Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1985-006

1985-006Kanag

Full text

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
January 16, 1985
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 85- 6
Honorable Rex Crowell, Chairman
Special Committee on Transportation and
Utilities
R.F.D.
Longton, Kansas 67352
Re: Taxation--Retailers' Sales Tax--Transfers from
General Fund to Highway Fund
Kansas Constitution--Legislature--Delegation
of Legislative Authority
Synopsis: A law which does not attempt to confer legislative
power upon some person or group cannot be found to
involve an unlawful delegation of legislative authority.
The provisions of 1985 House Bill No. 2023, concerning
the transfer of a portion of the sales tax receipts
of the state from the general fund to the highway
fund, do not attempt to delegate legislative power.
Thus, those provisions do not involve an unlawful
delegation of legislative authority. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 79-34,147, 79-34,148, Kan. Const., Art. 2,
§1, 1985 House Bill No. 2023.
Dear Representative Crowell:
As chairman of the Special Committee on Transportation and
Utilities, you seek our opinion on whether certain amendments
proposed by the special committee which relate to the transfer
of sales tax moneys from the state general fund to the state
highway fund involve an unlawful delegation of legislative
authority to the secretary of revenue. The amendments are
proposed in 1985 House Bill No. 2023.
Your concern arises from the fact that, under current law,
the amount of sales tax revenue that is transferred from the
state general fund to the state highway fund is set at a fixed
percentage rate by K.S.A. 79-34,147. The statute, in relevant
part, provides:
"(a) The secretary of revenue shall certify
daily to the director of accounts and reports
the amount equal to 9.19% of the total revenue
received by the secretary . . . under the
Kansas retailers' sales tax act . . . on the
preceding day. . . .
(b) Upon receipt of such certification under
subsection (a), the director of accounts and
reports shall transfer from the state general
fund to the state highway fund the amount
computed as follows:
• • •
(2) during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1985,
the amount equal to 10/42 of the amount so
certified. . . . (Emphasis added:)
As the 9.19% rate is fixed by statute, this rate will not vary
from year to year, but can be changed only by an amendment to
the statute. In order to determine whether that percentage
rate should be changed, the legislature, when it enacted K.S.A.
79-34,147 also enacted K.S.A. 79-34,148, which provides:
"On or before each December 1, the secretary
of revenue shall determine the percentage
of the total estimated revenues to be re-
ceived under the Kansas retailers' sales
tax act and credited to the state general
fund during the fiscal year commencing on
the ensuing July 1 which represents that
portion of such estimated revenues which
are attributable to the retail sale of new
and used motor vehicles intended for use
on the highways of this state. Upon making
such determination, the secretary of revenue
shall certify such percentage to the director
of the budget and to the director of the
legislative research department.''
It is clear that when the provisions of K.S.A. 79-34,147 and
79-34,148 were originally enacted in 1983 (L. 1983, ch. 320,
§§22, 23), the percentage determined by the secretary under
K.S.A. 79-34,148 would be used for informational and planning
purposes. Now, however, the special committee proposes legis-
lation which would use this percentage rate as the rate of sales
tax revenue that is to be certified to the director of accounts
and reports under subsection (a) of K.S.A. 79-34,147. Specifically,
the special committee has recommended that K.S.A. 79-34,148 be
amended to include the language underscored below and to read:
"On or before December 1, the secretary
of revenue shall determine the percentage
of the total estimated revenues to be
received under the Kansas retailers' sales
tax act and credited to the state general
fund during the fiscal year commencing on
the ensuing July 1 which represents that
portion of such estimated revenues which
are attributable to the retail sale of new
and used motor vehicles intended for use
on the highways of this state, but such
percentage shall never be determined to
be more than .5% above nor less than .5%
below the percentage determined under this
section the immediately preceding year.
Upon making such determination, the sec-
retary of revenue shall certify such percent-
age to the director of the budget and to the
director of the legislative research depart-
ment."
Further, the special committee proposes to amend subsection (a)
of K.S.A. 79-34,147 by making the following changes:
"(a) The secretary of revenue shall certify
daily to the director of accounts and reports
the ameumt-equal-to-97-19 54 percentage most
recently determined under K.S.A. 79-34,148
and amendments thereto of the total revenues
received by the secretary from the taxes
imposed under the Kansas retailers' sales
tax act and deposited in the state treasury
and credited to the state general fund on
the next preceding day that such revenues
were so received and deposited."
Thus, the committee proposes to eliminate the fixed percentage
rate now prescribed by statute and replace it with the percentage
rate that is determined annually by the secretary of revenue.
It has been questioned, however, whether this proposal involves
an unlawful delegation of legislative power to the secretary
of revenue, since the secretary's estimated percentage under
K.S.A. 79-34,148 would be used as the basis for transfers of
monies under K.S.A. 79-34,147.
Article 2, Section 1 of the Kansas Constitution provides:
"The legislative power of this state shall be vested in a house
of representatives and senate." Thus, under our constitution,
it is the legislature that possesses the authority to legislate --
to make the law -- and such authority cannot be delegated to some
other tribunal or person. See State v. Dumler, 221 Kan. 386,
391 (1977); State ex rel. v. Fadely, 180 Kan. 652 (1957); and
Coleman v. Newby, 7 Kan. *82 (1871). In order to violate this
constitutional principle, a law must attempt to confer legislative
power, i.e. the power to make law, on a person or group. If such
is not done, the statute clearly does not involve an unlawful
delegation of legislative power, since there is no delegation of
legislative power at all.
We state this obvious fact because, under the bill proposed by the
special committee, we fail to perceive any attempt to confer
legislative power upon the secretary of revenue. It appears to
us that the law simply would require the secretary to perform
two administrative duties. Specifically, under K.S.A. 79-34,148,
the secretary would determine a percentage, within a range established
by the legislature. Then, under K.S.A. 79-34,147, the secretary
would certify an amount to the director of accounts and reports.
Neither of these actions involves the exercise of legislative
power. Thus, we do not believe the provisions of this proposed
legislation involve an unlawful delegation of legislative authority.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Rodney J. Bieker
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:RJB:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.