Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1983-144

1983-144Kanag

Full text

September 21, 1983
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 83 - 144
The Honorable Frank D. Gaines
State Senator, Sixteenth District
P. 0. Box 219
Augusta, Kansas 67010
Re: Taxation -- Retailers' Sales Tax -- Exemptions;
Property Consumed in Process of Production
Synopsis: The sale of acid which is used to treat a salt
water disposal well, which well is utilized in
the process of oil production, is exempt from
the Kansas Retailers' Sales Tax Act under the
provisions of K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3602(m) and
79-3606(n). Cited herein: K.S.A. 1982 Supp.
79-3602(m), 79-3606(n).
*
Dear Senator Gaines:
You seek our opinion concerning the applicability of the
exemption prescribed in K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3606(n) to the
sale of acid which is used to treat salt water disposal wells,
which wells are utilized in the process of oil production.
The statute about which you inquire provides, in relevant
part:
"The following shall be exempt from the tax
imposed by this act . . .
"(n) all sales of tangible personal property
which is consumed in the production, manufac-
ture, processing, mining, drilling, refining
or compounding of tangible personal property,
the providing of services or the irrigation
of crops for ultimate sale at retail within
or without the state of Kansas; and any pur-
chaser of such property may obtain from the
director of taxation and furnish to the sup-
plier an exemption certificate number for
tangible personal property for consumption in
such production, manufacture, processing,
mining, drilling, refining, compounding, irri-
gation and in providing such services." (Em-
phasis added.)
In reference to this exemption, the legislature, in K.S.A.
1982 Supp. 79-3602(m), defines the phrase "property which is
consumed," as follows:
"'Property which is consumed' means tangible
personal property which is essential or nec-
essary to and which is used in the actual
process of and immediately consumed or dissi-
pated in (1) the production, manufacture,
processing, mining, drilling, refining or
compounding of tangible personal property,
(2) the providing of services or (3) the ir-
rigation of crops, for sale in the regular
course of business, and which is not reusable
for such purpose. The following items of
tangible personal property are hereby declared
to be 'consumed' but the listing of such pro-
perty shall not be deemed to be exclusive
nor shall such listing be construed to be a
restriction upon or an indication of, the
type or types of property to be included
within the definition of 'property which is
consumed' as herein set forth:
"(1) Insecticides, herbicides, germicides,
pesticides, fungicides, antibiotics, biolo-
gicals, pharmaceuticals, vitamins and chemi-
cals for use in commercial or agricultural
production of fruit, vegetables, feeds, seeds,
animals or animal products whether fed, in-
jected, applied or otherwise used; and
"(2) Electricity, gas and water."
You indicate that the State Department. of Revenue allows the
exemption for the sale of acid which is used to treat wells
producing oil, but does not allow the exemption for the sale
of acid which is used to treat salt water disposal wells. You
believe this is an unjustified interpretation of the statute,
since the treating of salt water disposal wells is as integral
a part of the process of producing oil as the treatment of
producing wells. We concur.
While it is axiomatic that tax exemption provisions are to
be construed strictly [see Topeka Cemetery Ass'n v. Schnellbacher,
218 Kan. 39, 42 (1975)] and this rule applies to exemptions
granted in the Kansas Retailers' Sales Tax Act [see Warren v.
Fink, 146 Kan. 716 (1937)], it also is settled that the
"strict construction" rule does not warrant an "unreasonable
construction." See, e.g., Trustees of The United Methodist
Church v. Cogswell, 205 Kan. 847, Syl. ¶2 (1970). Moreover,
the Kansas Supreme Court has held that the rule of strict
construction simply means that ordinary words are to be given
their ordinary meaning and a statute subject to strict con-
struction should not be read to add that which is not readily
found within it or to read out what, as a matter of ordinary
English language, is in it. See State v. Finley, 199 Kan.
615 (1967).
The exemption provided in K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3606(m) con-
cerns "property which is consumed" in, among other things,,
the production of tangible personal property. The phrase
"property which is consumed" is legislatively defined as
tangible personal property which is "used in the actual process
of . . . the production . . . of tangible personal property."
(Emphasis added.) K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 79-3602(m).
In R. L. Polk & Co. v. Armold, 215 Kan. 653 (1974), the
Director of Revenue, predecessor to the Director of Taxation,
denied a sales tax exemption in regard to certain items of
tangible personal property which were used and consumed in
the taxpayer's manufacturing process. One basis upon which
the Director denied the exemption was his belief that "the
processes wherein the materials were consumed were preliminary
to the manufacturing." Id. at 656. The Court rejected this
reasoning, since the processes were part of "an integrated
manufacturing operation." Id. at 656. The Court labeled
the Director's interpretation of the exemption language
too "narrow." Id. at 656.
Like the "integrated manufacturing operation" involved in
Armold, supra, the production of oil involves an integrated
production process, one phase of which is the proper disposal
of salt water produced in conjunction with the production of
oil. In fact, this phase of the production process is man-
dated by state law. See K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 55-901 et seq.
and K.S.A. 55-1003. Without the proper disposal of such salt
water, production must cease. K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 55-904(a)(1).
The legislative mandate concerning the proper disposal of
salt water "produced in conjunction with the production of
oil or natural gas" [K.S.A. 1982 Supp. 55-904(a)(1)], makes
clear to us that such disposal is an integral part of the
process of the production of oil and natural gas. Therefore,
we are of the opinion that tangible personal property which
is used in this phase of the production process is within the
language of this sales tax exemption.
Therefore, we are of the opinion that the sale of acid which
is used to treat a salt water disposal well, which well is
utilized in the process of oil production, is exempt from the
Kansas Retailers' Sales Tax Act under the provisions of K.S.A.
1982 Supp. 79-3602(m) and 79-3606(n).
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rodney J. Bieker
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:BJS:RJB:hle

Continue your research in ChatGPT or Claude

Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.