Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1984-024

1984-024Kanag

Full text

March 9, 1984
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 84- 24
Honorable Stephen R. Cloud
State Representative, Thirtieth District
Room 175-W, State Capitol
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Honorable Robert J. Vancrum
State Representative, Twenty-Ninth District
Room 115-S, State Capitol
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Honorable Ron Fox
State Representative, Twenty-First District
Room 155-E, State Capitol
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Public Utilities--Powers of State Corporation
Commission--Valuation of Utility Property by
Commission
Synopsis: Section 2 of 1984 House Bill No. 2927 (as amended
by House Committee of the Whole) would empower
the State Corporation Commission to exclude from
the rate base of .a public utility all or a portion
of costs of acquisition, construction or operating
which were incurred (in whole or in part) due to a
lack of efficiency or prudence, or costs incurred
in the acquisition or construction of excess capacity.
Such legislation, if enacted, could be enforced by
the State Corporation Commission and the courts of
this state. Cited herein: K.S.A. 66-128, 1984
House Bill No. 2927.
Dear Representatives Cloud, Vancrum and Fox:
You request our opinion as to the validity of Section 2 of
1984 House Bill No. 2927 (as amended by House Committee of
the Whole), a measure supported by each of you. Specifically,
you pose the following questions:
"(1) May the Legislature permit the State
Corporation Commission ('SCC') to exclude all
or a portion of the costs of acquisition,
construction or operating incurred due to a
lack of efficiency or prudence (Sec. 2 of the Act)?
"(2) May the Legislature permit the SCC to
exclude all or a portion of the costs of
acquisition incurred to build excess capacity
(Sec. 2 of the Act)?"
Section 2 of 1984 House Bill No. 2927 (as amended) provides as
follows:
"The state corporation commission, in deter-
mining the reasonable value of property under
K.S.A. 66-128, and amendments thereto, shall
have the power to evaluate the efficiency or
prudence of acquisition, construction or
operating practices of that utility. In the
event the state corporation commission deter-
mines that a portion of the costs of acquisition,
construction or operating were incurred due in
whole or in part to a lack of efficiency or
prudence, or were incurred in the acquisition
or construction of excess capacity, it shall
have the power and authority to exclude all or
a portion of those costs from such reasonable
value as so determined.
"For the purpose of this act, 'excess capacity'
means any capacity in excess of the amount
used and required to be used to provide adequate
and reliable service [to the public within the
state of Kansas] as determined by the commission.
The commission may in its discretion prohibit or
reduce the return on costs which were incurred
in constructing, maintaining or operating excess
capacity."
In regard to your first question, concerning exclusion from
the rate base of costs incurred due to lack of efficiency or
prudence, it should be noted that the State Corporation Commission
(commonly known as the K.C.C.) has historically had the duty,
pursuant to K.S.A. 66-128, to ascertain the reasonable value
of all property of a public utility used or required to be
used in services to the public, whenever the Commission deems
the ascertainment of such value necessary to enable it to fix
fair and reasonable rates. In the process of reviewing orders
of the K.C.C. (previously the Public Service Commission) involv-
ing public utility rates, the Kansas Supreme Court has indicated
that lack of efficiency or prudence is a legitimate consideration
in determining whether property should be included in the rate
base.
In State, ex rel. v. Telephone Co., 115 Kan. 236 (1924), a
case wherein the rate base of a public utility was contested,
the court, in the process of defining what constituted a
"reasonable rate," stated as follows:
"In this attempt at a definition, it has
been assumed that the telephone exchanges
in controversy have been built where they
were needed; that they have been properly
constructed; that they were economically
built; and that they have been well managed."
115 Kan. at 251.
In Southwestern Bell Tel. Co. v. State Corporation Commission, 192
Kan. 39, 65 (1963), the court held that, in determining a rate
base pursuant to K.S.A. 66-128, the K.C.C. "should receive and
consider all evidence which has a relevant bearing on reasonable
value of a company's property." Further, the court, in considering
the propriety of including in the rate base the cost of a plant
purchased by a public utility where the purchase price exceeded_
the original cost of the Plant less depreciation, indicated that
the K.C.C. could consider the prudence of the purchase. Specifically,
the court stated as follows:
"Where the reasonableness of the purchase price
is not questioned by the Commission, it should
be included in the rate base as the original
cost of the Company's property. It should be
understood, however, that where there is a
material difference between the cost to the
seller and the purchase price paid, the Com-
mission may consider the prudence of the purchase
and govern its allowance accordingly." (Emphasis
added.) 192 Kan. at 67.
Although we are unaware of any reported case wherein a Kansas
court has ruled upon the authority of the K.C.C. to consider,
in determining rate base, lack of prudence of a public utility
in constructing a plant, the legislature may, in our judgment,
resolve any uncertainty in this regard by expressly granting
such authority to the K.C.C. Thus, in response to the first
question set forth above, and in accordance with the pronounce-
ments of the Kansas Supreme Court in the Telephone Co. case and
the Southwestern Bell case, it is our opinion that the legislature
may grant regulatory authority to the State Corporation Commission
to exclude from the rate base of a public utility all or a
portion of costs of acquisition, construction or operating which
were incurred (in whole or in part) due to a lack of efficiency
or prudence.
In regard to your second question, the Kansas Supreme Court
has addressed, by way of dicta, the authority of the K.C.C. to
exclude, from the rate base, a facility, or segment thereof,
whose production is far in excess of present or near future
needs. Specifically, in Kansas Gas & Electric Co. v. State
Corporation Commission, 218 Kan. 670 (1976), the court reviewed
an order of the K.C.C. which excluded a portion (1/3) of the
reasonable value of a plant on the grounds that, due to
mechanical problems, it was operating at a low percentage of
capacity. The court held that the K.C.C. was not authorized,
under K.S.A. 66-128, to exclude a percentage of the utility
property since the Commission had found there to be significant
use of the plant, and had failed to find specifically that the
plant was not required to be used. However, the court qualified
its holding as follows:
"This is not to say that a unit or segment
of a facility that has become obsolete or
whose production is far in excess of present
or near future needs or for any valid reason,
is not used or required to be used and can
be set off or separated from a facility other-
wise used, cannot be excluded from the rate
base under the statute." (Emphasis added.)
218 Kan. at 674.
In accordance with the above-quoted authority, it is our opinion
that the legislature may grant regulatory authority to the
State Corporation Commission to exclude from the rate base
of a public utility all or a portion of costs of acquisition
or construction which were incurred in the acquisition or
construction of excess capacity.
Finally, it is appropriate to note several recent decisions
wherein state courts have indicated that excess capacity and
managerial imprudence may be considered in determining rate
base. In Park Towne v. Pennsylvania Public Utility Comm., 433
A.2d 610 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1981), the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
held that, where evidence supports findings of managerial
imprudence or other wrongdoing, plant construction costs found
to have been imprudent may be excluded from the rate base. The
same court ruled that generating units found to represent excess
generating capacity may be removed from the rate base. Philadelphia
Elec. v. Pa. Util. Comm., 433 A.2d 620 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1981). Further,
in Consumer's Counsel v. P.U.C., 423 N.E.2d 820 (Ohio Sup. Ct.
1981), the Ohio Supreme Court stated, by way of dicta, that if
a utility imprudently completed a project that should have been
abandoned, the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio was required
to disallow inclusion of such costs in the rate base and disallow
any claimed operating expenses related to the unnecessary project.
Although the above-cited decisions from other jurisdictions
are not controlling in Kansas, they indicate that ratepayers
need not bear costs associated with managerial imprudence and
excess capacity. In our judgment, legislation conveying such
authority could be enforced by the State Corporation Commission
and the courts of this state.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Terrence R. Hearshman
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:TRH:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.