Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-013

1985-013Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
January 31, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 13
The Honorable Joseph C. Harder
State Senator, 25th District
State Capitol, Room 143-N
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Intoxicating Liquors and Beverages -- Licensing and
Related Provisions -- Farm Winery; Serving of Samples
in Tasting Room
Constitution of the State of Kansas -- Miscellaneous --
Intoxicating Liquors; Prohibition on Open Saloon
Synopsis: A farm winery licensed under K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 41-308a
may manufacture, store and sell domestic table wines.
While a provision which would have allowed a farm
winery to provide free samples of its products was
included in a 1983 bill (Substitute for House Bill No.
2551), such a provision was deleted before the measure
became law. L. 1983, ch. 161, §3. In view of Article
15, Section 10 of the Kansas Constitution and cases
which have interpreted its prohibition against the
operation of an "open saloon" in this state, samples
of wine could not be distributed, even on a compli-
mentary basis, to persons who were not "guests" of
the owner. As used in the intoxicating liquor laws,
the term "guest" is defined to exclude those individuals
who are not personally known to the owner. Therefore,
only a private party organized by the owner of the
winery to which guests are invited would be in com-
pliance with the constitution and with provisions of
Kansas liquor laws dealing with consumption of liquor
in public and private places. Cited herein: K.S.A.
1984 Supp. 41-102; 41-308a; K.S.A. 41-719; 41-803;
41-2602; 41-2604; K.A.R. 1983 Supp. 14-18-4; L. 1983,
ch. 161; Kan. Const., Art. 15, §10.
Dear Senator Harder:
As Senator for the 25th District, which consists of all or a
portion of McPherson, Harvey and Marion Counties, you request our
opinion on a question concerning farm wineries. Specifically,
you inquire whether a farm winery may have a tasting room on
the premises, where samples of the available products could be
tasted by customers prior to an actual sale. This is a common
practice in wineries located in other parts of the country,
most notably in California. In the event that we conclude such
a facility is prohibited, you ask if the prohibition is statutory
or constitutional in nature.
Farm wineries were recognized by the Kansas legislature only very
recently. In 1983, the legislature enacted Substitute for House
Bill No. 2551 (L. 1983, ch. 161) which contained provisions pro-
viding for the licensing, operating and taxing of farm wineries.
Prior to its passage, the bill contained [at §3(a)] certain
language which allowed a licensed farm winery to serve "com-
plimentary" samples of its products to prospective customers.
Presumably, the customers would be able to make a more intelligent
decision as to the type and quantity of wine they purchased if
they could sample various types before doing so. For whatever
reason, the provision for complimentary samples was deleted from
the bill prior to its enactment into law.
Following the repeal of prohibition at the state level in 1948
through the amendment of Article 15, Section 10 of the Kansas
Constitution, liquor consumption has been regulated by the
Liquor Control Act, K.S.A. 41-101 et seq., and, since 1964, by
the Private Club Act, K.S.A. 41-2601 et seq. Both of these acts
give practical effect to Article 15, Section 10, which states:
"The legislature may provide for the pro-
hibition of intoxicating liquors in certain
areas. Subject to the foregoing, the legis-
lature may regulate, license and tax the man-
ufacture and sale of intoxicating liquors,
and may regulate the possession and trans-
portation of intoxicating liquors. The open
saloon is hereby forever prohibited."
(Emphasis added.)
The term "open saloon" has been defined by both the legislature
[K.S.A. 41-803(b)] and the courts [State ex rel. v. Kennedy, 225
Kan. 13, 24 (1979)] to mean any establishment open to the
public, without discrimination, where alcoholic beverages are
dispensed or sold or served for consumption on the premises.
While the general prohibition against open saloons underlies
Kansas liquor laws, practical guidelines permitting the regulated
consumption of liquor are contained in the statutes. Consumption
of liquor in public places is regulated by K.S.A. 41-719, which
is part of the original Liquor Control Act of 1949. It states
as follows:
"(a) Except as provided in subsection (b), no
person shall drink or consume alcoholic liquor
upon the public streets, alleys, roads or high-
ways; in beer parlors, taverns, pool halls or
places to which the general public has access,
whether or not an admission or other fee is
charged or collected; upon property owned by
the state or any governmental subdivision thereof;
or inside vehicles while upon the public streets,
alleys, roads or highways.
"(b) The provisions of subsection (a) shall not
apply to the drinking or consumption of alcoholic
liquor:
"(1) Upon real property leased by a city to
others under the provisions of K.S.A. 12-1740
to 12-1749, inclusive, and amendments thereto,
if such real property is actually being used for
hotel or motel purposes or purposes incidental
thereto.
"(2) In any state owned or operated building or
structure and upon the surrounding premises which
are furnished to and occupied by any state officer
or employee as a residence.
"(3) In a club which is licensed by the director
and which is located upon property owned or
operated by an airport authority created pursuant
to chapter 27 of the Kansas Statutes Annotated.
"(4) In a club which is licensed by the director
and which is located upon property owned or
operated by an airport authority established by
a city having a population of more than 200,000.
"(5) Upon property exempted from the provisions
of subsection (a) pursuant to subsection (c) or
(d).
"(c) Any city having a population of more than
200,000 may exempt, by ordinance, specified property,
title of which is vested in such city, from the
provisions of subsection (a).
"(d) The board of county commissioners of any county
having a population of not less than 150,000 may
exempt, by resolution, specified property, the
title of which is vested in such county, from the
provisions of subsection (a).
"(e) Violation of any provision of subsection (a)
is a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of not less
than $50 or more than $200 or by imprisonment for
not more than six months, or both."
As noted by at least two prior opinions of this office (Attorney
General Opinions No. 82-116 and 84-51), the above provisions
must be read in pari materia with statutes contained in the
Private Club Act, K.S.A. 41-2601 et seq. Unlike K.S.A. 41-719,
which speaks only to the prohibition of the consumption of liquor
in public places, the latter statutes provide a comprehensive
system of regulation for consumption anywhere, in public or in
private. K.S.A. 41-2604 prohibits all consumption of liquor
which is not in conformity with the parameters laid down by K.S.A.
41-2602, which states:
"The consumption of alcoholic liquor by any
person shall be authorized in this state:
"(a) Upon private property by those occupying
such private property as an owner or as the
lessee of an owner and by the guests of said
owner or lessee provided that no charge is
made by the owner of lessee for the serving or
mixing of any drink or drinks of alcoholic
liquor or for any substance comixed with any
alcoholic liquor; and if no sale of alcoholic
liquor in violation of K.S.A. 41-803 takes
place on said private property;
"(b) at a club licensed by the director under
the provisions of the act;
"(c) in a lodging room of any hotel, motel or
boarding house by the occupant of said lodging
room or his guests provided the occupant is
not engaged in a sale of liquor in violation
of K.S.A. 41-403; and if the occupant makes
no charge for (1) serving or mixing any drink
or drinks of alcoholic liquor, and (2) for
any substance comixed with any alcoholic liquor;
"(d) in a private dining room of a hotel,
motel or restaurant when said dining room is
rented or made available on a special occasion
to an individual or organization for a private
party and if no sale of alcoholic liquor in
violation of K.S.A. 41-803 takes place at said
private party." (Emphasis added.)
It should be noted that the above statute makes three references
to K.S.A. 41-803 ("no sale of alcoholic liquor in violation of
K.S.A. 41-803 takes place"), which statute contains the definition
of open saloon discussed earlier in this opinion.
Accordingly, given the above statutes and constitutional pro-
vision, what may be concluded about a proposal to distribute
free samples of wine produced at a farm winery? In that any
such winery would presumably be privately owned, the prohibitions
of K.S.A. 41-719 relating to public consumption would not be
invoked. However, K.S.A. 41-2602 also regulates private con-
sumption, and so would be applicable. Subsection (a) of the
statute permits consumption on private premises by the owner(s)
thereof, as well as the "guests" of the owner. Although the
statutes do not provide a definition for the term "guest, K.A.R.
14-18-4, an administrative rule and regulation of the Alcohol
Beverage Control Division of the Department of Revenue, states:
"(a) Members of licensed private clubs may bring
guests upon club premises provided the guests
are accompanied by the member. The relationship
between member and guests necessarily requires
that the member shall be acquainted with
the guest and not be a total stranger before
the time that the privilege of access is ex-
tended.
"(b) Every club shall require the name and ad-
dress of all persons who enter the club premises
as guests of management or club employees.
These guests shall be registered in a perman-
ently bound book kept on the club premises for
that purpose. The relationship between management
or employees and their guests necessarily re-
quires that the management or employee shall
have been acquainted with the guest for some
period of time before the privilege being ex-
tended, which would exclude a total stranger."
(Emphasis added.)
This concept of the term "guest" is necessary in view of the
definition given to the phrase "open saloon" as being a place
where liquor is served to members of the general public at large.
Hence the need to have some type of connection between "guest" and
the "member," or, in the case of liquor being served on private
premises, between the "guest" and the "owner."
Clearly, any proposal to distribute samples of wine [an alcoholic
liquor as defined by K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 41-102(2)] to anyone
visiting a farm winery would encounter problems both with the
Private Club Law and the constitutional prohibition against the
operation of open saloons in Kansas. While licensure under
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 41-308a would allow the sale of wine for
consumption elsewhere, consumption on the premises, even in the
form of complimentary samples is controlled by K.S.A. 41-2602
and 41-2604. In that a farm winery could not qualify as a
licensed club [K.S.A. 41-2602(b)], a lodging room of a hotel,
motel or boarding house [K.S.A. 41-2602(c)], or a private dining
room of a hotel, motel or restaurant [K.S.A. 41-2602(d)], it
would have to qualify, if at all, under K.S.A. 41-2602(a) (con-
sumption on private property by an owner and his guests). Given
the problem with the definition of "guest" discussed above,
however, in our opinion even this option is not available.
Further, even if K.S.A. 41-2601 et seq., were amended to include
farm wineries (i.e. to make them private clubs), they could still
not invite members of the general public to drink free samples
of wine in a tasting room. While private parties of individually
invited guests would be permissible, a "come one, come all" policy
is irreconcialably at odds with the language of Article 15, Section
10 of the state constitution. So, while the concept of a wine
tasting room faces difficulties under existing statutes, the
amendment of such statutes would not remove the underlying
obstacle presented by the ban on open saloons.
In conclusion, a farm winery licensed under K.S.A. 1984 Supp.
41-308a may manufacture, store and sell domestic table wines.
While a provision which would have allowed a farm winery to
provide free samples of its products was included in a 1983
bill (Substitute for House Bill No. 2551), such a provision was
deleted before the measure became law. L. 1983, ch. 161, §3.
In view of Article 15, Section 10 of the Kansas Constitution and
cases which have interpreted its prohibition against the oper-
ation of an "open saloon" in this state, samples of wine could
not be distributed, even on a complimentary basis, to persons
who were not "guests" of the owner. As used in the intoxicating
liquor laws, the term "guest" is defined to exclude those indi-
viduals who are not personally known to the owner. Therefore,
only a private party organized by the owner of the winery to
which guests are invited would be in compliance with the con-
stitution and with provisions of Kansas liquor laws dealing
with consumption of liquor in public and private places.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Jeffrey S. Southard
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JSS:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.