Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1984-019

1984-019Kanag

Full text

February 17, 1984
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 84- 1 9
The Honorable Kenneth D. Francisco
State Representative, District 90
Kansas House of Representatives
Capitol
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: Counties and County Officers -- Planning and Zoning --
Adoption or Amendment of Zoning Regulations; Area
Included.
Synopsis: Under K.S.A. 19-2919 the decision to adopt zoning reg-
ulations for an entire county or "portions thereof" is
within the discretion of the county commissioners.
The language of K.S.A. 19-2919 which provides that a
resolution adopting zoning regulations "may" include
certain areas in the county is permissive and not ex-
clusive. The county may enact zoning regulations which
are applicable in any of the specified areas, in other
non-specified areas or in any combination thereof.
Cited herein: K.S.A. 12-701, 12-715, 12-715b, 12-715d,
K.S.A. 1983 Supp.
Dear Representative Francisco:
As State Representative for the 90th District you have requested an
Attorney General's opinion concerning certain county zoning statutes.
You indicate that a question has arisen among your constituents
regarding the ability of Sedgwick County to adopt zoning regula-
tions which cover all unincorporated areas of the county except
the three mile ring around certain cities which is presently reg-
ulated by city zoning authorities.
19-2901, 19-2913, 19-2914, 19-2919,
19-2920, 19-2926, 19-2927, 19-2937.
*
As you point out, the Kansas statutes make three types of zoning
available to counties. Under K.S.A. 19-2901 through 19-2913, a
county may zone all lands within any township in the county which
lie outside the limits of any incorporated city. Under K.S.A.
19-2914 through K.S.A. 19-2926 county-wide zoning is authorized.
K.S.A. 19-2927 through K.S.A. 19-2937 authorize county commis-
sioners of any county having a city of the first, second, or third
class located therein to adopt zoning regulations for the incor-
porated territory lying within three miles of any such city which
has established a city planning commission and has adopted a
zoning ordinance under the provisions of K.S.A. 12-701 et seq.
You indicate that Sedgwick County planning officials have recom-
mended county-wide zoning under K.S.A. 19-2914 through 19-2926
and that a question has arisen concerning whether the county may
except from county-wide zoning regulations the three mile area
surrounding the perimeter of any city which has chosen to zone
that area under the authority of K.S.A. 12-715 et seq.
In particular you inquire about the interpretation of K.S.A. 19-
2919(a) which provides in relevant part:
"For the purpose of promoting health, safety, morals,
comfort or the general welfare, and conserving and
protecting property values throughout the county or
portions thereof, the board of county commissioners
of any county may by resolution at a regular meet-
ing of the board, provide for the adoption, or a-
mendment, of zoning regulations in the manner pro-
vided by this act. . . .
Such resolution shall define the area to be gov-
erned by such zoning regulations and may include:
(1) All of the unincorporated area of the county,
or the unincorporated area of any township con-
taining or adjoining a city which has adopted a
zoning ordinance, or which may adopt a zoning
ordinance; (2) any lands within any township of
any county which lie outside the limits of any
incorporated city, upon recommendation and ap-
proval of the township board of the township;
(3) the unincorporated area lying within three
miles of any city having adopted a zoning or-
dinance; or (4) the unincorporated area lying
within three miles of the conservation pool
waterline of any existing or proposed artificial
impoundment of water exceeding 100 surface acres
at conservation pool level." (Emphasis added.)
You indicate that a local planning official has interpreted this
statute to mean that the county-wide zoning regulations must cover
one of the areas listed in the statute and that the county has no
discretion to exclude the three mile area surrounding a city if
the county chooses to adopt regulations covering all of the unin-
corporated area of the county. In our opinion this is an overly
strict interpretation of the statute. We note that K.S.A. 19-
2919 provides that a resolution adopted by the board of county
commissioners which established zoning regulations "shall define
the area to be governed by such zoning regulations and may in-
clude" certain defined areas. You inquire whether the word "may,"
as used in this context, should be read as mandatory and exclusive,
thus limiting the areas a county may zone to those listed in the
statute.
Ordinarily the word "may" as used in a statute is permissive
rather than peremptory. The word is sometimes regarded as synon-
ymous with "must" in cases where public authorities are authorized
to perform an act for the benefit of the public or for an in-
dividual who has a right to its performance. The word should
be given its ordinary, permissive meaning, however, unless the
terms and provisions of the statute compel another view. The
State v. School District No. 1 of Edwards County, 80 Kan. 667,
669 (1909).
The distinction between mandatory and directory provisions of
statutes has often been the subject of court decision. In Paul
v. City of Manhattan, 212 Kan. 381, 511 P.2d 244 (1973), the Kansas
Supreme Court discussed such provisions in the context of a city
zoning question and set out the following rules:
"In determining whether a legislative provision is
mandatory or directory, it is a general rule that
where strict compliance with the provision is es-
sential to the preservation of the rights of parties
affected and to the validity of the proceeding, the
provision is mandatory, but where the provision
fixes a mode of proceeding and a time within which
an official act is to be done, and is intended to
secure order, system and dispatch of the public
business, the provision is directory.
Factors which would indicate that a statute or or-
dinance is mandatory are: (1) the presence of neg-
ative words requiring that an act shall be done in
no other manner or at no other time than that des-
ignated, or (2) a provision for a penalty or other
consequence of noncompliance." (Syl. Ili 1,2)
See also Board of Lincoln County Commissioners v. Berner, 5 Kan.
App. 2d 104, 111, 623 P.2d 676 (1980).
The portions of K.S.A. 19-2919 at issue here are not provisions
which require strict compliance in order to preserve the rights
of the parties affected or to protect the validity of the pro-
ceedings. The decision to adopt zoning regulations for the entire
county or "portions thereof" is one left in the discretion of the
county commissioners. No individual is legally entitled to the
adoption of such regulations in certain specified areas. Further,
there is no language in the statute indicating that compliance
with the section at issue here is necessary to ensure the validity
of the proceedings. [Certain procedural portions of these statutes
may be regarded as affecting the validity of proceedings, for ex-
ample, the notice, protest, and hearing requirements found in
K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 19-2920. See, e.g. Koppel v. City of Fairway,
189 Kan. 710, 713, 371 P.2d 113 (1962).] Moreover, the statute
does not impose penalties or consequences for non-compliance with
the portions at issue here. Nor do the relevant portions contain
negative words requiring that the zoning regulations cover only
those areas listed in K.S.A. 19-2919.
In our opinion the language of K.S.A. 19-2919 which indicates that
a county resolution adopting zoning regulations "may" include cer-
tain areas is permissive and non-exclusive. The county may zone
in any of the specified areas, in other non-specified areas or in
any combination thereof. We note that some of the areas specified
in the statute are those about which there could be some conflict
over who is the proper authority to adopt and enforce zoning regu-
lations. K.S.A. 19-2919 simply makes it clear that the county's
authority to zone in the county takes precedence over the other
entities which may enjoy some jurisdictional authority over portions
of the county. We do not read the statute to require that county
zoning regulations be applicable only to one of the areas listed.
Thus, in our opinion, Sedgwick County may adopt county-wide zoning
regulations which exempt the three mile area surrounding the peri-
meter of any city which has chosen to zone that area under the
authority of K.S.A. 12-715 et seq.
The combination of city and county zoning authority over the three
mile perimeter of any city has been the subject of previous at-
torney general opinions and is discussed in many of the relevant
statutes. For example, if Sedgwick County should decide to zone
in the three mile area surrounding a city which has adopted a
zoning ordinance such action is subject to protest. K.S.A. 1983
Supp. 19-2920 provides in part:
"If a written protest against the proposed zoning
or rezoning of any land lying within three miles
of the city limits of any municipality having a
zoning ordinance is received from the governing
body of the city, the county commissioners shall
not adopt the proposed zoning of the land except
by a vote of all members which shall be recorded
in the minutes of the meeting along with a state-
ment of the reason for the action."
The statutory authority which permits the city to extend its zon-
ing regulations to include the three mile area outside the city
limits is K.S.A. 12-715b. That statute places certain prereq-
uisites upon the exercise of that power including a requirement
stated in 12-715b(c) that "the county or township does not have
in effect zoning regulations for such area outside the city but
within three (3) miles thereof. . . ." In addition, K.S.A. 12-
715d provides:
"This act [*] is supplemental to the provisions
of the laws of this state which authorize counties
to adopt zoning regulations for all or any part of
the land located within the county and outside of
any incorporated city, which laws are specifically
K.S.A. 19-2901 to 19-2937, inclusive, and amend-
ments thereto. Existing city zoning regulations
and the authority of any city to adopt zoning
regulations for land located outside the city
but within three (3) miles thereof shall cease and
terminate on the date the county or township places
in effect zoning regulations which are in reasonable
conformance with a comprehensive plan and have
been adopted in conformity with the appropriate
statutes set forth in this section."
Thus the city zoning regulations in the three mile zone remains
effective until the county places regulations in effect. If the
county chooses not to zone that area, the city retains the author-
ity under K.S.A. 12-715b to extend regulations into the area.
The inaction of the county in zoning this area prejudices its right
to zone thereafter only to the extent that they continue not to
act. See Attorney General Opinion No. 75-214. The county, when
it acts under K.S.A. 19-2919, however, is not required to in-
clude the three mile area in county-wide zoning regulations.
We conclude, that that under K.S.A. 19-2919 the decision to adopt
zoning regulations for an entire county or "portions thereof" is
within the discretion of the board of county commissioners. The
language of K.S.A. 19-2919 which provides that a resolution ad-
opting zoning regulations "may" include certain areas in the
county is permissive and not exclusive. The county may enact
zoning regulations which are applicable in any of the specified
areas, in other non-specified areas or in any combination there-
of.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mary P. Carson
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:MFC:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.