Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-179

1983-179Kanag

Full text

December 15, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 179
Philip E. Winter
Assistant Lyon County Attorney
Lyon County Courthouse
Emporia, Kansas 66801
Re: Cities and Municipalities -- Plats of Cities and
Townsites; Title to Lands Platted as Public Squares;
Responsibility of County Concerning Such Lands
Synopsis: The title to property designated as a "public
square" in a plat, filed and recorded pursuant to
K.S.A. 12-401 et seq., vests in the county for-
ever, to be held in trust for the public. There
are no statutes authorizing the county to vacate
such property absent a request from a city govern-
ing body or adjoining landowners. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 12-401, 12-403, 12-406, 12-411, 12-504,
K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 58-2613, K.S.A. 58-2615.
* *
Dear Mr. Winter:
As Assistant Lyon County Attorney you have requested an
Attorney General Opinion concerning certain property in Lyon
County which has been platted as a "public square." Your
inquiries concern an area in Lyon County known as Plymouth,
which you advise was platted a number of years ago and always
has been sold as platted. Plymouth has never established a
city government and remains an unincorporated part of the
county. Two areas within the Plymouth plat are designated
as "public squares" and apparently certain individuals re-
siding in the area desire to use the property for that pur-
pose. You inquire on behalf of Lyon County about the extent
of the county's responsibility with regard to these "public
squares". Specifically, you ask whether the county holds
the property so platted in trust for the public purpose desig-
nated on the plats and whether there is a procedure by which
such property may be vacated by the county.
The statutes pertaining to plats of cities and townsites
appear at K.S.A. 12-401 et seq. K.S.A. 12-401 provides in
relevant part:
"Before any 'proprietor or proprietors of any
proposed city of the second or third class or -
of any town, or of any proposed addition to
any such city or town shall record the plat
of such proposed city, town or addition, he
or she shall furnish to the county attorney
of the county in which such proposed city or
town is located, or the city attorney and
governing body in case of a proposed addition,
an abstract of title and the plat to the land
which is to be incorporated into such city,
town or addition. Such county attorney, in
case of any proposed city or town, or such
city attorney and governing body in case of a
proposed addition, after examination duly
made, shall approve or disapprove said plat.
"The plat shall accurately and particularly
set forth and describe: First, all the par-
cels of ground within such city or town or
addition reserved for public purposes, by
their boundaries, course and extent whether
they be intended for avenues, streets, lanes,
alleys, commons, parks or other uses; and,
second, all lots intended for sale, by num-
bers, and their precise length and width."
(Emphasis added.)
K.S.A. 12-403 provides that such a plat shall be recorded
with the register of deeds in the county where the city or
townsite is located. K.S.A. 12-406 concerns land conveyed
or platted for public use and provides in relevant part:
"Such maps and plats of such cities and towns,
and additions, made, acknowledged, certified,
filed and recorded with the register, shall
be a sufficient conveyance to vest the fee of
such parcels of land as are therein expressed,
named or intended for public uses in the
county in which such city or town or addition
is situated, in trust and for the uses there-
in named, expressed or intended, and for no
other use or purpose. . . . The provisions of
this act shall apply to all maps or plats,
heretofore or hereafter made, acknowledged,
certified, filed and recorded with any such
register. -" (Emphasis added.)
If the Plymouth plats were filed in accordance with these
statutes, the filed and recorded plats are sufficient to
vest in the county title to the land intended for public use.
A number of Kansas cases have discussed land platted for pub-
lic use under these statutes. The general rule is that the
fee title to lands platted or designated for public-use vests
in the county to hold in trust for the public purpose while
control of such property vests in the city. For example, in
City of Council Grove v. Ossman, 219 Kan. 120 (1976), the
court said:
"The fee title to all property intended for
public use vests in the county in trust for
the public by virtue of K.S.A. 12-406. The
authority to control, use and improve the
streets is vested in the city. (Citations
omitted.) The dedicators no longer have title
to property dedicated for public use once a
plat has been approved filed and recorded.
The fee title vests in the county forever."
(p. 411, emphasis added.) See also State ex
rel., v. City of Manhattan, 115 Kan. 794
(1924); J & S Building Co. v. Columbian Title
& Trust Co., 1 Kan.App.2d 228,234 (1977).
We can find no provision or indication in the statutes or in
applicable case law to the effect that this general policy is
changed because the platted area remains in an unincorporated
portion of the county. Thus, in response to your first in-
quiry, it is our conclusion that the county holds title to
the duly platted and recorded areas know as "public squares"
in Plymouth in trust for the public purpose designated on the
plats.
Your second inquiry asks whether there is any procedure whereby
the county may vacate the property. You indicate in your
letter that certain persons desire to use the property platted
as a public square for that purpose. Since that use would be
consistent with the designation on the plat it is unclear
why the county would wish to vacate the property. In any
event, it appears that the county alone may not vacate such
property. First, we note there are objections to such actions
as a matter of policy. In Cooper v. City of Great Bend, 200
Kan. 590, 594 (1968), the court discussed a city's efforts
to vacate certain portions of a public square surrounding the
county courthouse in order to utilize the land for a parking
lot. Referring to K.S.A. 12-401; 12-406 and 12-411 the court
said:
"These statutes have always been construed to
mean that when public grounds, such as market
squares and public squares, are dedicated by
city plat the legal title vests in the county
in trust for the public, while possession,
dominion and control are vested in the city, -
and further that when property is so dedicated
for a specific purpose it cannot ordinarily be
put to any other use." (Emphasis added.)
Second, our research has failed to disclose any statutes which
authorize the county, acting independently, to vacate property
which it holds title to in trust for a public purpose. Such
a vacation would be inconsistent with the policy expressed
in the cases discussed above. We note, however, that under
K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 58-2613 the owners of platted land which
adjoins on both sides of any street, alley, public easement,
or public reservation, or part thereof and which lies outside
the limits of any incorporated city or within the limits of
an incorporated city which has no governing body for 10 years
or more, may petition the board of county commissioners seeking
to have the land vacated. Upon hearing and after determining
that the public will not suffer loss or inconvenience, the
board of county commissioners may order vacation of the pro-
perty. K.S.A. 58-2613 is an act supplemental to all other
statutes providing for the vacation of plats and appears
most applicable to the situation described in your opinion
request. The statutes governing the vacation of plats within
cities are found at K.S.A. 12-504 et seq. Those statutes
make similar provisions for the vacation of property platted
for a particular purpose upon the request of a city governing
body or adjoining landowner.
We conclude that the title to property designated as a "pub-
lic square" in a plat, filed and recorded pursuant to K.S.A.
12-401 et seq., vests in the county forever, to be held in
trust for the public. There are no statutes authorizing the
county to vacate such property absent a request from a city
governing body or adjoining landowners.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mary 'F. Carson
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:MFC:hle

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.