Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1984-004

1984-004Kanag

Full text

January 27, 1984
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 84- 4
Marvin R. Webb
Director
Grain Inspection Department
P.O. Box 1918
Topeka, Kansas 66601
RE: Grain and Forage, Grain Storage; Terminal and
Local Warehouses -- Public Warehouseman, License:
Application -- Financial Statements
Synopsis: Kansas law requires applicants for a public grain
warehouse license to submit to the state Grain
Inspection Department a certified financial state-
ment. When the applicant is a wholly-owned sub-
sidiary of another company, a certified financial
statement of the parent company which does not
separately identify at least, a current balance
sheet, a statement of income (profit and loss),
a statement of retained earnings and a statement
of retained earnings of the applicant is in-
adequate. Even the inclusion of a guarantee agree-
ment for the benefit of the state does not cure
the defect where the agreement does not expressly
purport to protect the rights or interests of
creditors or depositors of the applicant. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 34-228, 34-229, L 1983,
ch. 137 § 1.
Dear Mr. Webb:
You have requested our opinion concerning whether the parent
corporation of an applicant for a public warehouseman license
may submit the parent company's certified financial statement
to satisfy the requirements of K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 34-228.
We are advised that the Smoot Grain Company seeks a license
to operate a public warehouse in this state. Pursuant to
statute, it has remitted the appropriate fees and submitted
a certified financial statement of its parent company,
Archer-Daniels-Midway (ADM). You ask our opinion whether
this financial statement and accompanying guaranty satisfy
the statutory requirements.
K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 34-228 et seq., sets out the requirements
for a license. Among other things, the statute requires in
part that:
"Every application for a public warehouse
license shall be accompanied by a current
financial statement. The statement shall in-
clude such information as required by the
director to administer and enforce the public
warehouse laws of this state, including but
not limited to a current balance sheet, state-
ment of income (profit and loss), statement
of retained earnings and statement of changes
in financial position. The applicant shall
certify under oath that the statement as pre-
pared accurately reflects the financial condi-
tion of the applicant as of the date specified
and presents fairly the results of operations
of the applicant's public warehouse business
for the period specified." (Emphasis added.)
K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 34-228.
In this case the applicant is the Smoot Grain Company, but
the financial statement is that of ADM.
General corporation case law states that "[a] holding or
parent company has a separate corporate existence and is
treated separately from its subsidiary in the absence of
circumstances justifying disregard of the corporate entity."
Service Iron Foundry, Inc. v. M.A. Bell Co., 2 Kan.App.2d
662, 673 (1978). See also, Quarles v. Fuqua Industries, Inc.,
504 Fed.2d 1358, 1362 (D. Kan. 1974).
In the absence of evidence to the contrary, Smoot Grain and
ADM must be viewed as separate and distinct companies, even
though Smoot Grain is a wholly-owned subsidiary of ADM. In
regard to the financial statements of both companies, we are
advised that ADM prepares its financial statement based upon
all the profits and losses of all its subsidiary companies.
It does not break the statements down to distinguish the
status of each subsidiary, nor does each subsidiary prepare
an individual financial statement.
In an effort to satisfy the provisions of K.S.A. 1983 Supp.
34-228, ADM executed a guaranty agreement to the state of
Kansas that:
"Archer-Daniels-Midland Company, in consider-
ation of the waiver of the State of Kansas of
its requirements that the Smoot Grain Company
and each of its subsidiary corporations pro-
vide an individual financial statement, will
guarantee the prompt payment of such sum or
sums of money as may at any time hereafter
become due and owing to the State of Kansas
from the Smoot Grain Company or any of its
subsidiary corporations . . . ." Guaranty
Agreement of Archer-Daniels-Midland Company,
paragraph 2, dated September 27, 1983.
First, contrary to the assumption expressed in the ADM
guarantee, Kansas law does not grant, either expressly or by
reasonable implication, the authority to the Grain Inspection
Department to "waive" the required financial statement. The
complete financial statement of each separate warehouse is
required. Moreover, the 1983 Kansas Legislature amended this
provision to provide greater specificity by designating just
which financial information is to be required. See L. 1983,
ch. 137 § 1.
Second, the guarantee, by its own terms, is not broad enough
to protect creditors and depositors of grain in the applicant's
warehouse. Indeed, the guarantee is less comprehensive than
the surety bond required by K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 34-229 which
provides that the bond "shall be in favor of the state of
Kansas for the benefit of all persons interested, their legal
representatives, attorneys or assigns."
Finally, the financial statement of ADM does not disclose the
assets of Smoot Grain which could be reached by creditors or
depositors in the event of default. We have nothing in the
records submitted to us to indicate that the entire assets of
ADM are available to satisfy the obligations of the sub-
sidiary corporation. It is, of course, the depositors and
creditors of the grain elevator licensee which the legislature
sought to protect by these statutory requirements and without
such disclosures, we cannot conclude that the financial statement
and accompanying guarantee satisfy Kansas law.
Several possibilities exist that may rectify the problem.
ADM may become the applicant, modified guaranty statements
may be executed or changes may be made in the law. However
absent such alterations, we have little hesitancy in con-
cluding that when an applicant for a public warehouse license
is a wholly-owned subsidiary of another company, and the
parent company issues a guaranty agreement on behalf of its
subsidiary to the state of Kansas for the payment only of
the applicant's debts to the state, and which does not
expressly purport to protect the rights and interests of
the creditors and depositors of the grain elevator, the
applicant's submission of its parent company's certified
financial statement and guaranty statement do not satisfy
the statutory requirements of K.S.A. 1983 Supp. 34-228.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
Matthew W. Boddington
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:MWB:crw

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.