Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1984-010

1984-010Kanag

Full text

February 8, 1984
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 84- 10
The Honorable Norman E. Justice
State Representative, Thirty-Fourth District
Room 279-W, State Capitol
Topeka, Kansas 66612
Re: State Departments; Public Officers, Employees --
Kansas Open Meetings Act -- Application of Act to
Non-Profit Corporation (Community Action Agency)
Synopsis: The Kansas Open Meetings Act is applicable to meet-
ings of the Board of Trustees of the Economic Opportun-
ity Foundation, Inc., and such meetings must be open
to the public. Cited herein: K.S.A. 75-3036, 75-3734,
K.S.A. 75-4317, K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 75-4318, 42 U.S.C.A.
§2790, 42 U.S.C.A. §6861, 42 U.S.C.A. §9901, 42
U.S.C.A. §9904.
Dear Representative Justice:
As a state representative and a board member of the Economic
Opportunity Foundation, Inc. (EOF), you request our opinion con-
cerning the applicability of the Kansas Open Meetings Act (KOMA),
K.S.A. 75-4317 et seq., to the EOF.
The EOF was established by members of a committee created by a
joint resolution of the city commission of Kansas City, Kansas,
and the Board of County Commissioners of Wyandotte County, Kansas,
in October, 1964 (Joint Resolution Nos. 19043 and 680) to combat
poverty at the local level in connection with the Economic Op-
portunity Act of 1964 (42 U.S.C.A. §2790 et seq.). On January 13,
1965, three members of the committee incorporated the EOF as a
non-profit community action corporation. See Articles of Incor-
poration of Economic Opportunity Foundation, Inc. The EOF was
formally designated as an official community action agency for
purposes of the Economic Opportunity Act of 1964 by Joint Resol-
ution Nos. 20901 and 839 on June 20, 1968. The EOF sponsors
and directs numerous programs for low-income families (see the
Annual Report 1981-1982 of the Economic Opportunity Foundation,
Inc.) and receives in addition to private funds, county, state
and federal moneys for implementation of its programs.
The EOF is governed by a 30 person board of trustees. The Board
is composed of 10 representatives of the various city and county
governmental representatives (who serve at the pleasure of the
governmental officials), 8 representatives of local private sector
organizations and 12 representatives elected at large by the
residents of designated low-income areas. Bylaws of the Economic
Opportunity Foundation, Inc., revised September 1982. (See also
42 U.S.C.A. §9904.)
Your question concerns whether the Board of Trustees, in the
conduct of its monthly meetings, is subject to the provisions
contained in the KOMA. K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 75-4318 reads in
pertinent part as follows:
"all meetings for the conduct of the affairs of,
and the transaction of business by, all legislative
and administrative bodies and agencies of the state
and political and taxing subdivisions thereof, in-
cluding boards, commissions, authorities, councils,
committees, subcommittees and other subordinate
groups thereof, receiving or expending and supported
in whole or in part by public funds shall be open
to the public and no binding action by such bodies
shall be by secret ballot . . . ."
In order to determine whether the EOF is subject to this act,
we must apply the following two-part test: Is this community
action agency a legislative or administrative body of state
or local government and is it supported in whole or in part by
public funds. See Kansas Attorney General Opinion Nos. 79-219
and 79-284.
The term "public agency" is not defined in the Kansas open meet-
ings law. However, prior Kansas Attorney General opinions have
identified four criteria to be used in determining whether a
body is a public agency:
"1) If the agency has the authority to make govern-
mental decisions and act for the state, it is covered
by an open meetings law. If it only collects infor-
mation, makes recommendations or renders advice, it
is not. McLarty v. Board of Regents, 231 Ga. 22,
200 S. E. 2d 117, 119 (1973).
2) Does the agency have independent authority in
the exercise of its functions? Soucie v. David, 440
F. 2d. 1067 (D.C. Cir. 1971).
3) Is the agency subject to governmental audits
or otherwise have its business procedures super-
vised? Rocap v. Indiek, 539 F. 2d. 174, (D.C. Cir.
1976).
4) Finally, one court has defined 'governmental
agency' to include corporate instrumentalities
that accomplish public ends, both governmental
and proprietary. Ratan Public Service Co. v.
Hobbes, 76 N.M. 535, 417 P.2d 32 (1966)." Kansas
Attorney General Opinion Nos. 79-219 pp. 3, 4,
79-284 p. 3.
Our office has had at least four recent occasions to consider the
application of the KOMA to corporations related to government and
receiving public funds. In Kansas Attorney General Opinion No.
79-221 we concluded that a private nursing home was not subject
to the state open meetings law as it did not exercise any powers
of state or local government and its directors were not appointed
by a government agency. Planned Parenthood of South-Central
Kansas, Inc., was considered to be a private, non-profit cor-
poration and thus not subject to the KOMA because there was so
little control exercised by the county oveheorate oper-
ations. Kansas Attorney General Opinion No. 81-253 at 6. Like-
wise, the Kansas Cosmosphere and Discovery Center, Inc., was
outside the scope of the open meetingcounty tprofitedhe corpor-
ation did not administer a government program for which the
county would otherwise be responsible, the corporate directors
were not appointed by government and the counon-profited no
control over the corporation activities. Kansas Attorney Gen-
eral Opinion No. 82-256.
On the other hand, McPherson County Diversified Services, Inc.,
a privately organized non-"profit corporation, is subject to
the KOMA. Kansas Attorney General Opinion No. 79-284. There
the Board of County Commissioners confirmed all appointments to
the corporate board of directors, and required reporting on
programs that otherwise would have been carried out by the county
itself.
In our judgment EOF is similar to this latter situation. First,
federal law specifies that "any non-profit private organization
receiving assistance under this chapter [of the Economic Oppor-
tunity Act of 1964] which has responsibility for planning, devel-
oping and coordinating community anti-poverty programs shall be
deemed to be a State or local agency." 42 U.S.C.A. §9904(e).
See also Part C §8(h) of the Department of Social and Rehabil-
itation Services, State Economic Opportunity office, Procedure
Manual for the Community Services Block Grant Program.
Second, the corporation was established by joint resolutions of
members of the Wyandotte County Commission and the city commis-
sioners of Kansas City, Kansas in order to coordinate local anti-
poverty programs to be funded by the federal government. Such
functions would have been performed by the city and county but for
the creation of this new corporation.
Thirdly, the county commission and city commissions of the re-
spective cities located within the county continue to appoint
one-third of the corporation's board of directors and thereby
exercise considerable control and influence over the activities
of the corporation.
Finally, the corporation is subject to reviews and audits by
the State Economic Opportunity Office (SEOO) of the Kansas De-
partment of Social and Rehabilitation Services. The EOF must
provide a monthly fiscal report to the SEOO and must submit
quarterly program reports to the SEOO. See Procedure Manual,
supra, Part E.
Nothing in the information we have been able to gather regarding
EOF suggests that the corporation is fundamentally a private
entity which merely contracts with public bodies to deliver
services for a fee. Instead, all indicia suggest that the
corporation is indeed a functional arm of city-county government,
and therefore, is to be viewed as an administrative body or
agency within the meaning of the KOMA.
In applying the second part of the test, we find that the term
"public funds" is not defined in the KOMA, however, many sources
of funds have been considered to fall within this, definition.
See Open Meetings Profile; The Prosecutors View, Smoot and
Clothier, 20 W.L.J. 241, 255, 256 (1981). The EOF receives
many different types of funding for its programs. While it is
not necessary to examine each and every source, suffice it to
say that in addition to the local county mill levy that the
corporation receives directly (.17% of its total budget), the
EOF receives federal funds pursuant to 42 U.S.C.A. §9901 et seq.,
and 42 U.S.0 A. §6861 et seq. Under these federal programs, each
state is allocated a certain percentage of the total federal funds
available. These funds are placed in the state treasury pursuant
to K.S.A. 75-3734. When distributed by SRS to the local agencies,
these funds are considered state funds. K.S.A 75-3036.
Upon reviewing the fiscal characteristics of the EOF, we find
that 36% of its total funding is funneled through the state.
Forty-three percent of its budget comes directly to EOF for cer-
tain programs but we find no indication that this money is any-
thing but public funds. (See 1983 Budget of EOF.) Hence, we
have no hesitency in concluding that the EOF receives public
funds within the meaning of the Kansas Open Meetings Act. There-
fore, it is our opinion that the Kansas Open Meetings Act is
applicable to meetings of the Board of Trustees of the Economic
Opportunity Foundation, Inc., and such meetings must be open to
the public.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Matthew W. Boddington
Assistant Attorney General
cc: Honorable Cordell Meeks, Jr.
Connie Hadley
RTS:BJS:MWB:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.