Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1984-048

1984-048Kanag

Full text

June 5, 1984
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 84- 48
David Belling
Miami County Attorney
P.O. Box 245
Paola, Kansas 66071
Re: Personal and Real Property -- Conveyances of Land --
Recordation of Instruments Affecting Real Estate
Synopsis: A register of deeds is required to file of record
a written instrument whereby real estate may be
affected. Such filing can properly be refused
only if the instrument contains apparent errors,
or is not proved or acknowledged and certified in
the manner prescribed by law, or the register of
deeds has been directed by a court not to file the
instrument. A register of deeds also may refuse to
file instruments that clearly do not affect real
estate, or where the law requires some act, such as
payment of the mortgage registration fee, before the
instrument may be received and filed of record. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 5872211, 58-2221; Affirming Attorney
General Opinion go'. 82-164.
Dear Mr. Belling:
As Miami County Attorney and on behalf of the Miami County Regis-
ter of Deeds you seek an opinion as to the appropriate response
to a document presented to the Register of Deeds for filing which
is entitled "Land Patent." You indicate that you and the Regis-
ter of Deeds are uncertain as to whether such a document should
be filed as requested.
You have enclosed a copy of the instrument in question. It
is captioned "Land Patent (The Title Deed By The Government)",
and describes a parcel of property in Miami County. Attached
to the document is a copy of an official United States Govern-
ment land patent which apparently describes the same property
(the copy is illegible). A land patent is simply the instrument
by which the United States government passes its title to por-
tions of the public domain. See St. Louis Smelting Co., v.
Kemp, 104 U.S. 636, 26 L.Ed. 875 (1882). The document attached
to the land patent purports to grant "allodium title" (apparently
derived from the government patent) to the persons who executed
the document, who are described therein as "common law agents."
The word "allodium" as defined by Webster's Third International
Dictionary refers to a form of estate found in Anglo-Saxon
England during the 11th Century in which absolute possession
and control of the estate were vested in the owner as opposed
to an estate burdened with feudal duties. Thus, "allodium" re-
fers simply to land which is the absolute property of the owner
and not subject to "rent, service or acknowledgement to a
superior." See also Black's Law Dictionary, Fourth Ed. (1957).
The word "allodial" refers to free ownership as opposed to
feudal ownership and has little significance in modern United
States property law. Feudal tenures do not and cannot exist in
U.S. jurisdictions, thus all property in the U.S. is held al-
lodially, that is, not subject to feudal duties or obligations.
See 28 Am.Jur.2d Estates, §4.
Thus, it is not clear what purpose these documents can have,
particularly with reference to property which is owned by the
persons who execute the document. The apparent purpose is to
provide some ill-defined protection to the property, in that
the document declares that property with title derived from
the government land patent is "impervious to collateral attach
(sic) by the City, County, State, or Federal Governments."
While the legal effect of such documents is questionable at best,
the Register of Deeds should knot be placed in the position of
deciding that issue. We have enclosed a copy of Attorney General
1 See the recent decision by the United States Supreme Court
in Hawaii Housing Authority v. Midkiff, Case No. 83-141, in
which the Hawaii Legislature dealt with some of the after-
effects of a feudal landholding system, in which much of the
land in Hawaii was owned by only a few people. However, as
this case contained facts based on Polynesian property law,
it does not affect the law of this jurisdiction with regard
to Anglo-Saxon feudal concepts.
Opinion No. 82-164 which provides some guidance to a Register of
Deeds faced with a similarly questionable document titled "common
law lien." That opinion concluded that a register of deeds is
required to file of record a written instrument whereby real
estate may be affected. A register of deeds may properly refuse
a filing only if an instrument contains apparent errors, or is
not proved or acknowledged and certified in the manner prescribed
by law, or the register of deeds has been directed by a court
not to file the instrument. In the case of "common law liens"
the opinion noted that while such instruments may well be
spurious and legally unfounded, "we are constrained to conclude
that the Register of Deeds should not be placed in the position
of having to determine which instrument should be recorded and
which should not, absent judicial instruction." This conclusion
is based on the language of K.S.A. 58-2221 which provides in part:
"Provided, It shall be the duty of the regis-
ter of deeds to file the same for record im-
mediately, and in those counties where a numer-
ical index is maintained in his or her office
the register of deeds shall compare such in-
strument, before copying the same in the record,
with the last record of transfer in his or her
office of the property and if the register of
deeds finds such instrument contains apparent
errors, he or she shall not record the same
until he or she shall have notified the grantee
where such notice is reasonably possible."
Thus, except in the case of "apparent errors" or a court order
to the contrary, a register of deeds is obligated to file or
record every written instrument whereby real estate may be af-
fected if the instrument is proved and acknowledged and certified
in the manner prescribed by law. See K.S.A. 58-2211 et seq.
The instrument you have referred to us is clearly a "written in-
strument" affecting real estate. In the cases where the property
affected by the "land patent" is already owned by the person or
persons who execute the document it should be filed. While it
is likely that the instrument has no legal effect, it does pur-
port to affect real estate and should be filed under the terms
of K.S.A. 58-2221. In such a case the claim of "allodium title"
by the owners of the property is merely redundant.
A far more difficult question is presented if such an instrument
should be presented for filing by one person on property owned by
another. In such a case the only apparent purpose of seeking
to file such a document is to harass the legitimate owners of
the property. It may be argued that an instrument which purports
to grant "allodium title" to one person when the records in
the register of deeds office clearly show that the property be-
longs to another contains "aparent errors." Unfortunately,
K.S.A. 58-2221 provides in such cases only that the register of
deeds not record such instruments until he or she shall have
notified the grantee "where such notice is reasonably possible."
In the case of a document like the one presented to this office,
it is not clear who is the "grantee." It does not appear that
the apparent error language of K.S.A. 58-2221 is broad enough
to cover this situation. Thus we conclude, as did the cover
letter to Opinion No. 82-164 (which is also enclosed), that
where apparently spurious instruments are brought to a register
of deeds, the proper remedy cannot come from a refusal to file.
The party or parties filing such documents may be subject to
legal action and money damages, but such relief must come from
the courts.
Until a court has ruled on the effect of documents such as the
one you present, or until the legislature grants registers of
deeds the power to refuse to file such questionable documents,
the question of what to do with them is a most difficult one.
In the meantime we conclude that the result reached in Attorney
General Opinion No. 82-164 regarding "common law liens" is
equally applicable to documents to documents entitled "Land
Patent." Thus, a register of deeds is required to file of
record a written instrument whereby real estate may be affected.
Such instrument can properly be refused only if the instrument
contains apparent errors, or is not proved or acknowledged
and certified in the manner prescribed by law. A register of
deeds may also refuse to file instruments that clearly do not
affect real estate, or where the law requires some act, such
as payment of the mortgage registration fee, before the in-
strument may be received and filed of record.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mary F. Carson
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JSS:MFC:crw
encl.

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.