for placing
the name of such candidate on the ballot," and ask whether the
county clerk may place the commissioner's name on the ballot under
these circumstances.
Subsection (a) of K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 25-2110 provides in part
as follows:
"In cities of the first and second class,
any person desiring to become a candidate
fora city office elected at large shall
file with the city clerk before the filing
deadline a statement of such candidacy on a
form furnished by the county election officer
as specified by the secretary of state. The
city clerk of any city upon receiving any
filing under this section shall record the
same and transmit it, together with the
filing fee or petition herein provided,
within three business days to the county
election officer." (Emphasis added.)
The Kansas Supreme Court has held that filing deadlines, such as
that prescribed by the above-quoted statute, are mandatory, and
that a declaration or statement of candidacy filed after the
deadline is a nullity. See Bird v. Beggs, 116 Kan. 619 (1924);
State ex rel. v. Lutz, 116 Kan. 621 (1924); Parsons v. Ryan,
144 Kan. 370 (1936). Although the court has not considered
the validity of a statement of candidacy filed in the wrong
office, several Kansas Attorney General Opinions have indicated
that a candidate for city office must file with the city clerk
rather than the county election officer, and that such a
candidate "does not enjoy the option of filing his statement
[of candidacy] with any public officer other than that prescribed
by statute." See Kansas Attorney General Opinion Nos. 73-74
and 79-29; Letter Opinion dated January 28, 1969, published
at VI Opinions of the Attorney General 341. Additionally, it
is generally held that "statutory provisions requiring a
petition, certificate or application of nomination to be filed
with a specified officer within a stipulated period of time
are mandatory." See 25 Am.Jur.2d, Elections 5140. Therefore,
in our judgment the requirement that a candidate must file a
statement of candidacy with the city clerk is mandatory, and
a person who files such a statement with the county election
officer may not have his or her name placed on the ballot.
Although what has been said above is dispositive of your second
question, it should be noted that K.S.A. 25-308 does not authorize
the county clerk to place a candidate's name on the ballot where
a statement of candidacy is not filed with the prescribed officer
before the filing deadline. That statute only validates a
declaration of intent filed "in apparent conformity with law,"
and, as noted above, filing in the wrong office does not so
conform.
1 Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:TRH:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.