Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-175

1983-175Kanag

Full text

November 28, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83- 175
Robert G. Suelter
Great Bend City Attorney
City Building
P.O. Box 1168
Great Bend, Kansas 67530
Re: Taxation--Property Exempt from Taxation--Business
Aircraft
Synopsis: K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-201k, which exempts aircraft
used actually, regularly and exclusively in business
or industry from property or ad valorem taxes, is
not unconstitutional as a matter of law on the
ground that the law lacks a rational basis. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-201k, Kan. Const.,
Bill of Rights §1, U.S. Const., Amend. XIV.
*
Dear Mr. Suelter:
As legal counsel for the city of Great Bend, you seek our
opinion on the constitutionality of the property tax exemption
granted by the provisions of K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-201k. This
statute provides:
"(a) It is the purpose of this section to
promote, stimulate and develop the general
welfare, economic development and prosperity
of the state of Kansas by fostering the
growth of commerce within the state; to
encourage the location of new business and
industry in this state and the expansion,
relocation or retention of existing business
and industry when so doing will help main-
tain or increase the level of commerce within
the state; and to promote the economic stability
of the state by maintaining and providing
employment opportunities, thus promoting the
general welfare of the citizens of this state,
by exempting aircraft used in business and
industry, from imposition of the property tax
or other ad valorem tax imposed by this state
or its taxing subdivisions. Kansas has long
been a leader in the manufacture and use of
aircraft and the use of aircraft in business
and industry is vital to the continued economic
growth of the state.
"(b) The following described property, to the
extent herein specified, is hereby exempt
from all property or ad valorem taxes levied
under the laws of the state of Kansas:
"First. For all taxable years commencing after
December 31, 1982, all aircraft actually and
regularly used exclusively in the conduct of
a business or industry."
The exemption prescribed by these provisions is commonly referred
to as "the business aircraft exemption." The exemption was
enacted by the 1982 Legislature and became effective for tax
years 1983 and thereafter. See L. 1982, ch. 390, §4.
In your letter of inquiry, you question whether there is a
rational basis upon which the legislature could have concluded
that this exemption would promote the general welfare. If
not, the law would violate the due process clause of the
Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution and
Section 1 of the Bill of Rights of the Kansas Constitution,
each of which protects persons residing in this state from
arbitrary governmental action. See, e.g., Baker v. List and
Clark Construction Co., 222 Kan. 127, 134 (1977) and Manzanares v.
Bell, 214 Kan. 589, Sy. 115 (1974). However, to successfully
challenge this tax exemption statute on this ground, it would
be necessary to convince the courts that the legislature could
have had no reasonable basis for believing this exemption would
accomplish the public purposes expressed in subsection (a) of
the statute. See, e.g., State ex rel. Tomasic v. Kansas City,
Kansas Port Authority, 230 Kan. 404, 413 (1981) and State ex rel. v.
Board of Regents, 167 Kan. 587, 596 (1949). In addition, in any
case where the legislative judgment is drawn into question, the
inquiry will be restricted to the issue of whether any state
of facts, either known or which could reasonably be assumed,
affords support for the act. See State ex rel. v. Sage Stores
Co., 157 Kan. 404 (1943) and the numerous cases cited therein
at 413.
In any constitutional challenge of this statute, certain basic
principles would be applied by the court. These principles
are stated in City of Baxter Springs v. Bryant, 226 Kan. 383,
Syl. ¶111-4 (1979) , as follows:
"The constitutionality of a statute is
presumed, all doubts must be resolved in
favor of its validity, and before the
statute may be stricken down, it must clearly
appear the statute violates the constitution.
"In determining constitutionality, it is the
court's duty to uphold a statute under attack
rather than defeat it and, if there is any
reasonable way to construe the statute as
constitutionality valid, that should be done.
"Statutes are not stricken down unless the in-
fringement of the superior law is clear beyond
substantial doubt.
"The propriety, wisdom, necessity and expedi-
ence of legislation are exclusively matters
for legislative determination and courts will
not invalidate laws, otherwise constitutional,
because the members of the court do not consider
the statute in the public interest of the state,
since, necessarily, what the views of members
of the court may be upon the subject are wholly
immaterial and it is not the province nor the
right of courts to determine the wisdom of
legislation touching the public interest as
that is a legislative function with which courts
cannot interfere."
Also, in State ex rel. Tomasic v. Kansas City, Kansas Port
Authority, supra, the Supreme Court quoted with approval its
prior determination in Gunkle v. Killingsworth, 118 Kan. 154,
157 (1925) that:
"Within the scope of legislative power, the
legislature itself is the judge of what
exemptions are in the public interest and
will conduce to the public welfare." 230
Kan. at 412.
Due to the presumption of validity of legislative acts, the
burden of proof required to overcome this presumption and the
last quoted statement of the Kansas Supreme Court, we sincerely
doubt that a challenge to this statute on the ground asserted
in your inquiry would be successful. Regardless of our beliefs,
however, our opinion in response to your inquiry is that we
certainly cannot state, as a matter of law, that the legislature
could have had no rational basis for believing this exemption
would accomplish the public purposes prescribed in the statute
and, thus, promote the public welfare. Therefore, it is our
opinion that K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-201k, which exempts aircraft
used actually, regularly and exclusively in business or industry
from property or ad valorem taxes, is not unconstitutional as a
matter of law on the ground that the law lacks a rational
basis.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Rodney J. Bieker
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:RJB:jm

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.